Danny Buderus - still holding NSW back

[tiger_nick]

If Farah is fit I'd imagine he'd have the jump on Hornby for the bench spot in the next game ... surely.

gidley would be a better option then farah, but then again im biased towards the tigers...

 

[NthKnight]

gidley would be a better option then farah, but then again im biased towards the tigers...

Gidley should be in the starting line up at fullback. Playing him off the bench robs the Blues of his best asset - endurance. Unfortunantly this means that Stewart misses out but I believe it will mean a stronger side for game 2. A specialist Hooker or 5/8 is needed on the bench, Farah would be my pick followed by Anasta.

 

[perverse]

Gidley should be in the starting line up at fullback. Playing him off the bench robs the Blues of his best asset - endurance. Unfortunantly this means that Stewart misses out but I believe it will mean a stronger side for game 2. A specialist Hooker or 5/8 is needed on the bench, Farah would be my pick followed by Anasta.

hard to drop stewart after game 1 mate. i agreed with you pre-game 1, but stewart was great on wednesday night and deserves to retain his spot.

 

[NthKnight]

hard to drop stewart after game 1 mate. i agreed with you pre-game 1, but stewart was great on wednesday night and deserves to retain his spot.

Cant really argue with you there as he had a good game and doesnt deserve to be dropped. However I believe if Farah is fit he needs to be on the bench and be blooded this year not thrown in the deep end in 09 and Gids will definantly be there in game 2 if fit. For me this is the best combo as a NSW fan but speaking as a Knights fan Id rather he miss out and be available to play for the red and blues.

The above is unlikely to happen however, its just my opinion.

 

[lotti]

especially since he was one of the try scorers Stewart was probably out for revenge for round 5 and you know Slater taking his test spot.

 

[DeeGan]

Kurt Gidley won't start, though he will replace Hornby pending his fitness of course.

 

[lotti]

if Gidley's in the NSW team he might not be put on until the series is in the bag.

 

[NthKnight]

if Gidley's in the NSW team he might not be put on until the series is in the bag.

Um why is that?

 

[perverse]

Um why is that?

i think lotti is suggesting that by the time gids comes on the field in game 2 (if available) then the game could potentially already be won. if he misses game 2 and gets selected game 3 - it could also be a dead rubber.

it's actually a pretty realistic comment.

 

[lotti]

Um why is that?

because it seems he's gone to the Kimmorley school of Origin football.

 

[voltron]

i thoguht it was really funny
whenever buderus and smith came across each other on the field
they would keep pushing each other
like little kids
LOL

btw i thought buderus played to his gameplan
and will definitely be retained for the series

 

[NthKnight]

because it seems he's gone to the Kimmorley school of Origin football.

No wonder most on this forum ignore you. You make yourself sound like a dead set nuffy with comments like that.

 

[lotti]

I've made no secret of the fact I don't like Kimmorley especially after that intercept pass he threw during an Origin game in I think 2005 that cost NSW the series.

 

[God-King Dean]

I've made no secret of the fact I don't like Kimmorley especially after that intercept pass he threw during an Origin game in I think 2005 that cost NSW the series.

:lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[Apey]

Oh my f**king god :lol:

To the Fight Club! "Lotti is a tithead"

 

[NthKnight]

I've made no secret of the fact I don't like Kimmorley especially after that intercept pass he threw during an Origin game in I think 2005 that cost NSW the series.

What the f**k does that have to do with Gidley and his chances of playing SOO you merkin? From what I remember NSW won that series :crazy:

 

[Misanthrope]

:lol:

If I had $1 for every time a Tigers' fan started a thread about Danny Buderus, I'd be able to afford one week of Benji Marshall's medical bills

 

[Loudstrat]

Funny how some players get bad press no matter HOW good they play.

Bedsy is NSW's longest serving skipper.

Plus, he has crapped on Smith in TWO consecutive Origins.

 

[bigdogsgottaeat]

Buderus is a dirty player. Always has been.

Maybe if he got on with trying to play the game and not milking penalties NSW would have a better chance. The game is better of without that rubbish. Good riddance.

 

[Cletus]

Yeah he's worse than Gallen and Bird combined, complete dog:lol:.