A Hypothetical situation Part 6

[Stagger eel]

we're over the sallery cap and 2 of the 5 players listed need to be released to get back under.

Timan Tahu
Eric Grothe
Glen Morrison
Mark Riddell
Tim Smith

who would you choose, bare in mind it can't be outside this list.

there will be a twist to this tomorrow.

 

[Phillips]

i'd say Mark Riddell & Glenn Morrison

Morrison's my favourite player but i picked him because out of that list he's the oldest

Riddell can be replaced with either Marsh/Morris

 

[Twizzle]

I'll wait till tomorrow then

 

[number8]

Are we over the cap because of Lyons payments. If so release him to keep Tahu. If he is comming back NOW to honour the contract Release Tahu.

Morrison is great so is Riddell. I'd have to say Morrison the other given the depth in that position.

I'd go Morro & Tahu as good as they are. The others would give more bang for the buck!

How long have we lacked a traditional halfback. Tim stays.

We should have learnt the first time. Guru stays

Riddell in the side allows us to use our bench the way we do. That is our greatest strength as a team. Riddell stays.

Tough call, & people have been giving it to Smith/fitzy for years for the clubs retention policy. Fancy doing this for real every year!

 

[number8]

Riddell can be replaced with either Marsh/Morris

Yes but they are already in the 1st 17. who then replaces them & how do the new team combinations play out?

 

[Phillips]

Yes but they are already in the 1st 17. who then replaces them & how do the new team combinations play out?

if Morris goes to hooker, i'd put maybe feleti Mateo or even Marcus Perenara there at 5/8th

if Marsh goes into hooker i'd have James Storer on the bench

 

[number8]

if Morris goes to hooker, i'd put maybe feleti Mateo or even Marcus Perenara there at 5/8th

if Marsh goes into hooker i'd have James Storer on the bench

I was hoping to watch a bit of Mateo for the Broncos but saw nothing. How'd he go over there?

 

[strider]

f) None of the above - we just buy a packet of brown paper bags ;-)

 

[MarkInTheStands]

The thing is with this Timana and Grothe are in the positions that have the most talent coming through. Ben Smith, Brett Delaney, Luke Burt and Jarred Hayne with Joel Reddy available as well as mckinnion, those would be the positions with enough depth to cover.

In saying that if we have kept Drew Dalton, you could find Piggy out of the club, but I don't think so.

 

[Hellsy]

U and ur fricken twists Eela.. how can we make decisions unless we know the whole story?

 

[Eelementary]

we're over the sallery cap and 2 of the 5 players listed need to be released to get back under.

Timan Tahu
Eric Grothe
Glen Morrison
Mark Riddell
Tim Smith

who would you choose, bare in mind it can't be outside this list.

there will be a twist to this tomorrow.

As much as I hate saying this...

My two players would be Tahu and Grothe.

I would have chosen Riddell in Grothe's place, but Scott Jones left - so he's out of the equation.

Morrison is too vital to our pack at the moment to leave out.

Tim Smith is the best halfback in the game.

And we could replace Tahu with Delaney and possibly Davis and Grothe with Williams and Inu.

 

[Stagger eel]

U and ur fricken twists Eela.. how can we make decisions unless we know the whole story?

you'll find out tomorrow.

 

[Hellsy]

you'll find out tomorrow.

:sto: :sto: I'll tell u tomorrow then

 

[Stagger eel]

:sto: :sto: I'll tell u tomorrow then

please yourself. ;-)

 

[The Engineers Room]

My two would be Morrison and Tahu

Morrison because we have enough depth to cover the back row and Tahu for a similar reason. The others should stay because they can all add something to the side that no other player can replace.

Is the twist that Jamie Lyon is the reason we are over the cap?

 

[Stagger eel]

Is the twist that Jamie Lyon is the reason we are over the cap?

no.

 

[number8]

These twist are a treat. Everytime I think I know what it is POW! I get it shut right down. What could it be?

Tommorrow I guess!

 

[Stagger eel]

These twist are a treat. Everytime I think I know what it is POW! I get it shut right down. What could it be?

Tommorrow I guess!

yeah! still trying to dream it up

 

[number8]

Have you ever come up with one but had to change it because someone thought they worked it out?

 

[Stagger eel]

Have you ever come up with one but had to change it because someone thought they worked it out?

no! not out to rack anyones brain, just setting a non reallistic scenereo of hypotheticals and interested to see what direction people take, one thing about this, is that no one's right or wrong but it does bring up some spirited discussion which we can have over the off season.