What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Charges!!

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,788
Barrett grade 2 striking!!

PJ Marsh - Grade 2 Careless high tackle ---won't be suspended with early guilty plea.

Woolfed - Grade 2 [gone for 6 weeks]

Stevens
Croker
Soward also charged!!

BOY!!! OH!! BOY!!!
 

Nickeel

Juniors
Messages
2,372
eelavation said:
PJ Marsh - Grade 2 Careless high tackle ---won't be suspended with early guilty plea.

Joke. Absolute f**king joke, and simply to appease Dragons fans.

Don't know how many times I've seen these types of challenges, week after week. Putting pressure on the kicker. I've rewatched that incident on at least four separate occasions now (complete with replays etc.) and I still fail to see how PJ's challenge could come to anything at the judiciary... he struck Barrett's ARM, GODDAMMIT!!!

eelavation said:

Crocker?

Nick
 

Macca_

Coach
Messages
18,629
eelavation said:
Barrett grade 2 striking!!

PJ Marsh - Grade 2 Careless high tackle ---won't be suspended with early guilty plea.

PJ's is easy to defend. The video ref already reviewed it and ruled there is nothing wrong. Thought they only looked at these things if the refs miss it...

What's a grade 2 striking charge result in? Cause there is no defence for it, he's guilty.

Macca_
 

PB

Bench
Messages
3,311
eelavation said:
PJ Marsh - Grade 2 Careless high tackle ---won't be suspended with early guilty plea.

I said it somewhere before.

His defence to that is simple. He wasn't making a tackle, he was making a charge down! If he was making a tackle there would have been alot more contact! If you are not attempting to hit a player, and hence make a tackle, then how can you be charged with a high tackle!?

I say fight it!
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,788
PB said:
I said it somewhere before.

His defence to that is simple. He wasn't making a tackle, he was making a charge down! If he was making a tackle there would have been alot more contact! If you are not attempting to hit a player, and hence make a tackle, then how can you be charged with a high tackle!?

I say fight it!

mate, at the end of the day, no matter how minimal contact was to the head, there was some contact and I guess he had to go.

Wouldn't Stone look like an idiot know!!
 

Lenny_2212

Juniors
Messages
593
stop crying you wheiners.

macca, barrett gets 1 if he takes the early plea, or 2 if he fights it and loses.
 
Top