What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2024 Match Review & Judiciary charges

League Unlimited News

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
8,186

Gold Coast Titans v Newcastle Knights​

Jack Hetherington (Newcastle)
  • Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Beau Fermor (44 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • 2nd offence last 12 months
  • His options
    $2500 - guilty/no contest
    $1800 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
Keenan Palasia (Gold Coast)
  • Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Enari Tuala (58 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • His options
    $1500 - guilty/no contest
    $1000 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC

Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks v Sydney Roosters​

No players charged.

South Sydney Rabbitohs v North Queensland Cowboys​

Dion Teaupa (South Sydney)
  • Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Tom Dearden (71 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • His options
    $1500 - guilty/no contest
    $1000 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
 

League Unlimited News

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
8,186

Warriors v Penrith Panthers​

Jackson Ford (Warriors)
  • Grade 1 Dangerous Throw on Matt Eisenhuth (65 min)
  • Base penalty $2000 fine
  • His options
    $2000 - guilty/no contest
    $1500 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
James Fisher-Harris (Penrith)
  • Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Dylan Walker (70 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • His options
    $1500 - guilty/no contest
    $1000 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC

Melbourne Storm v Parramatta Eels​

Nelson Asofa-Solomona (Melbourne)
  • Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Maika Sivo (37 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • His options
    $1500 - guilty/no contest
    $1000 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC

Wests Tigers v Dolphins​

Brent Naden (Wests Tigers)
  • Grade 2 Dangerous Contact on Jack Bostock (40 min)
  • Base penalty 2 matches
  • His options
    2 matches - guilty/no contest
    1 match - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
Justin Olam (Wests Tigers)
  • Grade 2 Dangerous Contact on Jamayne Isaako (47 min)
  • Base penalty 2 matches
  • His options
    2 matches - guilty/no contest
    1 match - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
24,878

Warriors v Penrith Panthers​

Jackson Ford (Warriors)
  • Grade 1 Dangerous Throw on Matt Eisenhuth (65 min)
  • Base penalty $2000 fine
  • His options
    $2000 - guilty/no contest
    $1500 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
James Fisher-Harris (Penrith)
  • Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Dylan Walker (70 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • His options
    $1500 - guilty/no contest
    $1000 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC

Melbourne Storm v Parramatta Eels​

Nelson Asofa-Solomona (Melbourne)
  • Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Maika Sivo (37 min)
  • Base penalty $1500 fine
  • His options
    $1500 - guilty/no contest
    $1000 - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC

Wests Tigers v Dolphins​

Brent Naden (Wests Tigers)
  • Grade 2 Dangerous Contact on Jack Bostock (40 min)
  • Base penalty 2 matches
  • His options
    2 matches - guilty/no contest
    1 match - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
Justin Olam (Wests Tigers)
  • Grade 2 Dangerous Contact on Jamayne Isaako (47 min)
  • Base penalty 2 matches
  • His options
    2 matches - guilty/no contest
    1 match - early plea
  • PLEA: TBC
Naden should have got grade 10 stupidity

How anyone can say Olams is the same as Papallis who landed directly on the guys legs is laughable
 

League Unlimited News

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
8,186

Pleas entered for Thu-Sat matches:​

Corban Baxter (NSW W)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. Warning.
Zahara Temara (QLD W)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. Warning.
Josh Papali'i (Canberra)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. 1 match
Jordan Rapana (Canberra)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. $1000
Joseph Tapine (Canberra)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. $1000
Brendan Piakura (Brisbane)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. $1000
Jack Hetherington (Newcastle)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. $1800
Keenan Palasia (Gold Coast)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. $1000
Dion Teaupa (South Sydney)
  • PLEA: Guilty - early plea. $1000
 

jc155776

Coach
Messages
13,515
Val’s charge seems harsh but probably done to save referee/bunker face. Wasn’t a hip drop, was a collision where his body was thrown into the Tigers players legs by another tackler.

How Klemmer stays on the field after copping a grading like that for a more obvious offence astounds me.

Saying this as a Sharks fan who enjoys watching both sides when playing well and hold no ill will against either side (lived in Cowboy country for many years and still remember how great the Cows vs Tigers games use to be back in the mid to late 00s) .
 

no name

Coach
Messages
19,718
Holmes’ tackle was very similar to Josh Papalii’s one last week, which was given a grade 2.
The nauseating bleating in the media all night last night did the trick to get it down to a grade 1.
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
24,878
Yeah, you can’t tell me the NRL don’t treat some teams differently to others when it comes to this shit. It’s become farcical how we get charged compared to tackles that literally rule guys out for 6-8 weeks
 

no name

Coach
Messages
19,718
Also, there is something fundamentally wrong when player A gets 10 in the bin and then gets grade 1 and a fine, player B stays on the field gets grade 2 and 3 weeks.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
27,494
Klemmers was worse than Holmes and it got missed initially because there was no injury. Holmes one didn't deserve a bin, it was just ruled on outcome. Klemmers should have been a bin. Much more of a classic hip drop.
 

mozza91

Coach
Messages
13,360
You know they have NFI what is and isn’t a bad hip drop. Penalties on the field are based solely on a player getting injured. Then the charges are a lucky dip. Massive farce.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,161
Yeah, you can’t tell me the NRL don’t treat some teams differently to others when it comes to this shit. It’s become farcical how we get charged compared to tackles that literally rule guys out for 6-8 weeks
Agreed.

Klemmer not even get getting penalised, smacks of clear favouritism
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
24,878
Klemmers was worse than Holmes and it got missed initially because there was no injury. Holmes one didn't deserve a bin, it was just ruled on outcome. Klemmers should have been a bin. Much more of a classic hip drop.
IMG_1418.jpeg

I’m talking purely on grading from the MRC

their own rules state they have to take injury into consideration. In what world is a tackle that doesn’t injure someone, more dangerous then one that rules a guy out for 6-8 weeks?
 

skeepe

Immortal
Messages
47,311
If Papalii’s was a grade 2, so was Val’s.

I don’t think either of them were a grade 2, but some consistency would be nice.
 

no name

Coach
Messages
19,718
If Papalii’s was a grade 2, so was Val’s.

I don’t think either of them were a grade 2, but some consistency would be nice.
In origin selection week? Good luck.

It’s never consistent, but you can be sure to see bafflingly inconsistent decisions even more around Origin.
 

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,246
Tigers are such NRL darlings. How the f**k does Klemmer stay on the field last night?

He's got form that bloke too intentionally trying to injure players.
 

Latest posts

Top