What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2017 R22 Sun - Panthers 28-14 Wests Tigers @ Pepper

Round 22: Panthers v Wests Tigers


  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
I think danger game for the Panthers with Merrin, Latu definitely out and more than likely to be without Moylan and James Fisher Harris. Certainly down on troops in such a crucial game.
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
25,427
I think danger game for the Panthers with Merrin, Latu definitely out and more than likely to be without Moylan and James Fisher Harris. Certainly down on troops in such a crucial game.

You're playing the team coming 15th who are missing 5 of their best starting 13 from the start of the year. Missing a lock and bench prop don't exactly cut it as an excuse if you lose.
 

2010Dragons

Bench
Messages
4,038
Warning to all West Tigers fans:
Hometown referee Gavin Badger and his novice puppet Ziggy will favour the Panthers with every DODGY 50-50 calls going to the hometown.
They will punish the West Tigers in the penalty count and won't be accountable for the injustice !
This is the way Badger does things.
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
25,427
Good luck with those 2 home town muppets controlling the game.
You guys are no chance with those clowns with the whistle.

i know fans probably make too much of the impact refs have on games, but badger is the only one i feel genuinly has something against the tigers. this is also shared by the tigers club, the media manager confirmed it on twitter before quickly deleting it after the titans game at campbelltown earlier in the year.
 

Todd Hoffman

Juniors
Messages
490
I expect the Tigers to put up an initial fight then fall victim to Penrith who have a habit of turning up for matches in the 2nd half.If the Panthers are serious about the top 8 they win this one quite comfortable.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Hometown referee Gavin Badger and his novice puppet Ziggy will favour the Panthers with every DODGY 50-50 calls going to the hometown.
Panthers Wiinning Average Under Badger Compared to Under All refs During Badger's Career- -3.12% (46.0% under Badger, 49.2% under all refs)
Wests Tigers Winning Average Under Badger Compared to Under All Refs During His Career- -1.86% (42.9% under Badger, 44.8% under all refs).

The worst club under him is the Titans with 34.2% wins compared to 44.1% under all refs.

The Dragons, by the way have 6.9% higher winning percentage under Badger than all refs.
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
25,427
lol, tigers fans already complaining about being done by the Refs, and the game is in 4 days....

Not refs, just badger, no one else. I wouldn't say his cost us games but he seems to make really baffling calls against us every game.

And please look at any panthers game day thread, you're the worst set of fans for complaining about refs out of anyone on here.
 

2010Dragons

Bench
Messages
4,038
TheFrog,
Nice stats, you can read the stats which ever slant you want.
The true indication is, how many of these games referee by Badger were home team winners and away team losers. I would dare to say the home team would win more games under Badger.
Badger doesn't referee the game for the players or to in force the rules .
He loves making an impression with the home team crowd.
This has been proven time and time again.
That's why he will NEVER referee a GF or SOO.
His file has been marked !!!
 
Last edited:

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
You're playing the team coming 15th who are missing 5 of their best starting 13 from the start of the year. Missing a lock and bench prop don't exactly cut it as an excuse if you lose.

A previous poster said it will be a full strength team. Pick one.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Not refs, just badger, no one else. I wouldn't say his cost us games but he seems to make really baffling calls against us every game.

And please look at any panthers game day thread, you're the worst set of fans for complaining about refs out of anyone on here.

It's every week in every thread. It's started mid week BEFORE the game here.

To the thread I think Tigers are better than their results show. Tedesco had a massive game last week as well and could trouble us. Will be fun and I wish I wasn't working because I try to go to Panthers/Tigers games including some away.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,956
Not refs, just badger, no one else. I wouldn't say his cost us games but he seems to make really baffling calls against us every game.

And please look at any panthers game day thread, you're the worst set of fans for complaining about refs out of anyone on here.

How special are you? Come in here sooking about the ref days before the game then you try and shift onto Penrith fans. "wah wah Badger hates us we will lose because of him...but those panthers fans geez they can whinge about a ref they are way worse than me" lol you muppet.

Good luck this week Tigers, I kind of feel like you will struggle to replicate your efforts last week but if you do we are very beatable.
 
Last edited:

billypilgrimnz

First Grade
Messages
5,169
Panthers Wiinning Average Under Badger Compared to Under All refs During Badger's Career- -3.12% (46.0% under Badger, 49.2% under all refs)
Wests Tigers Winning Average Under Badger Compared to Under All Refs During His Career- -1.86% (42.9% under Badger, 44.8% under all refs).

The worst club under him is the Titans with 34.2% wins compared to 44.1% under all refs.

The Dragons, by the way have 6.9% higher winning percentage under Badger than all refs.

It's almost as if it is all normal random statistical variation! It's like no NRL fan ever heard of a bell curve.
 

billypilgrimnz

First Grade
Messages
5,169
How special are you? Come in here sooking about the ref days before the game then you try and shift onto Penrith fans. "wah wah Badger hates us we will lose because of him...but those panthers fans geez they can whinge about a ref they are way worse than me" lol you muppet.

To be fair, we have a fair bunch of whingers about refs. But it's an NRL thing that really pisses me off, this obsession with "ref bias"
 
Top