BotanyBorn&Bred
Juniors
- Messages
- 2,245
I pretty much agree with almost all of this, the only thing is I feel a bit of a tug on the heart strings that Reynolds could have been offered a 2 year deal and it not impact negatively on the club.We haven’t gone onto a grand final since 2014, we have faded the past few tries. If this current team can’t win a premiership then I’m all for a clean out and reboot. No point being a Debbie downer and saying it’s a dark time etc. It’s time to embrace the future, and move forward, how many times have people bagged Gagai out for being a shit defender or he only plays good for Qld? I quite like him don’t get me wrong.
Then Sua who goes Mia most games and puts on a few good hits, but ffs he couldn’t even dive on a simple ball to score last week. I’d rather clear out some players, get the cap sorted and rebuild. I’d say Cook will be the next to go.
re: players that are leaving, with the exception of Reynolds, I'm ok with it. None were worth keeping, and the decisions made to not keep them have been justified. Sua was a shrinking violet an no use to our club, Gagai - a year ago most here was saying he needed to take a pay cut if he was to stay on; shame about Mago, but maybe he just doesn't have it in him to be an elite footballer.
If you look at all the guys that Souths have cast aside since 2014, NONE have made much of an impression anywhere else - Hymel Hunt, Fuimaono, Talakai, Av'a, the dude Cronulla got on the wing, Dylan Walker, the Mascot dude that was Walker's mate - nobody.
At the moment, I still trust the front office. I think Reynolds should have been offered 2 years, but I can also see why they haven't. Cook - I didn't realise he's still on the books for another 2 years, but he is on a major decline. No way is he the best hooker in the game, and he's been primarily responsible for the last two PF losses, he completely disappeared in both those games.
Cody is a different story - I've already explained how and why. He MUST be retained beyond next year.