What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2021 Rabbitohs Rumours, Signings And News

big hit!

Bench
Messages
3,452
Sam Burgess has been nominated at second row in the Menulog Team of the Decade: https://www.rabbitohs.com.au/news/2...second-row-in-the-menulog-team-of-the-decade/

Really?!

Played his best football in the middle. Should be a lock for 13 (no pun), but they're obviously trying to get Murray in that jersey.

Don't agree with a few of these selections tbh - Georgie B had a stand out 2014, but for the rest of his time at Souths, he's clearly been the inferior twin.
 

Travitoh

First Grade
Messages
5,186
Really?!

Played his best football in the middle. Should be a lock for 13 (no pun), but they're obviously trying to get Murray in that jersey.

Don't agree with a few of these selections tbh - Georgie B had a stand out 2014, but for the rest of his time at Souths, he's clearly been the inferior twin.

Agree, though I'd be looking at Crocker in 13.

For me:
8. Asotasi
9. Luke
10. Sam
11. Sutton
12. McQueen (debatable)
13. Crocker
 

Travitoh

First Grade
Messages
5,186
I agree with that except I'd have Te'o in place of McQueen.

And if all of them were in their prime at the same time, man what a devestatingly scary pack that'd be to go up against.

I could've gone any one of McQueen, Te'o and Taylor. Went McQueen based on him having an impact over a longer period of time. Te'o was the better player but played a much shorter period of time than McQueen did.
 

BotanyBorn&Bred

Juniors
Messages
2,245
Indeed, it would be the equal of our pack in 1989.
I'm glad you brought this up because I was thinking the exact same thing when I typed that post, but didn't mention it because I wanted to stay focused on the original point I was making.

And now that you bring it up, I always thought that side was the greatest team to never win the comp. And arguably one of Souths' all time great forward packs.

Roberts, Fenech, Boyle, Davidson, Chisolm, Andrews

What a pack!

And if Silverdale Phantom is lurking, I'll bring him in on this convo. The absolute battle of the titans when this pack went up against Roach, Elias, Edmed, Sironen, McGuire, Pearce.

I was a just turned young adult when this was rivalry going down 1986-1989, I remember the games (I went to them - they'd just moved to SFS), the hits, the punch ups, and that bout between Roach and Davidson, a full on heavyweight title bout! If this happened in today's game, they'd both be in gaol, on attempted murder charges LOL
 
Last edited:

Jim Rockford

Bench
Messages
3,082
I'm glad you brought this up because I was thinking the exact same thing when I typed that post, but didn't mention it because I wanted to stay focused on the original point I was making.

And now that you bring it up, I always thought that side was the greatest team to never win the comp. And arguably one of Souths' all time great forward packs.

Roberts, Fenech, Boyle, Davidson, Chisolm, Andrews

What a pack!

And if Silverdale Phantom is lurking, I'll bring him in on this convo. The absolute battle of the titans when this pack went up against Roach, Elias, Edmed, Sironen, McGuire, Pearce.

I was a just turned young adult when this was rivalry going down 1986-1989, I remember the games, the hits, the punch ups, and that bout between Roach and Davidson, a full on heavyweight title bout! If this happened in today's game, they'd both be in gaol, on attempted murder charges LOL
Without a doubt the best club pack I've ever seen. Don't forget they laid the platform for Souths to be the first team to beat every other team on their own home grounds that year.
 

BotanyBorn&Bred

Juniors
Messages
2,245
Without a doubt the best club pack I've ever seen. Don't forget they laid the platform for Souths to be the first team to beat every other team on their own home grounds that year.
Yeah 12 straight.
Minor Premiers.
Just bad luck they had to run into the Tigers first up, and the Canberra who seemed to come out of nowhere to win the title
 

LittleWayne

Juniors
Messages
395
Really?!

Played his best football in the middle. Should be a lock for 13 (no pun), but they're obviously trying to get Murray in that jersey.

Don't agree with a few of these selections tbh - Georgie B had a stand out 2014, but for the rest of his time at Souths, he's clearly been the inferior twin.

Cant agree with you there, George was the best prop in the world for a couple of seasons and our best prop for another 2/3. I think Tom’s done 3 really good years but not to the level of George.
 

Mr Spock!

Referee
Messages
22,502
Yeah 12 straight.
Minor Premiers.
Just bad luck they had to run into the Tigers first up, and the Canberra who seemed to come out of nowhere to win the title
Yeah but look at who was in the Canberra team.

Daley, Walters, Belcher, Meninga, Clyde, Lazarus, Stuart, Ferguson.

They had a good forward pack and an extremely potent backline. And that's where they beat us.
 

Latest posts

Top