Acknowledging musical genius

[carcharias]

carc

you must have missed my question

is the shudduppayaface guy a musical genius?

and on yorke - i like radiohead....but yorke is a wanker

no he is not.

your turn.

was that song all you knew about him?

 

[millersnose]

no he is not.

your turn.

was that song all you knew about him?

yes

and remains that way

 

[cheese]

Dylan IS a musical genius.

As a lyricist he's just about without peer.


.....crapallica on the other hand

 

[carcharias]

Dylan IS a musical genius.

As a lyricist he's just about without peer.


.....crapallica on the other hand

yeah.
He was a great song writer.
Not many people can write more than one absolute classic.
He wrote dozens .
Who cares if he used only a handful of chords.

 

[millersnose]

the spice girls ?

stock aitken waterman?

 

[simmo1]

Thom Yorke is the modern day Axl Rose: great lyricist, but a complete douche.

"Thom Yorke sat at a piano singing, 'This is f**ked up,' for half an hour. We all know that, Mr Yorke. Who wants to sing the news? No matter how much you sit their twiddling, going, 'We're all doomed,' at the end of the day people will always want to hear you play Creep. Get over it" - Noel Gallagher

 

[carcharias]

I like Radiohead.
Saw them at the ent cent about 10 years back now.
Have all their stuff bar the last one.
Funny because one of the new songs is even a bit rock n roll...which is more my taste.

The dude is one ugly ugly man ...thats why he plays the tortured artist card IMO.

 

[fish eel]

Beck.

 

[carcharias]

Beck.

can't argue with that.

So many great songs.
great voice to go with the experimentation.

 

[fish eel]

can't argue with that.

So many great songs.
great voice to go with the experimentation.

He has been hit and miss, and his new album is very much like that.

However, I have been listening to Odelay quite a bit lately.

That still sounds as fresh and innovative as anything out today.

 

[carcharias]

He has been hit and miss, and his new album is very much like that.

However, I have been listening to Odelay quite a bit lately.

That still sounds as fresh and innovative as anything out today.

I really rate seachange.
Not bad for an album that almost didn't get released.

 

[fish eel]

Mutuations is another good one.

I'll also throw Thurston Moore and Wayne Coyne (flaming lips) into the mix.

 

[Mong]

Thom Yorke is the modern day Axl Rose: great lyricist, but a complete douche.

So people have said here, unfortunately asides from a "carbon" issue no one has been able to explain why he is a wanker or a douche..

 

[fish eel]

let's see - Axl Rose, track record of cancelling shows, coming on stage 2 hours late, taking how many years to record an album, being a general prick versus Thom Yorke who, umm.... yeah. :?

 

[Mong]

let's see - Axl Rose, track record of cancelling shows, coming on stage 2 hours late, taking how many years to record an album, being a general prick versus Thom Yorke who, umm.... yeah. :?

He does care about the environment though Fishy.. Definate wanker thing to do i guess..

 

[Ron Jeremy]

let's see - Axl Rose, track record of cancelling shows, coming on stage 2 hours late, taking how many years to record an album, being a general prick versus Thom Yorke who, umm.... yeah. :?

Besides him being a wanker Fish Axl is extremely talented, amazing actually, he is very unusual and a extreme perfectionist, that bad that if the sound speakers weren't up it at a concert he'd walk off, weird i know.

 

[Ron Jeremy]

So people have said here, unfortunately asides from a "carbon" issue no one has been able to explain why he is a wanker or a douche..

probably his childhood?

Can you believe that Axl was in his church choir at school:crazy:

 

[simmo1]

So people have said here, unfortunately asides from a "carbon" issue no one has been able to explain why he is a wanker or a douche..

Because he comes across as a pretentious git.

 

[Eelementary]

Mikael Akerfeldt, of Opeth. Just because he's not famous doesn't mean he's not a genius.

He writes music (not just metal; he writes acoustic pieces, metal, gothic-influenced pieces...his versatility is amazing).

He sings.

He growls.

 

[carcharias]

probably his childhood?

Can you believe that Axl was in his church choir at school:crazy:

so what.


Tim Rogers was school Captain .