El Diablo
Post Whore
- Messages
- 94,107
http://www.leaguehq.com.au/articles/2008/09/23/1221935641462.html?feed=fairfaxdigitalxml
Now Smith wants Thaiday to grapple with a moral bind
Brad Walter and Richard Hinds | September 24, 2008
BRONCOS forward Sam Thaiday may be approached to give evidence on behalf of Cam Smith as the Melbourne captain attempts to beat a grapple tackle charge that could end his season and rule him out of the Australian side for the official World Cup opener against New Zealand.
With Smith facing the prospect of being suspended for Friday's preliminary final against Cronulla and the following weekend's grand final if the Storm beat the Sharks, it is understood he is considering asking his Queensland and Australia teammate to testify at tonight's judiciary hearing.
Despite Thaiday clearly resenting the 59th-minute tackle in last Saturday night's semi-final that led to Smith and Melbourne teammate Jeremy Smith being charged with contrary conduct, his anger appeared directed at the Kiwi second-rower, who yesterday accepted a one-match ban for a "chicken wing".
While the charge against Smith has been described as a test case in the war against grapple tackles, a hearing two years ago that was considered equally significant at the time resulted in Parramatta's Nathan Hindmarsh being exonerated after his alleged victim, Adrian Morley, gave evidence on his behalf.
Sydney barrister Geoff Bellew, who will represent Smith, is expected to tell the three-man panel of former players that the Kangaroos hooker was unaware of Jeremy Smith's involvement in the tackle and was merely trying to force Thaiday to the ground. Bellew will argue that the pair was working against each other in the tackle, which also involved Dallas Johnson, who was around Thaiday's legs.
Smith is also likely to say he did not initially realise he had his arm hooked under Thaiday's chin and released his grip as soon as he did - although the NRL prosecution maintain that he then grabbed the Brisbane second-rower's head a second time and twisted it.
"Right from the start he has maintained it was accidental," said Melbourne CEO Brian Waldron. "He certainly releases the tackle, if you look at it in real time, when he realises that it might be an issue and I think there is a genuine case that it is not outside the spirit of the game. He certainly doesn't go through with anything that causes any damage.
"We are very conscious, like everyone, that the head is sacrosanct. But sometimes things happen and there have been a lot of cases this year - a lot of cases this year - where there could have been similar charges. That's the way the ball bounces."
If Smith is suspended and the Sharks beat Melbourne on Friday night, he will complete his ban in the October 26 World Cup clash at Sydney Football Stadium, but Cronulla and Australia coach Ricky Stuart yesterday said the judiciary panel had no choice but to find him guilty.
"He's been found guilty of attacking the head or the neck, or whatever it was. Rules are rules," Stuart told Sydney radio station 2KY. "It's disappointing for Cameron. It's disappointing for their coach because he's a big part of their team. He's been flirting with it all year, so the time comes when you pay the price. It's difficult for him. He's a good bloke. He'll be disappointed he's not going to be there."
The NRL would not reveal the three-man panel of former players which will decide tomorrow's verdict, but judiciary chairman Greg Woods will, as always, instruct them to ignore the media hype surrounding the case.
The interest surrounding the case has been so intense that Sportingbet Australia yesterday offered a market on whether Smith will play this week - $1.18 he won't and $4.25 he will.