Decision decisions

[God-King Dean]

Out of curiousity...

If you had to choose a player to retain for the rest of their careers & one had to leave the club immediatly; who would you choose?

Ben Creagh, or Dean Young?

 

[Follow Me Up To Carlton]

Creagh to leave.

For purely nepotistic reasons too.

 

[Biglance]

id rather see barrett go than gasnier cooper creagh or young

 

[drake]

If I had to choose: bye bye Youngie. Creagh I think will be a freak.

But FMOTC is right, Young not going anywhere; Albert would bash the Crown out of the mulletted one if Dean were released.

 

[gorilla]

Reluctantly keep YoungCreagh has it all before him - Young is already producing and seems set to continue for another 5 - 10 years.
Creagh could be or might not get there yet, great as he is at the moment.
MHO

 

[Willow]

Interesting hypothetical. Its like picking which ear to cut off.

 

[God-King Dean]

It's very hard to pick.

Young is a future captain, both players look likely to play rep footy, but at the moment you would say Creagh is the more damaging player.

 

[gorilla]

Yound does so much around the ruck and edges, as well as cleaning up mistakes, making busts and backing up. I have him pegged as a forward's version of Terry lamb.

 

[Biglance]

Dean wont go anywhere

 

[Goldthorpe]

Dean Young for sure, he is one of my favourite players.

 

[Wobbygong]

Young has produced week in week out for the lasy two seasons, Creagh has had his moments but has not really dominated like he possibly could. At this stage Creagh to go, because he needs a dominant season to change my mind.

 

[Dakink]

Id also take Young. He has a huge ticker (not that Creagh doesnt) and is the type of performer that each team needs.

 

[Steelers4eva]

Yound does so much around the ruck and edges, as well as cleaning up mistakes, making busts and backing up. I have him pegged as a forward's version of Terry lamb.

Totally agree Gorilla but I'd say he reminds me more of a Danny Buderus clone...only better at a younger age. Lets not hope its a decision they have to make.

 

[Biglance]

Young is the new thompson - all heart

 

[Godz Illa]

Perhaps a name change is in order then, Bigdean? hehe

 

[God-King Dean]

Definatly !

P.S My name is Dean

 

[Downsouthdragons]

is there anyone out there who thinks it is ludicrus to sign timmo for 2007

 

[gorilla]

is there anyone out there who thinks it is ludicrus to sign timmo for 2007

Yup, not completely and utterly stupid but really very questionable.

 

[Southernsaint]

is there anyone out there who thinks it is ludicrus to sign timmo for 2007

It's ludicrus to sign him for 2006...

 

[Collateral]

It's ludicrus to sign him for 2006...

Agreed.