Mr Saab said:El Masri holds the record in the Australian comp and thats all that matters.
Ken Irvine is the leading try scorer in the ARL/NRL..and he is acknowledged as so. However Brian Bevan has a million tries in the English comp.
What happens in overseas comps is irrelevant...it is like putting Andrew Gaze in some of the NBA stats...please.
bigdogsgottaeat said:The thing is that El Masri did it in completely different circumstances.
Covell is just out there kicking for the fun of it, because he knows the Sharks are so bad that 2 points will hardly make a difference in the scheme of things.
As soon as the pressure is on, Covell will choke. That is why El Masri is so much better - he actually performs when its really necessary.
Covell might be able to kick a goal, but he can't handle pressure situations.
bigdogsgottaeat said:It was 26-24 until we crossed in the dying minutes. At that point (correct me if I'm wrong) but Cov had missed 3 conversions, at least one which was basically right in front. If he had kicked those, you would've more than likely won that game.
Don't get me wrong, he played very well in that game, and I've been impressed this year. But the fact is that he is a choker. My point stands - if he had actually been under pressure this year, he would not even be close to the record. Its a very empty record when 13 of the goals were scored for a losing side, in zero pressure situations.
Inferno said:How is under any less pressure than any of the other kickers in other teams when he attempts a conversion? He missed 3 that day and 1 was from a reasonable distance, had he kicked it we still would have been equal. Fact remains you can't afford to let your position score 32 points and expect to walk away with the win.
Even if we are losing I think its stupid calling them zero pressure situations. We are not guaranteed a spot in the top 8 and it will most likely come down to F/A so every point is Vital.
Who are we losing from our squad this year that makes us weaker next year?
Corbin said:is Eaton still playing?
lockyno1 said:Covell is a damn good kicker and is in the top 3 natural kickers with Michael Witt and Hazen El Masri. If he break's Hazem's record then so be it!
Timmah said:Oh get a grip!
Timmah said:Michael Witt? WTF? Stop taking the piss and partake in an actual discussion.
As much as I hate Johns, he sh*ts all over both of those players. Covell is probably 5th or 6th at best.