Indeed, there are two very different stories getting around.
One of them is coming from "Miss X" – the woman who claims Cartwright and former Panthers player and family friend, Lou Zivanovic, bullied her into aborting the child – via News Corp.
The other story comes from numerous sources, and not exclusively out of Penrith, and it paints an entirely different set of circumstances to the one that has been reported so far.
Why isn't that story being reported?
Because the game, the club and the media itself are so sensitive about a backlash when being critical of a woman. A public slanging match – as Panthers boss Phil Gould described it – will just drag this situation further into the mud.