Amos Roberts

[blueshark]

Well penrith have not signed him yet and if we are looking at a goal kicking winger we could do worse.

 

[Dr. Funkenstein]

i dout that they will let him go he has been good.
would be good but though must improove his defence

 

[blueshark]

Depends if they have a option i would think if not he could go where he wants.

 

[Sharkies all the Way]

I dont think we would be in race, I think 1000 other clubs would also like him including Penrith. El Masri is a possible option.

 

[Booyah]

He'll stay at Penrith.

Understandable loyalty since they threw him a lifeline.

 

[ali]

I'd throw some mega bucks at him. I think he is top class. Could fill almost every spot in the backline and kick goals. I think he should be target number 1.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Could not agree more ALI
He would have to be the number 1 target for all clubs.
Unbelievable game the other night.
& it is a pleasure to finaly see someone in the NRL with distance in their kicking.
Great kickers are = to another player on the field.

 

[Dragon Slayer]

Yes Amos Roberts is certainly one of the most improved players this year.
If we released Peachey these are the type of players we could have in our backline next year.

Wouldn't Amos get them through the gates........15 tries already this year!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

No, if we keep Peachey we can fit players like this in the salary cap.
Also, how many would be packed in to watch a a peachey/ Roberts combo.

Spoken like the closet stgeorge supporter you are.

 

[Dragon Slayer]

Amos Roberts plays for Penrith................. :lol: :roll:

 

[blacktip-reefy]

& you support St George.
I am even surprised you would want a nother black man here, with your hatred towards our current black man.

 

[Macca]

Our current black man? Last time I looked there was more than one.

 

[Dragon Slayer]

Where have I said I don't want him playing next year because he is black?

Where have I said I support St.George?

 

[Mr Angry]

Amos would look great in Sharks colours.

 

[millersnose]

the fued erupts again

so far reefy has attacked DS implying racism and queens support

DS has challenged reefy to back his claim

ball in reefys court................

 

[PJ]

Where have I said I don't want him playing next year because he is black?

Where have I said I support St.George?

You disagree so you need to be discredited.

Simple really

 

[Macca]

DS, don't you get it? You are going against the TUBE. There fore you must be wrong. Atleast, all the tube members think so. ;-)

 

[blacktip-reefy]

It must be a black thing. There is no other logical reason for wanting peachy gone.
All of your reasons have been thoroughly discredited.

Age. No issue
fitness. No issue
Form. No issue
Cost. No issue

so by continuing with anti Peach sentiments, what is the "real" reason? Are you really a St Geo supporter or is it a race thing?

 

[Macca]

Are you completely missing DS's argument here Reefy?

I disagree with DS about Peachey but I thought it was obvious that his reasoning for wanting Peachey gone is that he believes that that salary cap portion could be used to lure a younger fullback that is already reasonably established with the potential to take over where Peachey has left off.

I want to keep Peachey but I can see where DS is coming from. I just think he is a year early. He is thouroughly entitled to that opinion and your continued attacks on him are just another example of your bullying tactics.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Mcshark. Get fugged.

there is no salary cap issue.peachey helps the salary cap. Do the sums.
Someone has to play fullback. A fullback costs money or r u saying that we play with out a fullback.
We are basically getting the a top level fullback for 100k by having peachey.
An Established full back will cost 150-200k, if there are any available.
Salary cap is stupid, ridiculous argument in the peachey issue.
As is the argument, when do the sharks use the entire cap. They do so every year.
My attacks on him are completely justified & I want him to answer.
All of his arguments for sacking peachey have been 100% discredited, so why does he want him gone? is it a race thing?