B.A. Baracus
Juniors
- Messages
- 197
Stranger said:To be fair, you have to give a player more than 6 games to adjust to a new position. Its not something that can be learned or taught over night. The Hornby/head combo would fall apart within an instant IMO. Hornby and Head do all the little things right, but neither are a dominate player IMO, like a Barrett or a Gaz. Head in my opinion is a great half, and from my knowledge Dragons let go clint greenshields to the titans? Thus they need a fullback. Hornby is an excellent fullback and fill in halfback imo.
People criticise brownie, but he has done a great job for the dragons IMO. They always fall short, but take last year. They were playing without their halfback for 75% of the season and they had a tampon playing 5/8. Don't know how many teams could cope with that.
Gaz is the best attacking player ball in hand bar none IMO. We will have to wait and see who has the vision to become the 5/8ths but IMO its stupid to move ur best players from their positions. I am against what the Dragons are doing, what melb are doing and what the Broncos did with locky, but we will just have to wait to see what works for them.
So - just to play Devil's Advocate here - if, say you are a Dragons fan - and your side is 0-6 after 6 games - and playing like a bunch of stiffs....
Do you stick with Gasnier at 6 because he needs the time to adjust (Which you're spot on with) - or do you get him the hell out of there?!?! The NRL is 'The Quick & the Dead' these days - you don't have much margin for error between success & disaster! And teams will be running their forwards at Gasnier and tiring him out in defence all day long in the halves - which will blunt some of his attacking ability - as will the responsibility of having to worry about those around him - as well as himself - as will having to assume some of the kicking duties! Therefore you now have a player that is only 2/3rds of the ball runner he used to be able to be - and a Kicker/Playmaker with L-Plates hanging around his neck! Look, Gasnier is a FINE footballer - but this is all a big ask - even for Superman!
Do you see why I say Brown is taking such a tremendous risk here? Playing with fire, and I can't help but feel he is going to get burned...