The Game 2023 NRL Match Review Charges & Judiciary

[lockyno1]

How wasn't Hynes charged like Walsh was for abuse? I don't mind Walsh being charged and suspended but any chance of an ounce of consistency?

 

[Mr. Shaman]

Suspended for the horrid wishbone on Paseka, but the Shark loving douche with the whistle didn’t even penalise them, was a scrum sharks

 

[League Unlimited News]

Pleas so far

Martin Taupau (Brisbane)

• PLEA: Guilty - early plea
• RESULT: 3 match suspension

Jesse Arthars (Brisbane)

• PLEA: Guilty - early plea
• RESULT: 1 match suspension

Harry Grant (Melbourne)

• PLEA: Guilty - early plea
• RESULT: $1000 fine

Tariq Sims (Melbourne)

• PLEA: Guilty - early plea
• RESULT: $3000 fine

as well as

• PLEA: Guilty - early plea
• RESULT: 2 match suspension

Valentine Holmes (North Qld)

• PLEA: Guilty - early plea
• RESULT: $1800 fine

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: Round 21 & NRLW Round 1 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

 

[Captain Apollo]

How wasn't Hynes charged like Walsh was for abuse? I don't mind Walsh being charged and suspended but any chance of an ounce of consistency?

I would suggest that the audio of what Hynes said may not have been in the same category as Walsh's or may have been inconclusive. Hynes' comments to the touch judge may not have been picked up by the microphones, Walsh's definitely were.

 

[Saxon]

Tariq Sims (Melbourne)

• Grade 1 Shoulder Charge
• 34th minute, on Mat Croker
• Base penalty $2000
• 2nd offence last 12 months
• His options:
  2 matches: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $3000: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

AND

• Grade 2 Careless High Tackle
• 36th minute, Jackson Hastings
• Base penalty 2 matches
• 2nd offence last 12 months
• His options:
  3 matches: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR 2 matches: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Disappointed.
I was hoping he'd plead not guilty to both and then get convicted.

We'd be rid of him for 5 weeks rather than just two.

 

[gerg]

Suspended for the horrid wishbone on Paseka, but the Shark loving douche with the whistle didn’t even penalise them, was a scrum sharks

Yeah, that wasn't good. Being held by two other players and he starts trying to rip his legoff. They made a big deal about protecting the players from the hip drop but that tackle was much worse.

 

[Frailty]

I would suggest that the audio of what Hynes said may not have been in the same category as Walsh's or may have been inconclusive. Hynes' comments to the touch judge may not have been picked up by the microphones, Walsh's definitely were.

Annesley has said that both audio and reports from the referee and touch judge were that it wasn't abuse, but merely whinging.

If players will be suspended for that, then Moses and Gutherino will never play again.

 

[Banger]

I hate the Sharks just as much as any dragons supporter does, but it was a shit decision and deserved to be called out.
It was a beautiful pass and that probably cost them the game.

 

[Chimp]

I hate the Sharks just as much as any dragons supporter does, but it was a shit decision and deserved to be called out.
It was a beautiful pass and that probably cost them the game.

Just to add to this, the Manly try right on half time, I was sure the last pass looked to float about 4 or 5 meters forward too!
That being said, the Sharks were shite, and deserved to lose, so I’m certainly not blowing up about it, or blaming the loss on poor officiating. The Sharks were soft and got what they deserved!

 

[Captain Apollo]

Just to add to this, the Manly try right on half time, I was sure the last pass looked to float about 4 or 5 meters forward too!
That being said, the Sharks were shite, and deserved to lose, so I’m certainly not blowing up about it, or blaming the loss on poor officiating. The Sharks were soft and got what they deserved!

I take it you are aware that it is possible for a ball to float forward even when it is not passed forward by the player passing the ball? Not having a go at you, just curious.

 

[Chimp]

I take it you are aware that it is possible for a ball to float forward even when it is not passed forward by the player passing the ball? Not having a go at you, just curious.

I am indeed, but looked forward ‘out of the hand’ to me - I may be wrong, but those are the ones that you can understand a touchie getting wrong (where the ball has actually travelled forward) - the Hynes one physically went backwards.
As I say, nothing to do with the result, just a mere comment on officiating.

 

[gerg]

How many weeks for JWH? Meh, who am I kidding? $1500 thank you.

 

[Canard]

How many weeks for JWH? Meh, who am I kidding? $1500 thank you.

He gets the Roosters dispensation

 

[SpaceMonkey]

Honestly not much in the JWH tackle. He squared up for a big shot, Haas slipped in the tackle so the contact ended up a bit high but no damage was done. Certainly not reckless or intentional

 

[League Unlimited News]

Broncos v Roosters​

Patrick Carrigan (Brisbane)

• Grade 1 Careless High Tackle
• 20th minute, on Daniel Tupou
• Base penalty $1500
• 2nd offence last 12 months
• His options:
  $2500: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $1800: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Jared Waerea-Hargreaves (Sydney)

• Grade 1 Careless High Tackle
• 26th minute, on Payne Haas
• Base penalty $1500
• 3rd+ offence last 12 months
• His options:
  2 matches: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $3000: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

No charges from NRLW Broncos v Titans.

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: Round 22 & NRLW Round 2 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

 

[gerg]

Haha. $3000 this time. He must have about 10+ offences in the past 12 months.

 

[League Unlimited News]

Haha. $3000 this time. He must have about 10+ offences in the past 12 months.

Five offences during 2022 (R5, R11, R20, R24, FW1)
Three prior to this week in 2023 (R15, R15, R20)

So, five in the last 12 months. The only one that attracted a suspension was the Finals Week 1 game which saw him miss some of the RLWC for NZ.

 

[gerg]

Five offences during 2022 (R5, R11, R20, R24, FW1)
Three prior to this week in 2023 (R15, R15, R20)

So, five in the last 12 months. The only one that attracted a suspension was the Finals Week 1 game which saw him miss some of the RLWC for NZ.

Is that specifically Grade 1 careless high tackles, or any charge? Sure seems to be more.

Don't know why roosters have re-signed him, probably better off without him.

 

[Saxon]

Whoregraves is a prime example of why there needs to be a minimum 1 week for 3+ convictions in a season. Otherwise the grub will never change.

 

[League Unlimited News]

Tigers v Rabbitohs​

Keaon Koloamatangi (South Sydney)

• Grade 1 Shoulder Charge
• 1st minute, on Dave Klemmer
• Base penalty $2000
• His options:
  $2000: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $1500: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

AND

• Grade 1 Shoulder Charge
• 11th minute, also on Dave Klemmer
• Base penalty $2000
• His options:
  $2000: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $1500: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Aitasi James (Wests Tigers)

• Grade 1 Careless High Tackle
• 31st minute, on Cameron Murray
• Base penalty $1500
• His options:
  $1500: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $1000: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Davvy Moale (South Sydney)

• Grade 1 Shoulder Charge
• 49th minute, on Shawn Blore
• Base penalty $2000
• 2nd offence last 12 months
• His options:
  2 matches: Guilty at judiciary or plea of no contest
  OR $3000: Guilty - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

No players were charged from Storm v Eels

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: Round 22 & NRLW Round 2 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com