What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2023 R21 Sat - North Qld 24-16 Parramatta @ QLD Country Bank

Round 21: North Qld v Parramatta

  • North Queensland Cowboys

    Votes: 6 75.0%
  • Parramatta Eels

    Votes: 2 25.0%
  • Draw after Golden Point

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    8
  • Poll closed .

Canard

Immortal
Messages
34,584
Well played Parra, undermanned but never gave up.

There having a great year. Gutho is such a competitor.
 
Messages
12,818
Matterson should have gone to the bin for the hip drop tackle. Cowboys didn't even get a penalty for this dangerous tackle.

Parra should have had a player sent to the bin for 10 when they gave away about 4 or 5 penalties in a row on their line early in the first half.

Blake should have gone for 10 for the shoulder charge.

The two injuries to Neame and Nanai buggered the Cowboys forward rotation in the latter stages of the second half. The two Parra tries in this stage were due to the tiring Cowboys forwards struggling to keep up.

Parra really are a grubby and overhyped team. Their premiership tally in the professional era will remain at zero.
 
Messages
12,818
Well played Parra, undermanned but never gave up.

There having a great year. Gutho is such a competitor.
Well played?

They were given every leg up in the world and still got flogged. The only reason they got the last two tries is because the injuries to Neame before half time and Nanai early in the second half f**ked our forward rotation. Guthbertson took advantage of this when the game was well and truly over and our forwards were gassed.

At least three Parra players should have been sin binned for foul play. Blake for the shoulder charge. The 4 or 5 penalties they conceded in their line in the early stages of the second half warranted a binning. Matterson should have gone for the hip drop.

Holmes should not have been binned.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
149,006
Matterson should have gone to the bin for the hip drop tackle. Cowboys didn't even get a penalty for this dangerous tackle.

Parra should have had a player sent to the bin for 10 when they gave away about 4 or 5 penalties in a row on their line early in the first half.

Blake should have gone for 10 for the shoulder charge.

The two injuries to Neame and Nanai buggered the Cowboys forward rotation in the latter stages of the second half. The two Parra tries in this stage were due to the tiring Cowboys forwards struggling to keep up.

Parra really are a grubby and overhyped team. Their premiership tally in the professional era will remain at zero.
Putting Blake in the bin would of helped Parra you dope.
 

Cowboyz

Juniors
Messages
475
Holmes should have been sent off for that cheap shot on Moses.
You are so dumb.

1) If Holmes had actually got him high, Bitchell would have been knocked into the middle of next week
2) If Holmes had actually got him high, where was the HIA? Isn’t that the rule for direct contact to the head?
3) Why did the ball fly off like a missile? Because he contacted the ball and the shoulder, any further contact was ricocheted. No direct contact whatsoever.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
99,934
You are so dumb.

1) If Holmes had actually got him high, Bitchell would have been knocked into the middle of next week
2) If Holmes had actually got him high, where was the HIA? Isn’t that the rule for direct contact to the head?
3) Why did the ball fly off like a missile? Because he contacted the ball and the shoulder, any further contact was ricocheted. No direct contact whatsoever.

Paulo got a binning and four weeks for that exact hit on Hynes.

ItS a CoNsPiRaCy
 

MRN

Juniors
Messages
1,686
BRB
img_6973-gif.77169
This is democracy manifest! Gagai just trying to have a succulent chinese meal and Harry just comes and puts his hands on his penis.
 

SLRBRONCOS

Referee
Messages
23,312
100% whiplash after he had hit the ball and shoulder. Still not direct contact. Do you really think Moses would have stayed on the field if that was a direct hit?
There was no change in direction - his shoulder came in direct contact with the putrid head of Bitch Moses.

Some head-knocks cause concussion, others do not. Luckily for Mitch, his facial bones (jaw) did a good job in protecting his brain from knocking against his skull, so he wasn't knocked out. Val's shoulder still came in direct contact with his head and he was rightly binned.

Screenshot 2023-07-23 at 10.39.47 am.pngScreenshot 2023-07-23 at 10.39.39 am.pngScreenshot 2023-07-23 at 10.44.39 am.png

Nothing in this hit was stopping Val's shoulder from hitting his head - the ball was yeeted into orbit and is an irrelevant factor of this tackle. You can fly from Brisbane to London via Dubai but you'll still hit London.

Our lust for the days of big hits causes us all to get a bit insane over these binnings, but this is how the game is adjudicated now. I'm sure if the roles were reversed, you'd be screaming for the Para player to be binned.

Like Bazal said, Paulo got 4 weeks for the same hit. You got the win, time to move on.
 
Last edited:

Canard

Immortal
Messages
34,584
For mine, using still frames for an incident like this is as useful as Karmicheal Hunt at NRL level in 2021.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
34,584
There was no change in direction - his shoulder came in direct contact with the putrid head of Bitch Moses.

Some head-knocks cause concussion, others do not. Luckily for Mitch, his facial bones (jaw) did a good job in protecting his brain from knocking against his skull, so he wasn't knocked out. Val's shoulder still came in direct contact with his head and he was rightly binned.

View attachment 77192View attachment 77193View attachment 77194

Nothing in this hit was stopping Val's shoulder from hitting his head - the ball was yeeted into orbit and is an irrelevant factor of this tackle. You can fly from Brisbane to London via Dubai but you'll still hit London.

Our lust for the days of big hits causes us all to get a bit insane over these binnings, but this is how the game is adjudicated now. I'm sure if the roles were reversed, you'd be screaming for the Para player to be binned.

Like Bazal said, Paulo got 4 weeks for the same hit. You got the win, time to move on.

The roles were reversed in the first half when Waqa hit Pet late and with a shoulder charge.

And Parra didn't even get penalised.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
10,517
Well played?

They were given every leg up in the world and still got flogged. The only reason they got the last two tries is because the injuries to Neame before half time and Nanai early in the second half f**ked our forward rotation. Guthbertson took advantage of this when the game was well and truly over and our forwards were gassed.

At least three Parra players should have been sin binned for foul play. Blake for the shoulder charge. The 4 or 5 penalties they conceded in their line in the early stages of the second half warranted a binning. Matterson should have gone for the hip drop.

Holmes should not have been binned.

Have more of a sook 😂
 

SLRBRONCOS

Referee
Messages
23,312
For mine, using still frames for an incident like this is as useful as Karmicheal Hunt at NRL level in 2021.
Frames saved a filthy murdoch share, but here you go - shows the same shit of course.

The roles were reversed in the first half when Waqa hit Pet late and with a shoulder charge.

And Parra didn't even get penalised.

Welcome to the NRL. Consistently inconsistent, and you proved my point that if the roles were reversed, you'd be calling for action - because you just did. Just enjoy the winnnnnnn
 

Latest posts

Top