Bulldogs v Dragons (Which do you rate higher)

[Jimbo]

South Sydney 30
St George-Illawarra 6

Bulldogs 40
South Sydney 16

If you use Souths as a marker, the Bulldogs are a 48-point better side...

 

[Sterling]

11 Sonny Bill Williams (10) v Young (8 ) [SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close]



best 2nd rower? ...... :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

forgot about hindmarsh now did we?

 

[Sterling]

So you dont rate any of Manly's Ex Parramatta Players

Scott Donald, Michael Witt, Shanye Dunley, Daniel Heckenberg, Nathan Hollingworth cant think of anymore at hand...


I would have to say Michael Witt is a good player and so is Daniel Heckenberg, Donald has pace but not much defence and the other two are rubbish!!

But Phillips more importantly have you got anymore Andrew Ryan's or Willie Tonga's Brian Smith thinks are rubbish and wants to send our way? We need a talented Hooker maybe you could send us a hooker maybe even PJ Marsh, or can Marcus Perenara or Tim Smith play hooker?

anymore andrew ryans? .... pretty happy with hindmarsh and morrison in our back row ... thanx! .. you can keep ryan :lol: :lol:

 

[Raiders Plight]

11 Sonny Bill Williams (10) v Young (8 ) [SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close]



best 2nd rower? ...... :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

forgot about hindmarsh now did we?

Gordon Tallis is the best 2nd rower i ever saw with Brad clyde being the best lock. Sonny Boy has a lot to do before he's up there with those 2.

 

[Dragon_psa]

11 Sonny Bill Williams (10) v Young (8 ) [SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close]



best 2nd rower? ...... :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

forgot about hindmarsh now did we?

Gordon Tallis is the best 2nd rower i ever saw with Brad clyde being the best lock. Sonny Boy has a lot to do before he's up there with those 2.

Agreed Plight - SBW has yet to cement himself truly. Hindmarsh wouldn't be far off Tallis though.

 

[God-King Dean]

SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close

Well you've just confirmed that he's over-rated. Greatest 2nd-rower after 10-15 games :!:

 

[AzzA84]

So you dont rate any of Manly's Ex Parramatta Players

Scott Donald, Michael Witt, Shanye Dunley, Daniel Heckenberg, Nathan Hollingworth cant think of anymore at hand...


I would have to say Michael Witt is a good player and so is Daniel Heckenberg, Donald has pace but not much defence and the other two are rubbish!!

But Phillips more importantly have you got anymore Andrew Ryan's or Willie Tonga's Brian Smith thinks are rubbish and wants to send our way? We need a talented Hooker maybe you could send us a hooker maybe even PJ Marsh, or can Marcus Perenara or Tim Smith play hooker?

anymore andrew ryans? .... pretty happy with hindmarsh and morrison in our back row ... thanx! .. you can keep ryan :lol: :lol:

I will gladly keep Ryan, he is a gun, so is hindmarsh but you had both imagine a combo 2nd row of Hindmarsh and Ryan it would have killed it as it did in Origin.

This would be your possible linup if you kept your guns...

1. B.Hodsgon or C.Schifcofske
2. L.Burt or M.Petersen or S.Kelly
3. J.Lyon or D.Vaealiki
4. W.Tonga Or A.Mogg
5. E.Grothe or J.Moodie
6. M.Witt or C.McGuire
7. PJ Marsh
8 N.Cayless Or Daniel Heckenberg
9 J.Morris Or Brad Drew
10 J.Cayless Or Michael Vella Or A.Chan
11 N.Hindmarsh
12 I.Hindmarsh Or D.Solamon
13 A.Ryan Or D.Wagon


My Strongest team would be...that is not including all the imports you have bought this year and last you bought duds so they wouldnt have made it anyways.

1. B.Hodsgon
2. D.Vaealiki
3. J.Lyon
4. W.Tonga
5. E.Grothe
6. M.Witt
7. PJ Marsh
8 N.Cayless
9 J.Morris
10 J.Cayless
11 N.Hindmarsh
12 I.Hindmarsh
13 A.Ryan

14 M.Vella
15 D.Soloman
16 D.Heckenberg
17 C.Schifcofske

So yeah thats why i was asking if Brian Smith had any so called rubbish played ready to throw out so we could pick them up and show there full potential.


:lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[AzzA84]

SBW best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome, Young doesnt even come close

Well you've just confirmed that he's over-rated. Greatest 2nd-rower after 10-15 games :!:

As i said "best 2nd rower i have ever seen is awesome" for the time that i have seen him he is the best 2nd rower i have ever seen, if i had seen Tallis for this short period of time and he was doing the same things as SBW at the same age i would have thought the same and i would rate him the same. SBW still has to keep it going though to be even considered the Best Of All Time but for now he is the Best I Have Seen in my eyes for his age and on ability, but i agree with you that he isnt a Tallis or Hindmarsh yet...but he will be and far beyond i believe

 

[TRANSLATION]

South Sydney 30
St George-Illawarra 6

Bulldogs 40
South Sydney 16

If you use Souths as a marker, the Bulldogs are a 48-point better side...

Clutching at Straws ?? :lol: :lol: 8)

 

[Raiders Plight]

Clyde won the clive churchill at 19 and played for NSW and Australia. Not trying to disparage SBW but its not like he's going over unchartered territory.

 

[Jimbo]

South Sydney 30
St George-Illawarra 6

Bulldogs 40
South Sydney 16

If you use Souths as a marker, the Bulldogs are a 48-point better side...

Clutching at Straws ?? :lol: :lol: 8)

We'll see who's clutching what after Round 1, won't we?

 

[Southernsaint]

South Sydney 30
St George-Illawarra 6

Bulldogs 40
South Sydney 16

If you use Souths as a marker, the Bulldogs are a 48-point better side...

Clutching at Straws ?? :lol: :lol: 8)

We'll see who's clutching what after Round 1, won't we?

You're always clutching it, Jimbo ;-)

And you will be after the 38th year passes you by...

 

[Jimbo]

Time will tell, as always.

Speaking of, when do you expect Anderson to take over from the Waterboy?

 

[Southernsaint]

Time will tell, as always.

Speaking of, when do you expect Anderson to take over from the Waterboy?

No idea.

"If Anderson goes, we are in very deep trouble." :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[AzzA84]

Clyde won the clive churchill at 19 and played for NSW and Australia. Not trying to disparage SBW but its not like he's going over unchartered territory.

Well at least Clyde is another CANTERBURY LEGEND!! hahahaha jokes man, i just always tease my raiders mate about it, love to stir it up alittle.

 

[Jimbo]

"If Anderson goes, we are in very deep trouble." :lol: :lol: :lol:

I was right.

What's funny?

 

[TRANSLATION]

South Sydney 30
St George-Illawarra 6

Bulldogs 40
South Sydney 16

If you use Souths as a marker, the Bulldogs are a 48-point better side...

Clutching at Straws ?? :lol: :lol: 8)

We'll see who's clutching what after Round 1, won't we?

You're always clutching it, Jimbo ;-)

And you will be after the 38th year passes you by...

Shit your Confident saints will do well, if you only want to judge us up to round 1.

What about the rest of the season ??

Is grandpa still playing ??.. Sir J S

 

[Jimbo]

sh*t your Confident saints will do well, if you only want to judge us up to round 1.

What about the rest of the season ??

Is grandpa still playing ??.. Sir J S

The thread is about the Bulldogs and Dragons.

I believe the Dragons have to play a few other teams after that...

 

[gregstar]

you're right jimbo - this is a dogs-dragons thread

out of interest, who would we compare the sharks to?
glebe?
cumberland?
university?
annandale?
bye?

 

[Sterling]

So you dont rate any of Manly's Ex Parramatta Players

Scott Donald, Michael Witt, Shanye Dunley, Daniel Heckenberg, Nathan Hollingworth cant think of anymore at hand...


I would have to say Michael Witt is a good player and so is Daniel Heckenberg, Donald has pace but not much defence and the other two are rubbish!!

But Phillips more importantly have you got anymore Andrew Ryan's or Willie Tonga's Brian Smith thinks are rubbish and wants to send our way? We need a talented Hooker maybe you could send us a hooker maybe even PJ Marsh, or can Marcus Perenara or Tim Smith play hooker?

anymore andrew ryans? .... pretty happy with hindmarsh and morrison in our back row ... thanx! .. you can keep ryan :lol: :lol:

I will gladly keep Ryan, he is a gun, so is hindmarsh but you had both imagine a combo 2nd row of Hindmarsh and Ryan it would have killed it as it did in Origin.

This would be your possible linup if you kept your guns...

1. B.Hodsgon or C.Schifcofske
2. L.Burt or M.Petersen or S.Kelly
3. J.Lyon or D.Vaealiki
4. W.Tonga Or A.Mogg
5. E.Grothe or J.Moodie
6. M.Witt or C.McGuire
7. PJ Marsh
8 N.Cayless Or Daniel Heckenberg
9 J.Morris Or Brad Drew
10 J.Cayless Or Michael Vella Or A.Chan
11 N.Hindmarsh
12 I.Hindmarsh Or D.Solamon
13 A.Ryan Or D.Wagon


My Strongest team would be...that is not including all the imports you have bought this year and last you bought duds so they wouldnt have made it anyways.

1. B.Hodsgon ...... -> wade mckinnon over speedhump hodgson anyday!
2. D.Vaealiki ........ -> hes not a winger
3. J.Lyon .............. > sook who fell in love with crusher
4. W.Tonga .......... -> would love to have kept him (at least hes replaced by an international)
5. E.Grothe ... .... > welcomed back with open arms
6. M.Witt ..... -> who you kidding .... time smith outplayed him everytime when they were both in premmies
7. PJ Marsh ....... -> welcomed back with open arms
8 N.Cayless .... -> our captain
9 J.Morris ...... -> ... solid .. but we have blockbuster riddell there!
10 J.Cayless ..... >a big loss .. but watch out for cannings
11 N.Hindmarsh ... -> no comment
12 I.Hindmarsh ... -> morrison anyday thanx ... whats hindmnarsh done at the raiders?
13 A.Ryan ... > big loss .. well covered though

14 M.Vella .... -> will be back hungrier after recovery
15 D.Soloman
16 D.Heckenberg ... ->chad robinson covers him well ... in the top 17 for the roosters week in week out for the last 2 years.
17 C.Schifcofske ... -> big loss .. but i just love mckinnon .. strong runner and one on one defense is EXCEPTIONAL

So yeah thats why i was asking if Brian Smith had any so called rubbish played ready to throw out so we could pick them up and show there full potential.


:lol: :lol: :lol:

now your argument looks quite lame now dosnt it?