What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Disgusted, Appalled....Good Bye Mr Smith

randy chicken

Juniors
Messages
70
Ah yes I remember now...they rolled the footage of their attacking set straight after their first try while he was talking about it.

randy chicken - what did you hear?

out for rooster with quad tear
unlikely against parra
hopes to be back v storm

Warriors????absdolutely NO CHANCE
 

voltron

Juniors
Messages
1,454
don't speak too soon dude. we just got flogged (and yes, this was a flogging) by the likely spooners, at home, with a relatively low injury toll.

relatively low?
mcmanus, dureau, tolar, houston, cross
5 from our top 17
we have pato playing prop cuz we're down

and the roosters have been building up to this performance

but yeah
im disappointed as hell about this
its pretty pathetic

i hope we can win two or three more
but we have a tough run home
but if we can win and build these are the games to build with
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/nrl/story/0,27074,25876275-14823,00.html


Brian Smith no certainty to see out season as Newcastle Knights coach


By Barry Toohey | August 04, 2009 12:00am

NEWCASTLE CEO Steve Burraston yesterday denied coach Brian Smith was facing the axe but said he could not guarantee he would be in the job until the end of the season.

The pressure is building on the Sydney Roosters-bound Smith with elements within the club believing the Knights should sever ties with him immediately following demoralising losses to Manly and the Roosters.

After looking serious top-four contenders less than two months ago, Newcastle have now lost five of their past seven games to sit precariously in eighth place.

They face another big test on Sunday when they meet the in-form Eels at Parramatta Stadium.

A meeting of the club's board had already been scheduled for tomorrow to discuss the coaching issue for next season.

But given their recent slide, it's almost certain Smith's current tenure will be raised again.

Burraston refused to speculate on what may be discussed but claimed no director had approached him about Smith since the loss to the Roosters.

"I'm not in a position to guarantee anything in relation to the coaching situation because it's a board decision," Burraston said.

Asked whether he believed Smith was in any danger of having his contract terminated early, Burraston replied: "I wouldn't think so. Nothing has been mentioned to me along those lines. As I said, it's a board decision.

"The meeting will be discussing the coaching options for next season.

"We have about a dozen applicants and it will be up to the board to make a decision on how we handle it going forward.

"There is the opportunity to make a decision on the coach at the meeting or there is the possibility we could establish a shortlist, conduct interviews and take it from there."

Among the contenders are former top-grade coaches Steve Folkes, Graham Murray and Graham Lowe and coaching assistants Rick Stone, Michael Maguire and Stephen Kearney.

Should Smith survive tomorrow's meeting as expected, he could still come under pressure if the Knights' poor form continues next Sunday against the Eels.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
Out of the above id like either Graham Murray or Mick Maguire.

Stone i'm unsure about now and how much an affect he could have.

Maybe we need someone new again to get the players to listen to them and not tolerate any crap. The players might be too comfortable with Stone.

And the problem with Graham is he may not command any respect with the way he left the game.
 

Matt23

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
16,495
I'm not sold on Rick Stone...comes across as a bit of a Hagan clone - another jobs for the boys type thing.
 

Pumba

First Grade
Messages
8,542
Smith out, Stone in – Knights directors consider quick move on coaching job

DEPARTING Newcastle coach Brian Smith might be asked to step aside immediately or give greater control of the team to assistant Rick Stone at a meeting of the Knights board tomorrow night.

With Stone having already been pencilled in to take over next season when Smith leaves for Sydney Roosters, it is possible he will be immediately appointed to the job.

Brisbane’s on-field woes under new coach Ivan Henjak, who was assistant to Wayne Bennett before he quit to join St George Illawarra, have given some Knights directors cause for concern and they are open to the idea of giving Stone greater responsibility for the remainder of the season.

It is even possible that he could be installed as a caretaker to help the board assess whether he is the right man for the job in the long term.

With the Knights’ 2010 roster virtually decided, directors would like to be sure that Stone can get the best out of the players he will have at his disposal if he is given charge. The Herald was told that all options were likely to be discussed at the board meeting, which was due to decide on the process for appointing a new coach after Smith’s shock decision to leave a year before his contract expires to accept a four-year deal with the Roosters.

Among the possibilities is that he will be told to stand down immediately and Stone appointed to take over. Smith could also be asked to take a back seat to give Stone more responsibility with a view to him being given the job next season.

Stone, who is in his fourth season at the Knights, has a 20-year coaching resume, including three Queensland Cup premierships in 13 seasons with Burleigh. He is understood to have unanimous support among the nine directors on the Knights board and also from chief executive Steve Burraston.

Initially, it was intended that Smith would remain in charge until the end of the season but the fact the Knights have lost their two games since his departure was announced and are now teetering on the brink of dropping out of the top eight has some directors considering installing Stone for the rest of the season.

With Melbourne assistant coach Michael Maguire, Cronulla and NSW assistant Shane Flanagan and former Bulldogs premiership-winning mentor Steve Folkes among the applicants for the job, there is a view that Stone should be given the opportunity to show why he deserves the job before such highly-credentialled candidates are ruled out.

The board could also decide to approach other potential coaches, such as Wests Tigers mentor Tim Sheens, or advertise for more applicants before making a final decision at another meeting on August 26.

Burraston said last night that he had not been approached by any directors about replacing Smith immediately. ‘‘It’s a scheduled board meeting and will kick off proceedings for replacement - no other changes,’’ he said.

But even if no decision is made at tomorrow night’s meeting, Smith’s tenure is sure to come under further scrutiny should the Knights lose again to Parramatta on Sunday.

Meanwhile, Sydney Roosters chief executive Steve Noyce was yesterday forced to deny that the club was trying to convince Isaac de Gois to follow Smith to Sydney next season after a caller to SkY Sports Radio’s Big Sports Breakfast reported seeing him at the Newcastle hooker’s house on Saturday.

Noyce, the former Wests Tigers chief executive, explained that he was with the joint venture club’s recruitment manager Warren McDonnell, who was picking up some tickets for the Roosters-Knights match from his son, Shannon, the Newcastle fullback who shares a house with de Gois.

League HQ
 

knights girl

Juniors
Messages
219
I hope stone doesn't get the coaching position either.......I to fear to much like Hagan. I'm hoping Macguire from Melbourne gets it.
 

Karmawave

Bench
Messages
4,950
What amazes me, it is left up to BRAD WALTER, Sydney based Fairfax journalist who writes for the Sydney Morning Herald to come up with an article about the Knights coaching situation.

An article that no doubt our local powderpuff writers would have been able to write themselves if they weren't in the business of protecting the team through their sponsorship, and prepared to put their name on the line in a trade off for keeping their propaganda popularity with the Knights administration ( and Smith ) vs journalistic integrity.
 

Joker's Wild

Coach
Messages
17,894
What amazes me, it is left up to BRAD WALTER, Sydney based Fairfax journalist who writes for the Sydney Morning Herald to come up with an article about the Knights coaching situation.

An article that no doubt our local powderpuff writers would have been able to write themselves if they weren't in the business of protecting the team through their sponsorship, and prepared to put their name on the line in a trade off for keeping their propaganda popularity with the Knights administration ( and Smith ) vs journalistic integrity.

Read the Illawarra Mercury lately Karma? This sort of thing happens in most 1 paper towns mate and is unlikely to change soon.
 
Messages
3,813
Folkes is a terrible coach.
Dude I would like the board to sign Michael Maguire up. I only see Folkes and Murray as possible short term measures in case they do not sign Maguire. It appears that Stone has about 8 weeks to prove himself if Smithy is asked to move on immediately. I have said before that Stone has that Hagan 'one of the boys' vibe about him. Keep Smithy I say until the end of the season.
 

Pumba

First Grade
Messages
8,542
Knights board could turn on Smith

He is understood to have unanimous support among the nine directors on the Knights board and also from chief executive Steve Burraston.

Initially it was intended that Smith would remain in charge until the end of the season, but the fact the Knights have lost their two games since his departure was announced and are now on the brink of dropping out of the top eight has some directors considering installing Stone now.

Melbourne assistant coach Michael Maguire, Cronulla and NSW assistant Shane Flanagan and former Bulldogs premiership-winning mentor Steve Folkes are among the applicants for the job, and there is a view that Stone should be given the opportunity to show why he deserves the job before such highly qualified candidates are ruled out.

The board could also decide to approach other potential coaches, like Wests Tigers mentor Tim Sheens, or advertise for more applicants before making a final decision at another meeting on August 26. Burraston said last night that he had not been approached by any directors about replacing Smith immediately.

"It's a scheduled board meeting and will kick off proceedings for a replacement no other changes," Burraston said.

But even if no decision is made at tomorrow night's meeting, Smith's tenure is sure to come under further scrutiny should the Knights lose again to Parramatta on Sunday.

Herald
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
Stuff Sheens, just ask Tigers fans what they think about him..

Flanagan has had a long apprenticeship, he may be alright.

I'm ok with pissing off Smith now, give Stone the rest of the year then sign someone like Maguire.

While a bit unfair on Stone, I just don't get a good vibe if we commit to him for next year.
 

roopy

Referee
Messages
27,980
My feeling is that Stone should get a one year contract, and we should put the job up for grabs again this time next year - and if Stone has done enough he should get a few years.
I think we have the team in place and the plan in place for next season, and we don't need a whole new regime right now - just the guy who has been there to see the plans through.
Whether he is the guy to make a new plan for 2011 is another question.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
My feeling is that Stone should get a one year contract, and we should put the job up for grabs again this time next year - and if Stone has done enough he should get a few years.
I think we have the team in place and the plan in place for next season, and we don't need a whole new regime right now - just the guy who has been there to see the plans through.
Whether he is the guy to make a new plan for 2011 is another question.
But will we have the same opportunity to get the likes of Maguire next year?

I said when Smith announced he's leaving that we are actually in a decent position because no other team is after a new head coach, so we have an open pool.

Who knows what will happen next year, could be 5 clubs after new head coaches..
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,517
Well, David Fairleigh will be available, would you please take him now and we will pay for his transport out of Parra back to Newcastle, complete waste of space.
 

Latest posts

Top