What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ben Hunt requests release from the Drags

This Year?

Immortal
Messages
35,784
TPJ > Panthers
SBW > Rorters
Oloapu > Dogs
Souffs land Wighton for '24 on less money

And yet all of a sudden, as soon as Brisbane look to land a big fish, OMFG SCANDAL CRISIS HOW CAN THIS HAPPEN TERRIBLE LOOK...

I honestly don't know why I'm so surprised.
I think what makes it extraordinary is that none of those players were the highest paid, captain of the club and looking to return to the club that they left.
Personally I don't have a problem with it as long as it's all above board.
 

THE CHAMP

First Grade
Messages
8,359
I think what makes it extraordinary is that none of those players were the highest paid, captain of the club and looking to return to the club that they left.
Personally I don't have a problem with it as long as it's all above board.
I think what makes it extraordinary is that none of those players were the highest paid, captain of the club and looking to return to the club that they left.
Personally I don't have a problem with it as long as it's all above board.
Exactly.
And because it's the Broncos you know everything is above board
 

Mojo

Bench
Messages
4,122
Any way you dice it, the optics of the best player in the lowest ranked side leaving mid season to play for the top ranked side, well they aren't great.
Yes. We’ve sent Ben a thank you card.
 

dannyt

Coach
Messages
14,491
Please post where I have done this
You mean this?
1687813603492.png
The two examples stated of this occurring during this thread are Gaz and TPJ, and your above quote could refer to either, both, or a completely different example. Given the context of the discussion of Brisbane trying to get Hunt from St George, it is entirely reasonable to conclude you were referring to Gaz in 2010, but certainly equivocal as per this amended post:
The above was in response to this statement “It was bullshit when Gasnier returned to the Dragons for 50k”
Context, you were trying to draw parallels to Hunt where there are none. So it was a response to Gasnier coming back for a portion of the year. I’ll ask again, which NRL club was he coming from?
Edited
If I have mistaken/misunderstood your intent, apologies. But I am in no doubt that’s what you meant.
Gaz come back to us around June 2010 from the union team Staide Francais. He signed a 4 1/2 year deal, so the intent wasn't to only play in 2010 to bag a premiership, which appears to be the whole point of the attempted Hunt transfer. Gaz was good enough to play in all three SOO in 2011, but announced his retirement in July 2011. Ironically, his last game was against Brisbane in the 2011 semi-final loss.
 
Last edited:

THE CHAMP

First Grade
Messages
8,359
Also I should state, I could go either way on Hunt, yes he could help propel Broncos if he played 9 and could be a backup for Reynolds, But I also think there is a chance he could hinder the harmony the squad has now.
It's also a big kick in the teethe for the guys who have worked so hard to get Broncos back to title challengers and he just comes in on the coat tales.
This. Christ I'm 50/50 on him coming back.

The main concern for me is how many players has the club told the cap is maxed out only to find 2-3 hundred K for Benny?
 

gerg

Juniors
Messages
2,491
I suspect Benny will see off 2023 at St George, and then he'll be off to the club that can give us the best deal.

How does that even happen now? He is signed until the end of 2025 (? is it) so clubs can't talk to him until November next year? Saints will probably allow him to negotiate at the end of the year or whenever it suits them I guess. Will be an interesting off-season of trading for Flanagan.
 

dannyt

Coach
Messages
14,491
How does that even happen now? He is signed until the end of 2025 (? is it) so clubs can't talk to him until November next year? Saints will probably allow him to negotiate at the end of the year or whenever it suits them I guess. Will be an interesting off-season of trading for Flanagan.
Clubs are, supposedly, not allowed to talk to players and discuss financial terms while the player is under contract. The club can get involved and discuss terms with other clubs, in conjunction with the player and manager, and if a consensus is reached, the contract is null and void. St George's stance that Benny honour his contract until the end of 2025 puts them in a better position to negotiate now. If St George can get a good deal, Benny will probably go.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
34,315
Gus thinks he will just end up playing out his remaining two years at the dragons then retiring back home

it’s not like the titans are a premiership force anyway

on whose the better coach going forward Hasler or flanghan it’s hard to say
 

Gardenia

Bench
Messages
2,832
Gus thinks he will just end up playing out his remaining two years at the dragons then retiring back home

it’s not like the titans are a premiership force anyway

on whose the better coach going forward Hasler or flanghan it’s hard to say
Yeah Gus might be right or he might be just saying that so it all dies down and he can make his moves
 

blaza88z

Coach
Messages
15,186
I still think he looks to get out, reminds me a bit of the Payne Haas saga with us last season I think it was.

For months many fans started to look at Payne through a different set of glasses but he kept his head down and put in while wearing the jersey and now he's back onside with those fans. A lot of it will depend on how Hunt performs. I got no doubt a few Dragons fans will be having mixed emotions after what has happened.

The most likely outcome is that the Dragons and Titans sort it out over the off season, maybe a player swap or something. They can't afford to lose a player like Ben Hunt.
 

This Year?

Immortal
Messages
35,784
After merkin's aerobics instructor antics I don't why he hasn't been shot out of a cannon into the sun.
 
Last edited:

Saxon

Bench
Messages
3,187
The club is absolutely responsible for the state that it’s in. The worst decision they made (and it’s a strong field) was to pay elite money for a precious little merkin like Hunt, and then make him the captain.

Now that we’re in a situation where he wants out, we’re much better off using his contract as a bargaining chip to try to improve our roster, rather than just raising the white flag and letting him walk.

Honestly, does anyone actually think he’s going to be with us next year? He’s gone. The rest is just details, and the club would be doubling down on its shitf**kery if it didn’t try to get something in return for letting him go.
The problem of course is that - based on recent history - what will actually happen is that the Dragons board will f*ck it up again.
 

Latest posts

Top