Dave Smith and John Grant facing a rebellion over the direction of the NRL

[El Diablo]

Do you know the definition of the word "may". It means there is a possibility of it happening. Not that it would happen.

So when I said that Smith and Grant may have nervous times ahead I was saying there is the possibility of that happening not that it would.

click on the link in this tweet to the article and you'll see they aint going anywhere https://twitter.com/brentread_7/status/527947831084994560

 

[RWB]

No one will go on the record at this stage and they lack the numbers to challenge the constitution and make-up of the independent commission.

Only a handful of clubs are still supporting the embattled NRL hierarchy. They are the ones Smith has propped up financially in recent times — St George Illawarra, the Wests Tigers, the Knights and possibly the Gold Coast Titans.

That moment when you contradict yourself in your own article :lol:

Ohhhh... Rothfield

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Where did I say that I agreed with it?

Only the stupid like AlwaysGreen read in to things that have not been said.

Where did I say you agreed with it. You read and decided to share it. Your thread title suggests that what is written in A@L's piece is a possibility. Why start a thread based on garbage?

 

[franklin2323]

You are saying its not true because the telegraph wrote it or are saying it because it really isn't true?

Nope lack of quotes. the fact Gus would never talk to him.... Yet he knows Gus hates Smith? Proves it as bullshit

 

[Frailty]

●SECRET loans to clubs including St George Illawarra and the West Tigers with no transparency or details of the terms;

Would the clubs like to have their dirty laundry open for other clubs as well? I would like to see more transparency in club operations, but I doubt the clubs would.

● LACK of communication with stakeholders;

I would agree - especially with the key stakeholder.. Fans. Clubs get to change the rules every year, and everything is run by Channel 9 first.

● THE dearth of rugby league experience in senior management roles and consultancy firms employed in increasing numbers;

Rugby League Experience is not needed in senior administrative roles. It's a business, not a local sport. Rugby League experience is vital in liaison roles.

● NEW corporate governance pressure on already successful clubs, telling long-time officials how to run their business;

Is there any detail of what this pressure involves? If it's a 'one-model-fits-all' approach, then yes, it is ridiculous. However, if it it new reporting procedures or simply involves every club undergoing a governance review - there shouldn't be whinging.

● THE embarrassingly slow process to produce a 2015 premiership draw and address other significant *issues, including the recent domestic violence case;

The draw should have been prepared and released by now. Unfortunately, I think a lot of it is due to the external forces that affect it's composition (Channel 9 and fox). As for their approach to domestic violence, it's getting better IMO.

● PLAYER burnout and lack of compensation to clubs for rep footy injuries;

This has been an issue well and truly before the current commission. Rep injuries happen. It's bad, but it's life. As for player burnout, the clubs need to figure out what they want - more money and status quo, or less money and less games. Other sports have much more demanding scheduling than rugby league.

● THE integrity unit’s inconsistency; and

A key issue to be raised - but hardly something you over throw management of the game for atm.

● SPENDING $750,000 on a feasibility study to rebuild Allianz Stadium, which is home to only one club while others are left with poor facilities.

Given that the government is likely to focus money into Allianz, ANZ, and a western sydney stadium, it seems illogical to spend money on feasibility studies on the suburban grounds.

 

[Snappy]

DC Fan trying to dig out of that hole but only heading towards China.

 

[Matt_CBY]

Look who the journalist is.

He was banned from attending NRL media functions about two weeks ago. I wouldn't be surprised if this is nothing more than this Journo's personal agenda against those who are the taking the game in the right direction.

 

[Keffola]

lol Rothfield..... says it all.

 

[jargan83]

Stopped reading once I realised it was a Rothfield article.

 

[insert.pause]

Look who the journalist is.

He was banned from attending NRL media functions about two weeks ago. I wouldn't be surprised if this is nothing more than this Journo's personal agenda against those who are the taking the game in the right direction.

He was never 'banned,' he was denied an interview request with Smith. Just more rothfield lies.

 

[Captain Apollo]

it's obviously not true

Sloth is just chucking a tanty because Smith refuses to talk to him

I agree. Sounds like a spoilt brat because someone finally said "no" to the old merkin. About time.

 

[LineBall]

I know many don't like clicking on the DT site - but reading the comments after Slothfields article are great. He's copping a hammering!

 

[El Diablo]

Sloth claims he's doing it for the fans :lol: http://blogs.news.com.au/dailyteleg...honchos_facing_a_rebellion/desc/#commentsmore

Mate I’ll never let go of issues that effect fans. I’m a paying customer and a member. I’m entitled to my view. I sit out with the fans and I get an idea of the issues from doing that.
Phil Rothfield

Mon 24 Nov 14 (03:30pm)​

 

[El Diablo]

I know many don't like clicking on the DT site - but reading the comments after Slothfields article are great. He's copping a hammering!

copping some on twitter too https://twitter.com/search?f=realtime&q=@BuzzRothfield&src=typd

 

[chewsta]

"I sit out with the fans and I get an idea of the issues from doing that"

If this merkin sat out with real sharks fans they would tear him limb from limb.

 

[Patorick]

You can't please everyone.

Especially the agenda driven sooks.

 

[Red Bear]

He spends his entire time bagging Gould, how the f**k would he know what Gould thinks? Gould would never give him the time of day, and nor should he.

“It’s like putting a motor mechanic into a job in David Jones men’s wear,” one official said. “Rugby league is different to running a bank. You need to understand the culture, the passion and the people at the clubs.”

Yeah, lets just give every senior administrative role to rugby league people because they have a long history of running clubs effectively and above board. Like Kevin Humphreys. Or George Piggins. Or the numerous clubs which have nearly keeled over. Or Micahel Searle wonderful work at the Gold Coast. Andrew Gee at Brisbane. etc.

It's a breath of fresh air getting the best people, not just league people, involved running our game.

Although i see to remember David Gallop had next to no afinity for the sport, he was just a super league lackey. But we aren't going to criticize him are we.

Rothfield is just a sad case, who unfortunately seems to hold a bit of sway with the general public.

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Phil Rothfield writes the same article every time the ARLC or NRL management is brought up, and it got tired months ago. Now it's just sad.

 

[Timmah]

Good ol' Rothfield. Isn't getting his way so has a cry about it.

He says he's "doing it for the fans". The only significant issue (IMO) at the moment is the lack of a draw and that's due to Channel 9 being slow coaches. Simple as that.

 

[kbw]

I think Smith and co are a bunch of useless hacks. I would not be surprised if this article is spot on the money.
I am involved in running a junior club and these clowns are making it harder and harder for kids to play the game.

There are certain aspects that require a business approach, but first and foremost this is a sport played by 1000s of people and the current administration largely ignore this.

These guys do not just administer the NRL competition they are responsible for the whole game of RL and they are stuffing up big time.