What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Cherry-Evans asks Manly for a release.

ceagle

Bench
Messages
4,853
2UE just said that Orr and the Sea Eagles have been working on a updated offer, their could be an announcement as soon as tomorrow.
 
Last edited:

851

Bench
Messages
3,141
If the asking price is actually 2.4mill over 4 years then I think many clubs would baulk at that. He's a hell of a player but his knees could give out at any time. I would love him to be a 1 club player and go down as a Manly legend alongside blokes like Eadie and Vautin but he has done the club proud and delivered 2 premierships, if he needs to go in order to earn big dollars then I'd have no problem with that. The Dragons have said they're not interested but how many times have we heard clubs say similar only to announce the signing days or weeks later? He could end up at the Roosters or (heaven forbid) the Dogs.
Vautin finished with 2 years at Easts
 

Cletus

First Grade
Messages
7,171
Just because I say something doesn't mean that the opposite is automatically true.

Manly to make the 8...omg are you spoon contenders now?

Didn't you say we'd miss the eight before the season started? How are the Bunnies going to go this year :)
 

Mr Fourex

Bench
Messages
4,916
The obvious would be Dogs but it would be Broncos behaviour - a repeat of how they got Ikin and Tallis.

Bingo...!!
PDT_002.gif
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
You could've kept all those guys surely? Didn't you shed those guys to help you squeeze in Sandow for 550k a year? Also signed Tonga.
Thats like saying you let Bob Fulton go to Easts so you could sign Craig Field 20 years later you clown.

Hayne, Mateo, Inu, Mortimer, Kris Keating and Kingston were all up for renegotiation. Hayne had the GWS offer that Folau eventually got. They had already re-signed Tahu - maxing out their salary cap, and then the dream run started. This inflated everyones value. They kept Hayne at 600k. Mortimer on $250k and let Keating and Kingston go. Salary cap pressure meant they couldnt retain Mateo and Inu after the Warriors threw gold by the tonne at them.

Then Tahu lost the plot, and left. Unexpectedly, Eric Grothe retired. Their combined wage made up the $600k they were suddenly under the cap by in the off season. There was no quality on the market at that stage, so they bought the likes of Webb and Walker on milk money.

I have never heard of a club dumping players to sign others years in advance. But I understand that you have no idea of that concept, seeing Manly's traditional answer is to throw more money around and sign entire teams.

But it looks like Karma is coming around in a massive way. Its funny to look at Manly struggling for $ in the player market - a bit like seeing Bill Gates at Centrelink. When DCE, Foran, Ballin and the Stewart brothers leave you can still have our rejects like you always bought. Manly in poverty and fighting to stay in the comp - what a delicious irony. :lol:
 

Nice Beaver

First Grade
Messages
5,920
Off-contract for 2012


Ben Farrar, Jorge Taufua, Matt Ballin, Liam Foran, Darcy Lussick, Michael McDougall, Michael Oldfield, Brett Stewart, Dean Whare, David Williams



A few of these guys are going to have to be released if we want to re-sign DCE and Foran

I'll have a lazy hundred on it that one B. Kite is running around in the North of England in 2013......
 

Cletus

First Grade
Messages
7,171
Thats like saying you let Bob Fulton go to Easts so you could sign Craig Field 20 years later you clown.

Hayne, Mateo, Inu, Mortimer, Kris Keating and Kingston were all up for renegotiation. Hayne had the GWS offer that Folau eventually got. They had already re-signed Tahu - maxing out their salary cap, and then the dream run started. This inflated everyones value. They kept Hayne at 600k. Mortimer on $250k and let Keating and Kingston go. Salary cap pressure meant they couldnt retain Mateo and Inu after the Warriors threw gold by the tonne at them.

Then Tahu lost the plot, and left. Unexpectedly, Eric Grothe retired. Their combined wage made up the $600k they were suddenly under the cap by in the off season. There was no quality on the market at that stage, so they bought the likes of Webb and Walker on milk money.

I have never heard of a club dumping players to sign others years in advance. But I understand that you have no idea of that concept, seeing Manly's traditional answer is to throw more money around and sign entire teams.

But it looks like Karma is coming around in a massive way. Its funny to look at Manly struggling for $ in the player market - a bit like seeing Bill Gates at Centrelink. When DCE, Foran, Ballin and the Stewart brothers leave you can still have our rejects like you always bought. Manly in poverty and fighting to stay in the comp - what a delicious irony. :lol:

Karma? We've just gone through a great period were we've won two GFs of course were going struggle with the cap. Parra on the other hand have been hopeless for 30 years. Eric Grothe:crazy:
 

Cheops

Juniors
Messages
254
If he signs a $500k/year deal for 3 years, then performs like shit or breaks a leg, will he hand the money back?
 
Top