What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Aust v India Test Series 24/25 Revenge or India three peat ?

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
50,430
I'd play Boland at da G in da boxing day test.

Starc plays with the pinky in Adelaide.

Hazelwood is our man most prone to breakdowns so I'd give him a spell somewhere.

I'm not counting on Marsh to bowl any more than 10 overs of his tripe per test.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
103,042
Rotation is BS unless for some reason the player needs it. Horses for courses, absolutely but f**k rotation policies to death with Trevor Hohns' pecker
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,525
I am warming to Inglis opening the batting as long as he can field.

Let's be honest all the current options are trash I rather roll the dice on proven international players who can take the attack a bit to India.

Harris and Bancroft are just going to prod and plod there way to ugly 20s at most anyway.
 

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
50,430
I am warming to Inglis opening the batting as long as he can field.

Let's be honest all the current options are trash I rather roll the dice on proven international players who can take the attack a bit to India.

Harris and Bancroft are just going to prod and plod there way to ugly 20s at most anyway.
Inglis would be in slips although I've got no doubt golden boy marsh will have one spot in the cordon just so he doesn't have to run too far.

Green will be a huge loss in the field not devouring everything that moves in the gully.
 

icewind

Juniors
Messages
2,282
Nice idea, poorly thought through IMO.

Part-time ODI opener does not a test opener make. He is more suited to the middle order against spin. I would prefer Marnus to partner Ussie in that case. Hell, even Marsh would be more suited.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
103,042
I think that sometimes, if you need a makeshift opener, someone from that 6 or 7 position can almost be a better bet because they often face the second new ball. Ofc it's still different to the fresh, first over opening quicks.

I don't think Inglis is the guy though
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,949
I was always in favour of letting Marnus open and having Smith back at 3. We've got better options available in the middle order and its been that way for a while now. The specialists openers aren't doing enough to get the gig.

But as far as I can tell that has never been a consideration for selectors. They don't want to move Marnus. Or perhaps Marnus doesn't want to move. But he is a weirdo who needs to be told what to do e.g. no toasties in your pocket, no silly noises when fielding etc.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,525
I was always in favour of letting Marnus open and having Smith back at 3. We've got better options available in the middle order and its been that way for a while now. The specialists openers aren't doing enough to get the gig.

But as far as I can tell that has never been a consideration for selectors. They don't want to move Marnus. Or perhaps Marnus doesn't want to move. But he is a weirdo who needs to be told what to do e.g. no toasties in your pocket, no silly noises when fielding etc.
After watching Marnus on the fletch/hindy skit a few weeks back where they had him on the lie detector test

I reckon he may less weird then Smith.

I saw more personality from Marnus there then what you generally get off Smudge.

He is still weird but i don't think he cares that people find him that way for loving Cricket so much.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
103,042
After watching Marnus on the fletch/hindy skit a few weeks back where they had him on the lie detector test

I reckon he may less weird then Smith.

I saw more personality from Marnus there then what you generally get off Smudge.

He is still weird but i don't think he cares that people find him that way for loving Cricket so much.

Smith is intensely weird.

Marcus is unhinged weird.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,949
We have them covered.

Our prep is good. Maybe the best it's been in years. We don't have any Ashes hangover to deal with so they are well rested. And everyone is getting some shield time or one day cricket at a minimum.

And right now India are looking at a home series loss to NZ. Half the country wil be burning effigies of Rohit Sharma if they lose the second test.

Btw have India ever played a 5 test away series before? I can't recall it happening. It's going to be a very long summer for them. I look forward to it.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,525
For all our issues

India have there legends in decline with the bat.

Rohit is 37 years of age averaging 31 this year

Kohli will be 36 next week and averaging 27 this year.

Ashwin is 38 years old and averaging 26 with the ball above his usual.

It's going to be a series where it seems everyone is slowly over the hill.
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
68,402
Sobering thoughts for both India (Kholi) and Australia (Smith)

Pakistan dropped their best batsman last 10 years after 1st test loss to poms - Pak won series 2-1

Kiwis without their best batsman last 10 years in Williamson , beat India in India 2-0

Dont think Smith or Kholi get dropped this summer,...

So my conclusion is...., who is coming with me in the dead of night before the first test, to amputate both Steve Smiths thumbs ?
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,525
Whose there to replace Smudge outside Inglis.

We don't have any quality batting depth coming through atm anywhere knocking the door down to replace these blokes.

McSweeny is young and wouldn't mind seeing what he has to offer but his numbers ain't exactly knocking the door down.

Konstas is 12 months away for mine.
 

bazza

Immortal
Messages
30,963
McSweeny is young and wouldn't mind seeing what he has to offer but his numbers ain't exactly knocking the door down.

Konstas is 12 months away for mine.
based on previous history they will give McSweeny this series and put Konstas in if/when he fails or the series is over
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
103,042
Whose there to replace Smudge outside Inglis.

We don't have any quality batting depth coming through atm anywhere knocking the door down to replace these blokes.

McSweeny is young and wouldn't mind seeing what he has to offer but his numbers ain't exactly knocking the door down.

Konstas is 12 months away for mine.

Well I mean no one is knocking the door down like you said but IIRC McSweeney averages 50-odd over the past 2 shield seasons or so? He's also a very good fielder and an excellent leader from what you see of him

More than that, he just looks a player too. He plays patient and late and compact. Maybe he's not the guy, but he's a guy who deserves a shot IMO
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
68,402
What ever happened to this bloke?

Was the next big thing when he toured here few years ago

Prithvi Shaw

Is 24yo,

but looks 34 and like a random player from the Euro Championships


1730365148531.png
 

Latest posts

Top