What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2nd ODI - Australia v England, Hobart Jan 21 2011

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
Dougie 3rd best batter today and probably looks the 2nd most comfortable behind Marsh :p
 
Messages
17,035
Can anyone tell me why marsh is playing today but not in the WC squad? Doesn't seem logical.. Shouldn't the team playing today be made up of WC players??? Either they should not have selected marsh to play today or they need to put him into the WC squad.
 
Messages
33,280
How come Marsh didn't get back in to the team after his injury his form wasn't that bad iirc but great century to the guy when under pressure :clap:
 

Cockadoodledoo

First Grade
Messages
5,045
Can anyone tell me why marsh is playing today but not in the WC squad? Doesn't seem logical.. Shouldn't the team playing today be made up of WC players??? Either they should not have selected marsh to play today or they need to put him into the WC squad.

Because Mike Hussey is going and is currently injured and the selectors are f**ktards.
 
Messages
17,035
Because Mike Hussey is going and is currently injured and the selectors are f**ktards.

Will Hussey be going though?


But anyway...

They have selected a squad of 15 for the world cup.

Ideally to win a world cup you want a good prep e.g a 7 game series against a top team. In the prep phase you want to use your 15 WC players to get some form together? right???

Ok.. so.... why is it so... that in a squad of 15 players we can not field a team during a one day game that is not too far away from the world cup.?

I dont know, I might not be seeing the full picture here, but wouldnt you want to select a squad of 15 players that are 1) Fit and 2) in form? And would you not want these 15 players to all atleast be fit for a 7 game series that is meant to be part of the preperation for the WC?

A bit silly if you ask me.
 
Last edited:
Messages
33,280
Will Hussey be going though?


But anyway...

They have selected a squad of 15 for the world cup.

Ideally to win a world cup you want a good prep e.g a 7 game series against a top team. In the prep phase you want to use your 15 WC players to get some form together? right???

Ok.. so.... why is it so... that in a squad of 15 players we can not field a team during a one day game that is not too far away from the world cup.?

I dont know, I might not be seeing the full picture here, but wouldnt you want to select a squad of 15 players that are 1) Fit and 2) in form? And would you not want these 15 players to all atleast be fit for a 7 game series that is meant to be part of the preperation for the WC?

A bit silly if you ask me.

You know that. I know that. Everyone on this forum knows that but Hilditch doesn't. Hoepfully being spanked in the Ashes and failing to get out of the group stage will be enough to get rid of him and his dinosaur cronies.
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
This is where they say Symonds missed the beginning of the last World cup, then played 'that' innings to keep us in it.
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
Gunna need early wickets to defend 230.

Wonderful Innings from Marsh, and a great cameo from the rug.
 

Cockadoodledoo

First Grade
Messages
5,045
Will Hussey be going though?


But anyway...

They have selected a squad of 15 for the world cup.

Ideally to win a world cup you want a good prep e.g a 7 game series against a top team. In the prep phase you want to use your 15 WC players to get some form together? right???

Ok.. so.... why is it so... that in a squad of 15 players we can not field a team during a one day game that is not too far away from the world cup.?

I dont know, I might not be seeing the full picture here, but wouldnt you want to select a squad of 15 players that are 1) Fit and 2) in form? And would you not want these 15 players to all atleast be fit for a 7 game series that is meant to be part of the preperation for the WC?

A bit silly if you ask me.

I agree with that to a point but Mike Hussey is so valuable I can understand including him... Sean Marsh is his standby player hence you can understand why he is playing this match.. they obviously feel there is a reasonable risk Hussey won't make it so at least want Marsh having some games under his belt in case... That all said they should have both been in the squad alongside Ferguson and Hodge with D Hussey, M Clarke and take your pick of Ponting and Smith sitting at home.
 
Messages
17,035
I would love to just slap hilditch in his face as hard as i could. The endorphin release that that would give me would be phenominal.

Back to the game.. 230 is defendable, but jeese our bowlers will need to bowl good.. And well we all know a few of them can be quite expensive...
 
Messages
17,035
I agree with that to a point but Mike Hussey is so valuable I can understand including him... Sean Marsh is his standby player hence you can understand why he is playing this match.. they obviously feel there is a reasonable risk Hussey won't make it so at least want Marsh having some games under his belt in case... That all said they should have both been in the squad alongside Ferguson and Hodge with D Hussey, M Clarke and take your pick of Ponting and Smith sitting at home.

That makes sense.
 

Latest posts

Top