2024 Match Review & Judiciary charges

[skeepe]

Grade 3? Are they f**king high?

Go f**k yourselves NRL you f**king useless pieces of shit.

Where's the charge for Tedesco's elbow that fractured Rapana's cheekbone?

Absolute bullshit.

 

[skeepe]

3 charges and and the one where he ruptured a blokes ACL is 4 weeks.

That can't be right, he is a good bloke whose character is getting assassinated and it's just a rugby league tackle.

Go f**k yourself

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Haha of course, because its against the Roosters and poor Robinson has an injured player, even though he was already injured.

 

[Valheru]

Haha of course, because its against the Roosters and poor Robinson has an injured player, even though he was already injured.

He had already ruptured his ACL?

 

[skeepe]

I seriously can't get over how stupid the MRC are. It shouldn't have even been a penalty, and they're going to give him a 3 match ban?

While Tedesco is free to lead with his elbow and fracture Rapana's cheekbone?

the National Rooster League strikes again.

 

[Captain Apollo]

I bet if it was JWH who'd performed a hip drop tackle, resulting in an major injury, the same people defending Whitehead would be calling for the league equivalent of the death penalty for JWH. The hypocrisy from some people is rank.

 

[Valheru]

I seriously can't get over how stupid the MRC are. It shouldn't have even been a penalty, and they're going to give him a 3 match ban?

While Tedesco is free to lead with his elbow and fracture Rapana's cheekbone?

the National Rooster League strikes again.

Look if you keep saying it, you might convince yourself it's true

 

[Valheru]

I bet if it was JWH who'd performed a hip drop tackle, resulting in an major injury, the same people defending Whitehead would be calling for the league equivalent of the death penalty for JWH. The hypocrisy from some people is rank.

Oh don't worry... JWH who wasn't playing yesterday and had nothing to do with either the on or off field incident has been widely discussed for some unknown reason so I could only imagine what would happen if it were him.

 

[Bazal]

Falling on a leg and rupturing an ACL is part of the game?

That's correct yes. As much as falling on a blokes face and crushing his cheekbone is anyway.

Accidents happen

 

[Bazal]

I bet if it was JWH who'd performed a hip drop tackle, resulting in an major injury, the same people defending Whitehead would be calling for the league equivalent of the death penalty for JWH. The hypocrisy from some people is rank.

You've sure made a point here....it's not the point you think it is, but boy is there a point

 

[Vic Mackey]

Admittedly Ive only seen it once, but it didnt look like a hip drop to me, he sort of got flung around by the momentum of the tackle and landed awkwardly on Smith. Very similar to Holmes on Papalli which broke his ankle. Of course Holmes wasnt charged, as that was only on a Tiger. Very different when its on a high profile player/team though.

 

[Chins get the wins]

3 charges and and the one where he ruptured a blokes ACL is 4 weeks.

That can't be right, he is a good bloke whose character is getting assassinated and it's just a rugby league tackle.

Cry more

 

[yobbo84]

Oh, rain, rain, rain, rain
A storm it comes our way
And those who rise through distorted lies
Poison in the veins
But we like to point the blame, blame, blame, blame
It's easier to blame
But point the mirror at ourselves
We're all part of this old money game

 

[dogslife]

Oh don't worry... JWH who wasn't playing yesterday and had nothing to do with either the on or off field incident has been widely discussed for some unknown reason so I could only imagine what would happen if it were him.

He couldn't have.

He wasn't allowed to play because he keeps treating his opponents heads like speed balls. Something Robbo overlooked when he went into bat for him.

 

[yobbo84]

Grade 3 is a direct result of the announcement that Brandon Smith has done his ACL.

If you don't believe that, I have a bridge to sell you.

 

[dogslife]

NRL are expected to ban ACL's from next season

 

[Valheru]

Grade 3 is a direct result of the announcement that Brandon Smith has done his ACL.

If you don't believe that, I have a bridge to sell you.

I definitely agree that's the case

Probably a fine if no injury and in between if a minor injury

 

[Captain Apollo]

The NRL have stated a number of times previously that any resulting injury does play a role in charges by the MRC and the grading.

 

[yobbo84]

The NRL have stated a number of times previously that any resulting injury does play a role in charges by the MRC and the grading.

Which is fine and dandy when it's foul play. If you break a bloke's jaw with a swinging arm you should get longer than if it's just a bruise.

But Whitehead's tackle was a total accident and we're going down the path of having to blame someone for every accident, which is stupid.

I'd be perfectly happy if Whitehead got nothing for the tackle, but 2 weeks for trying to kick Angus Crichton, which there is no excuse for.

 

[dogslife]

The NRL have stated a number of times previously that any resulting injury does play a role in charges by the MRC and the grading.

And you believe them?

My ribs now hurt from laughing at this.