What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

An American face-to-face with rugby league

nqboy

First Grade
Messages
8,914
LINK
By Chico Harlan
October 19, 2007 12:00am

US sportswriter Chico Harlan had his first taste of rugby league this week. From a bar stool, he received an education.
I BELIEVE it's a little-known matter of Constitutional policy that Americans (and I'm guilty as charged) must spend at least several hours every weekend watching great spasms of brutality on television. We call this football. For almost every weekend of my life, I've watched this sport in steady, unhealthy quantities.

But two weeks ago, I moved to Sydney for a six-month reporter's contract with The Daily Telegraph. That means receiving an education on the sporting differences between two countries separated by 14 time zones, one hemisphere and one brand of footy.

So last Sunday, I watched my first rugby league match, and the good afternoon of human collisions - as Australia battled, and dismembered, New Zealand - made this American feel right at home.

The basic concepts of rugby league translate quite well - even when a viewer has little clue about the nuances. After all, when you're watching a foreign movie scene with gunfire, you don't tend to require subtitles. For two hours, one American hunkered down at a Sydney bar (hotel) and watched eight Aussie rookies (debutants) take over the game (match).

The action entertained, and sometimes even marvelled. While watching, I found myself continually trying to complete this sentence: Aussie footballers make their US counterparts look like: Wimps? Pacifists? Tweed-wearing professors? A cocktail party collection of playwrights who wouldn't fight one another for the last piece of tuna tartare? Never did find an appropriate answer.

Though rugby league operates on similar principles to US football - one imposing group of men pushes forward, another imposing group resists - it redefines the brutality, raising it so high into the stratosphere that you feel not repulsed by it, but mesmerised. Players collide into one another (again and again, and very willingly) at breakneck speeds. Without helmets. Without pads of any sort. Wearing nothing but high-riding shorts, like an Italian's bathing trunks.

Perhaps the collisions are more tangible than in US football because here, you actually see the players' faces. You see them grimace and grin and bleed. You start to feel almost like you know them, at least until they're carried off on stretchers. For me, it scarcely mattered that all the Kangaroos, based on their uniform design, were identified across their backs by the same curious surname: PlayStation.

Rugby of any variety - league or union - still hasn't caught on in the States, likely because football owns such a commanding grip on the male attention span. At the college level back home, rugby isn't recognised as a sanctioned sport.

On this side of the planet, fans of losing World Cup teams demand the sacking their coaches. Over there, US fans wouldn't even know the name of the coach to sack.

This particular footy match, of course, was neither competitive nor dramatic. I watched the final half, with the winner already decided, only to gain greater understanding about rugby league's rules and details.

Gotta say, almost everything made perfect sense. At least so long as you don't worry about those missing helmets.
 
Messages
1,024
Great article!

Never really been a fan of gridiron - always thought it was quite soft when you compare it to league especially in the "non-protective gear" stakes. Too many pauses and stop/starts as well.

Given the fact that a lot of american sports lovers love their brutality in sport, If most of them took the time, or had better opportinuties to watch league, I'm sure they would love it

 
Messages
14,139
Millions of Americans would probably enjoy rugby league. Shame most will never see it because the NRL doesn't want them to. They know if the US ever got into RL In a big way it would potentially take over.
 

Godz Illa

Coach
Messages
18,745
Enjoyable piece. One undeniable fact we can garner from that article, regarding the differences between AUS and USA - they have better sportswriters. That's the best rugby league story the Telegraph have run in years.
 

Johnny Bravo

Juniors
Messages
489
The Mighty Panther said:
Great article!

Never really been a fan of gridiron - always thought it was quite soft when you compare it to league especially in the "non-protective gear" stakes. Too many pauses and stop/starts as well.

Given the fact that a lot of american sports lovers love their brutality in sport, If most of them took the time, or had better opportinuties to watch league, I'm sure they would love it

Every play is just going for the biggest hit possible though. You get to see some pretty brutal hits in the NFL. Without padding almost every hit would require a player getting stretchered off. Without padding, gridiron would be a boring spectacle IMO. It makes for some good highlight reels.
 

Simo

First Grade
Messages
6,702
East Coast Tiger said:
Millions of Americans would probably enjoy rugby league. Shame most will never see it because the NRL doesn't want them to. They know if the US ever got into RL In a big way it would potentially take over.

lol yeah thats the reason the game isnt taking off in the US.....
 

taste2taste

Bench
Messages
2,889
We can all agree here that rugby league is the greatest game on earth. It has every thing other sports are mssing, its non stop action.
So it amazes me that for the last 100 years league has only caught on in the northern eastern states of australia, the north of england and slowly catching on in the north of NZ.
Something must be very wrong with the spreading of the game, we've got the best product on earth and havnt been able to sell it..have we even tried to sell it? Surley places that play rugby eg:Sth Africa, lower half of NZ, France..etc are areas league could attract new veiwers and players, they're already aware of the bascics through rugby and surley could be sold a supeiror product, and thats all lague is a supeiror version of union.
Look how agressive union has been here in Australia and England. They continually raid our players which brings a huge amount of attention to their game, we've all tuned in to a wallabies game to see how lote or rogers is going. Why dosnt league do the same. Lets go after Jerry Collins from the all blacks, he's said on numerous occasions he'd consider a switch, what about Bryan Habana, a switch from him would gain the amount of attention money couldnt buy. During the week the tigers almost signed all black centre Nonu, the deal fell through and it would have been nice if the NRL helped the tigers out a bit, alot of hardend rugby fans in NZ would have tuned in to see him play league, and isnt that how you get new fans, by getting them to tune into the sport?
I hate to mention super league but wasnt that one of their big ideas, the 'global league' a team in every major city around the world. Would have been interesting to see how succsesfull they would have been.
Any way i'll get off my soap box now, what brought this rant on was the american writer saying how much he licked the game..could league catch on in america? i guess we'll never know.
 

Kurt Angle

First Grade
Messages
9,749
I can't recall Collins ever mooting a switch, some other all-blacks have vocalised about contemplating a change, but I've never heard of Collins being one of them.

There'd be no reason in Habana ever consider changing.

We aren't drastically poorer than RU, but we spread the money amongst more players.

The only RU players we can consider would be Piiri Wepu, and maybe O'Driscoll at the end of his RU playing career, and if he decided he wanted to run around for a while... then he really wouldn't be good enough, it'd only be a PR move.
 

B-Tron 3000

Juniors
Messages
1,803
Good article?

Anyone could have written that. Didn't even need to be a yank.

It explains nothing of the differences between the games, or what is required of the players. It was simplistic nonsense about the use or non-use of pads - which is basically the first thing anyone notices. A 6 year old can talk about the fact that the players don't have pads.

The only decent observation was that without the helmets you seem to get to know the players better.

Rubbish article.
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
East Coast Tiger said:
Millions of Americans would probably enjoy rugby league. Shame most will never see it because the NRL doesn't want them to. They know if the US ever got into RL In a big way it would potentially take over.

I hope you didnt write that with a straight face
 

Azkatro

First Grade
Messages
6,905
East Coast Tiger said:
Millions of Americans would probably enjoy rugby league. Shame most will never see it because the NRL doesn't want them to. They know if the US ever got into RL In a big way it would potentially take over.
Maybe if you could stop the inbreeding first ... did I just say that?
 

eels_fan_01

Bench
Messages
3,470
I always laugh when people say Americans would be good at rugby league because they are big and athletic. Ive seen big and athletic blokes be the worst players going around.
 

perverse

Referee
Messages
27,384
Natalie's Daddy said:
He has missed the point though. League is not a game of brutality. It is a game of finesse (sp?)
tell that to brett stewart a few weeks back. it would have been a waste of time though.. all you would have gotten was a blank look.. maybe some drool out the side of his mouth.

hang on a minute.. a good article in the telesh!te? brace yourselves people, i think we've crossed into the end times.
 

Coaster

Bench
Messages
3,162
I was in the states a few years ago, and downloaded and let them watch a State of Origin, these blokes all from Texas and big burly fellas, was tranfixed with it, they all wanted jumpers and everything i could get my hands on.

It was the SOO that Devere got the stapler to the head, even i found that hardcore, they were just atstounded.
 

brooksy19

Bench
Messages
3,683
curious said:
I was in the states a few years ago, and downloaded and let them watch a State of Origin, these blokes all from Texas and big burly fellas, was tranfixed with it, they all wanted jumpers and everything i could get my hands on.

It was the SOO that Devere got the stapler to the head, even i found that hardcore, they were just atstounded.

Haha awesome, anyone got a clip of that ?
 
Top