What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2024 Prediction Thread

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
74,109
Where will we finish?

If we don’t win it, who will?

Our best player?

Our biggest disappointment?

The first rookie to make NRL debut?

Surprise packet?

Breakout year?

Best retention?

The biggest name we let go?

Biggest signing?

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
 

Pazza

First Grade
Messages
8,650
Where will we finish?
1st
If we don’t win it, who will?
Brisbane
Our best player?
moses
Our biggest disappointment?
lane
The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Betham-Misa
Surprise packet?
Joe O
Breakout year?
Russell
Best retention?
ky rodwell???
The biggest name we let go?
simonson
Biggest signing?
tass
Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Benji flop
Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
y
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
32,301
Where will we finish?
7th

If we don’t win it, who will?
Roosters

Our best player?
Dylan Brown

Our biggest disappointment?
Junior Paulo

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Blaize Talagi

Surprise packet?
Morgan Harper

Breakout year?
Kelma Tuilagi


Best retention?
Nobody coming off contract will be retained

The biggest name we let go?
Junior Paulo

Biggest signing?
Ryan Papenhuyzen

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
The sacking of Anthony Seibold

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
No, he will replace Seibold at Manly
 
Last edited:

the phantom menace

First Grade
Messages
8,974
Where will we finish?
In a crumpled heap at full time on the field wherever our Round 27 match is held... So missing the 8 - let's say 11th?

If we don’t win it, who will?
Time for an upset/change of the guard... Knights?

Our best player?
I'm thinking Hopgood

Our biggest disappointment?
I'm thinking our ageing high-paid strike weapons... Junior and/or RCG

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Talagi... is there anyone else current in our top 30 or on a development contract that hasn't debuted?

Surprise packet?
Russell, in the centres

Breakout year?
Greig - time to shine Emu

Best retention?
As in re-signed during 2024... um, Jabriel Kalache - everyone else off contract may be heading elsewhere or not retained for 2025?

The biggest name we let go?
As in let go during or at the end of 2024... I'm going to say Matterson (early), because where there's smoke there's fire and I suspect he's (still?) on the nose after taking the suspension instead of the fine. (Failing that, Paulo on mutual early release to a willing club.)

Biggest signing?
I can't see us making one for 2024, but for 2025... we'll need a forward to replace Matto/Paulo (if released early) or just due to our ageing middle stocks. So maybe someone like Nat Butcher for 3 years (I don't think we'll do bigger signings)?

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
The bunker still being shit - every game, every week, and it's going to more obviously cost more teams some games, and the controversy will build...

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
I'm gonna say no - he'll "leave" early (at the end of 2024) when we again don't make the 8.
 

Hindmarshisgod2

Juniors
Messages
1,064
Where will we finish?
6th

If we don’t win it, who will?
Panthers

Our best player?
Dylan Brown

Our biggest disappointment?
Sivo

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Matt Arthur round 1

Surprise packet?
Superman

Breakout year?
Superman

Best retention?
Superman

The biggest name we let go?
Paulo

Biggest signing?
Bradman best

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Flanagan nepotism at dragons

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
No
 

Enamoured Eel

Juniors
Messages
174
Where will we finish?
5th. I think we go deep but unfortunately, I fear that Penrith and Brisbane will remain strong in ‘24. The Cowboys will bounce back. The Titans climb and the Roosters rise. The Storm only just cling on to a top eight spot. The Rabbitohs round out the teams who advance.

If we don’t win it, who will?

The Broncos.

Our best player?

Dylan Brown wins 5/8th of the year.

Our biggest disappointment?

Joe Ofahengaue is surplus to our needs.

The first rookie to make NRL debut?

There won’t be one unless there are a heap of restings late in the piece. I’ll go a youngster on the wing or Ethan Sanders.

Surprise packet?

Bailey Simonsson or Shaun Lane. Fingers crossed the former.

Breakout year?

Bailey Simonsson.

Best retention?

Hopgood and Penisini on further extensions.

The biggest name we let go?
Joe Ofahengaue.

Biggest signing?

Taylan May.

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?

Munster dropped from Origin in game three dead rubber.

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N

Yes.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
32,301
I am waiting for the draw to come out.

I want to see who has a softish or hard looking draw before deciding.

We might get 4 teams straight off a bye again to start the year.
You’re a smart young man. I understand. The rest however cannot make that excuse.
 

Noise

Coach
Messages
17,322
Where will we finish?
9th. Similar to this year we lack outside backs and a quality coach.

If we don’t win it, who will?
Broncos

Our best player?
Dylan Brown

Our biggest disappointment?
Ryan Matterson

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Mataele

Surprise packet?
Emu

Breakout year?
Hopgood. Will play origin

Best retention?
Penisini

The biggest name we let go?
Ryan Matterson

Biggest signing?
Lomax

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Paul Kent returns to NRL 360

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
Yes. There is no way you can judge a coach after just 11 years
 
Last edited:

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
10,499
Where will we finish?
13th

If we don’t win it, who will?
Broncos

Our best player?
Gutho

Our biggest disappointment?
Paulo

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Martyn

Surprise packet?
Martyn

Breakout year?
Martyn

Best retention?
No one

The biggest name we let go?
Paulo

Biggest signing?
No one

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Panther miss the 8

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
No
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
14,473
Where will we finish? 14th

If we don’t win it, who will? Broncos

Our best player? Hopgood

Our biggest disappointment? Paulo again.

The first rookie to make NRL debut? Ethyn Martin

Surprise packet? Hands

Breakout year? Simonsson

Best retention? Simonsson

The biggest name we let go? Matterson

Biggest signing? Another middle forward as yet to be named.

Non-eels, biggest controversy ? Bunker

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N Of cause he will.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,437
Where will we finish?
with some luck 7th or 8th, the lack of quality and depth in outside backs will hurt us eventually.

If we don’t win it, who will?
Broncos

Our best player?
King Clint

Our biggest disappointment?
Junior

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
JJBM

Surprise packet?
Doorey

Breakout year?
Emu

Best retention?
Blaize Talagi

The biggest name we let go?
Ryan Matterson

Biggest signing?
JAC ( if we're lucky )

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Bellamy and Munster fall out.

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
no
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
59,288
Where will we finish?

3rd

If we don’t win it, who will?
THE PENRITH PANTHER

Our best player?

RCG

Our biggest disappointment?

Moimesea

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Mataele

Surprise packet?

Lussick

Breakout year?
Morretti

Best retention?

Morretti


The biggest name we let go?

SIVO


Biggest signing?

Taylan May


Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
CLEARY ALREADY THE G.O.A.T


Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
Y
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
32,301
Where will we finish?

3rd

If we don’t win it, who will?
THE PENRITH PANTHER

Our best player?

RCG

Our biggest disappointment?

Moimesea

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Mataele

Surprise packet?

Lussick

Breakout year?
Morretti

Best retention?

Morretti


The biggest name we let go?

SIVO


Biggest signing?

Taylan May


Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
CLEARY ALREADY THE G.O.A.T


Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
Y
Taylan May would be a good acquisition.
 
Top