Cameron Smith’s stunning call for NRL to return Melbourne’s stripped titles

[Slater1]

How can we feel anything about something that doesn’t exist?

There wasn’t a season in 07 & 09??

 

[SBD82]

There wasn’t a season in 07 & 09??

The Storm are not premiers for those years.

 

[AJB1102]

Sure

You had players who had already been banned for peptides, players receiving money outside of the salary cap in the years both before and after the premiership.

If you honestly think that 20 years from now the sporting world won’t look back on that premiership as tainted you are deluded.

If you think any Sharks fan or player gives a f**k now or in 20 years what anyone else "believes" about our premiership you're well positioned to speak firsthand about delusions.

merkins believe the Earth is flat, idiots like yourself aren't rare.

 

[Knight Vision]

they kept the big 4 and came firs

they managed to keep 3 after being busted cheating. They should of been made to purge their top 10 players and start again. That or dissolve the club

 

[Slater1]

The Storm are not premiers for those years.

Then who is?

If you think any Sharks fan or player gives a f**k now or in 20 years what anyone else "believes" about our premiership you're well positioned to speak firsthand about delusions.

merkins believe the Earth is flat, idiots like yourself aren't rare.

The entire NRL seems to fit that Storm fans should think that their premierships were invalid, yet your one is as dodgy as both 07 & 09

 

[SBD82]

Then who is?

This guy: *

 

[Slater1]

This guy: *

Only because Gallop had the balls to do something that Greenberg doesn’t

 

[Loose Cannon]

Let’s assume Cronulla broke the rules in 2016.

That means they failed to count to 6,800,000 without screwing it up.

Meanwhile, a few years earlier Cam couldn’t count to 1 without screwing it up!

 

[SBD82]

Only because Gallop had the balls to do something that Greenberg doesn’t

Yeah... nah.

It’s because your club is a cheating bunch of merkins and were rightfully stripped of their premierships.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Get fuuucked

I should have led with this

 

[Slater1]

Yeah... nah.

It’s because your club is a cheating bunch of merkins and were rightfully stripped of their premierships.

I’ve never said we didn’t cheat...

What I’m saying is, despite watching the Storm get punished as harshly as they did only a few years later, the Sharks management incompetently did the exact same thing and should be punished for it— the only reason they haven’t is because Greenberg is too afraid to strip them of the 16 premiership.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Sure

You had players who had already been banned for peptides, players receiving money outside of the salary cap in the years both before and after the premiership.

If you honestly think that 20 years from now the sporting world won’t look back on that premiership as tainted you are deluded.

20 years from now. No one will give a shit, just like they won’t give a shit about melbournes!

 

[SBD82]

I’ve never said we didn’t cheat...

What I’m saying is, despite watching the Storm get punished as harshly as they did only a few years later, the Sharks management incompetently did the exact same thing and should be punished for it— the only reason they haven’t is because Greenberg is too afraid to strip them of the 16 premiership.

Unless new information comes to light, they didn’t do exactly the same thing. Happy to revisit if something else comes up.

If you want an idea of how misguided your idea of this is, you’re arguing with a dragons fan who is defending the sharks.

 

[Miller was a legend]

I’ve never said we didn’t cheat...

What I’m saying is, despite watching the Storm get punished as harshly as they did only a few years later, the Sharks management incompetently did the exact same thing and should be punished for it— the only reason they haven’t is because Greenberg is too afraid to strip them of the 16 premiership.

“Exact same thing”

You lose the internet in its entirety today.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Unless new information comes to light, they didn’t do exactly the same thing. Happy to revisit if something else comes up.

If you want an idea of how misguided your idea of this is, you’re arguing with a dragons fan who is defending the sharks.

It really says a lot and he just doesn’t get it

 

[myrrh ken]

If only chambers passed the ball

 

[Miller was a legend]

If only chambers passed the ball

Ohhhh OUCH! Lol

 

[AJB1102]

The entire NRL seems to fit that Storm fans should think that their premierships were invalid, yet your one is as dodgy as both 07 & 09

As dodgy? $700k over 5 years, most of which wasn't even paid vs. $3.78M.

If that's not perspective enough, consider that in 2010 when caught the cap was only $4.1M, in 2006 it was $3.6M, less than your total breaches!

 

[gordsy]

Good idea. Let’s go back in order to address players signing two contracts and sanction the players and managers involved.

I always wondered how players / managers can sign two contracts but not be held accountable or know they are doing something dodgey

 

[Miller was a legend]

As dodgy? $700k over 5 years, most of which wasn't even paid vs. $3.78M.

If that's not perspective enough, consider that in 2010 when caught the cap was only $4.1M, in 2006 it was $3.6M, less than your total breaches!

Bingo!