What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2ND TEST: Australia v West Indies Adelaide Oval Dec 4 - Dec 8 2009

Messages
3,140
Exactly and lets be honest he was very lucky to survive the first one. As a batsman you know if you hit it. Chanderpaul looked directly to the keeper. OUT!

Wait ... wait ... wait

On that first one, Haddin's reaction is a DEAD GIVEAWAY Chanderpaul didn't hit the ball. After the ball goes through to him, Haddin goes away to throw the ball away to a fieldsmen and only starts appealing when he realizes he has no one to throw the ball to cause they are all appealing. If we are using Chanderpaul's reaction as a clue to whether he hit ir not then we have to look at the keeper's reaction cause he along with the umpire have the best view of what happened. And Haddin's reaction is a DEAD GIVEAWAY that Chanderpaul did not hit the ball.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,894
Wait ... wait ... wait

On that first one, Haddin's reaction is a DEAD GIVEAWAY Chanderpaul didn't hit the ball. After the ball goes through to him, Haddin goes away to throw the ball away to a fieldsmen and only starts appealing when he realizes he has no one to throw the ball to cause they are all appealing. If we are using Chanderpaul's reaction as a clue to whether he hit ir not then we have to look at the keeper's reaction cause he along with the umpire have the best view of what happened. And Haddin's reaction is a DEAD GIVEAWAY that Chanderpaul did not hit the ball.
And Ponting who i think was at 2nd slip needed some convincing to even to go to the 3rd ump.
 
Messages
3,140
According to Locky, Benn just edged his second ball. He flung his bat at the ball, completely missed it BUT still looked behind. That is out by Locky'a rules ....
 
Messages
3,140
In actual fact Benn looks behind every single time he leaves a ball ....

I don't know why we aren't appealing for caught behind cause according to Locky that is a dead giveaway sign he has edged the ball.
 

Latest posts

Top