AzzA84
Juniors
- Messages
- 82
A lot of people you talk to rate the Dragons squad as the best in the league so i decided to compare both sides rating them without being biast...
1 Patten (8.5) v Hornby (8.5) [Both pretty good would have Patten though slighty over Hornby]
2 El Masri (8.5) v Best (7.5) [Havent seen much of Best but he wasnt that great at the sharks would pefer El Masri even without his star goal kicking]
3 Lolesi (8.5) v Gasnier (8.5) [Personally i would have Lolesi because Gasnier is always injuried but all in all both are qualities players, although most would rate Gasnier better]
4 Tonga (9.5) v Cooper (8.5) [Tonga is a gun and would beat any centre he came up againest at this point in time, so he gets the nod above Cooper even though Cooper is a very classy Centre]
5 Utai (9.5) v Simmonds (7.5) [Utai is the best winger in the game for mine and Simmonds comes no where close]
6 Anasta (9) v Barrett (9) [Really cant split these two both are very good players, i would have Barrett for the rep games and Anasta for the club games]
7 Sherwin (9) v Head (9) [Again both top halfback i really do like Matthew Head, but i would still not swap Brent Sherwin for any other halfback he is a legend when on song]
8 O'Meley (9.5) v Ryles (9) [Shrek is a awesome prop who i wouldnt swop for any other prop, in saying that Ryles is very good when he is on the field]
9 Perry (7.5) v Ennis (8.5) [Perry is very good defensively but average in attack, i havent seen much of Ennis but from what i have seen he does look the goods so he would be ahead of Perry]
10 Mason (9.5) v Bailey (9.5) [Both extrodinary players, i would have Luke Bailey in any side i choose let it be for Australia or whoever he is awesome, but in saying that we all know how good Mason is also, so they would be equal]
11 Sonny Bill Williams (10) v Young (8 ) [SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close]
12 Ryan (9.5) v Thompson (9) [Both very good players but i would have Ryan for sure. Ryan is a great player and leader]
13 Grimaldi (8 ) v Timmins (9) [I would have Timmins over Grimaldi but im not taking away anything from Grimaldi]
Bench
14 Maitua (8.5) v Creagh (8 )
15 Hughes (8 ) v Manu (8 )
16 Asotasi (9) v Sims (8 )
17 Cwzlowski (7.5) v Poore (8 )
All in all from the 17 players the highest score being 170...
The scores were...
Bulldogs - 149.5 from 170
Dragons - 143.5 from 170
So i would rate the Doggies better than the Dragons, how do other people see it what are your opinions and thoughts?
If i had to choose a side from the Dragons and Bulldogs this would be my hybrid team...
1 Patten, 2 El Masri, 3 Lolesi, 4 Tonga, 5 Utai, 6 Barrett, 7 Sherwin, 8 O'Meley, 9 Ennis, 10 Bailey, 11 Mason, 12 Ryan, 13 Anasta. Bench 14 SBW, 15 Asotasi, 16 Ryles, 17 Head.
12 Bulldogs
5 Dragons
1 Patten (8.5) v Hornby (8.5) [Both pretty good would have Patten though slighty over Hornby]
2 El Masri (8.5) v Best (7.5) [Havent seen much of Best but he wasnt that great at the sharks would pefer El Masri even without his star goal kicking]
3 Lolesi (8.5) v Gasnier (8.5) [Personally i would have Lolesi because Gasnier is always injuried but all in all both are qualities players, although most would rate Gasnier better]
4 Tonga (9.5) v Cooper (8.5) [Tonga is a gun and would beat any centre he came up againest at this point in time, so he gets the nod above Cooper even though Cooper is a very classy Centre]
5 Utai (9.5) v Simmonds (7.5) [Utai is the best winger in the game for mine and Simmonds comes no where close]
6 Anasta (9) v Barrett (9) [Really cant split these two both are very good players, i would have Barrett for the rep games and Anasta for the club games]
7 Sherwin (9) v Head (9) [Again both top halfback i really do like Matthew Head, but i would still not swap Brent Sherwin for any other halfback he is a legend when on song]
8 O'Meley (9.5) v Ryles (9) [Shrek is a awesome prop who i wouldnt swop for any other prop, in saying that Ryles is very good when he is on the field]
9 Perry (7.5) v Ennis (8.5) [Perry is very good defensively but average in attack, i havent seen much of Ennis but from what i have seen he does look the goods so he would be ahead of Perry]
10 Mason (9.5) v Bailey (9.5) [Both extrodinary players, i would have Luke Bailey in any side i choose let it be for Australia or whoever he is awesome, but in saying that we all know how good Mason is also, so they would be equal]
11 Sonny Bill Williams (10) v Young (8 ) [SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close]
12 Ryan (9.5) v Thompson (9) [Both very good players but i would have Ryan for sure. Ryan is a great player and leader]
13 Grimaldi (8 ) v Timmins (9) [I would have Timmins over Grimaldi but im not taking away anything from Grimaldi]
Bench
14 Maitua (8.5) v Creagh (8 )
15 Hughes (8 ) v Manu (8 )
16 Asotasi (9) v Sims (8 )
17 Cwzlowski (7.5) v Poore (8 )
All in all from the 17 players the highest score being 170...
The scores were...
Bulldogs - 149.5 from 170
Dragons - 143.5 from 170
So i would rate the Doggies better than the Dragons, how do other people see it what are your opinions and thoughts?
If i had to choose a side from the Dragons and Bulldogs this would be my hybrid team...
1 Patten, 2 El Masri, 3 Lolesi, 4 Tonga, 5 Utai, 6 Barrett, 7 Sherwin, 8 O'Meley, 9 Ennis, 10 Bailey, 11 Mason, 12 Ryan, 13 Anasta. Bench 14 SBW, 15 Asotasi, 16 Ryles, 17 Head.
12 Bulldogs
5 Dragons
