TRANSLATION
Juniors
- Messages
- 1,910
It's the most ridiculous system in the world. You are supposed to be voted by your peers as to who is the best player in the game, not by a bunch of wannabe Sensationalisers that are JOURNOS.
Which of these journos, knows more about Football than you do ???
The Game needs a proper set of judges making informed decisions. The way it is set out at the moment is a joke.
It lost all credibility with me when Anthony Mundine had a sensational year yet he only polled about 8 points. Why ???? because the journos and he never saw eye to eye. What a Fair system that is. Trent Barrett won it that year for memory, or the year after. Yet he was nowhere near the best at our own club let alone the competition.
To have 1 player singled out is beyond me, Each player should be judged in their posi as they are, and those are the winners.
To vote for the best. you have to have 2 categories.
Best Forward. Best Back.
The Point system also needs an overhaul.
Points should be allocated in such a manner where 5 players are voted on from each game.
5 Points to the best on the park
4
3
2
1
The judges should come from either the Coaches of the games.or a Few Ex well respected players who are voted into the position via the NRL or the players union.
Which of these journos, knows more about Football than you do ???
The Game needs a proper set of judges making informed decisions. The way it is set out at the moment is a joke.
It lost all credibility with me when Anthony Mundine had a sensational year yet he only polled about 8 points. Why ???? because the journos and he never saw eye to eye. What a Fair system that is. Trent Barrett won it that year for memory, or the year after. Yet he was nowhere near the best at our own club let alone the competition.
To have 1 player singled out is beyond me, Each player should be judged in their posi as they are, and those are the winners.
To vote for the best. you have to have 2 categories.
Best Forward. Best Back.
The Point system also needs an overhaul.
Points should be allocated in such a manner where 5 players are voted on from each game.
5 Points to the best on the park
4
3
2
1
The judges should come from either the Coaches of the games.or a Few Ex well respected players who are voted into the position via the NRL or the players union.