Dungeons & Dragons Mafia

[BunniesMan]

You idiots. Lynch unlynchable Don instead of seeing who the lynchable one may have been, get ridiculously useful player killed. Le sigh

We STILL don't know who was the supposedly lynchable one is. The day would have ended by now either way.

 

[mickyj]

yep no better info to go on so what other option was there?
how could anyone of known it would result in a town death?
until the person who attacked the other person speaks up we have nothing

dragon attacked BM I believe but it would be a long list who would of considered doing that

 

[Bazal]

Just an example of speed play rather than smart play. Couldn't have known the auto was gonna happen, but it was always a possibility and it did, and that's on you lot. And yes I'm cranky, I'm hungover as f**k, deal.with it

 

[Drew-Sta]

You think the trapped chest is a character? That would be rather awesome if true.

Even if it's a character it sounds like it was attacked? May not know anything.

Dutchy most obviously force voted. He never just posts a vote.

You idiots. Lynch unlynchable Don instead of seeing who the lynchable one may have been, get ridiculously useful player killed. Le sigh

What a very interesting series of posts...

Just an example of speed play rather than smart play. Couldn't have known the auto was gonna happen, but it was always a possibility and it did, and that's on you lot. And yes I'm cranky, I'm hungover as f**k, deal.with it

How do you know it was an auto? Most auto's end the day's affairs, and send us to night. It looked more like a day kill, to me.

 

[mickyj]

I agree Drew it looks like a day kill not a result of the lynch attempt.

 

[Bazal]

What a very interesting series of posts...



How do you know it was an auto? Most auto's end the day's affairs, and send us to night. It looked more like a day kill, to me.

Interesting that I'm cranky our most useful player died because people want everything right now? Sure. I've never seen a day kill so I assumed auto.

 

[soc123_au]

Auto would cancel out the existing lynch.

I would say it is an indie that has the info we want. Chances of them coming forward are very low.

 

[Monk]

In response to CJ, didn't misread my pm, mis just made a boo boo and i didn't see his correction till after I made the post.

If there are any outed townies, protect them ahead of me.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Interesting that I'm cranky our most useful player died because people want everything right now? Sure. I've never seen a day kill so I assumed auto.

I fail to see how we could have stopped what killed Dutchy? Sure, I'm annoyed too but last time I checked we can't protect during the day.

Also, your desire to not lynch JM is interesting. Noone knew he was unkillable (his post could be read as a bluff) and then you come on, after not voting (your only saving grace right now) and huff / puff that we outed the don? We now have a chance to RB him, and given what soc says below, it was likely the only info we'd get.

The bolded is just odd.

Auto would cancel out the existing lynch.

I would say it is an indie that has the info we want. Chances of them coming forward are very low.

Agree.

 

[Monk]

Baz is probs mafia

 

[DB]

There was no way in knowing there would be an autolynch.

P.s. How good are long beauty sleeps!?!? Looking this good takes time.

 

[Bazal]

I fail to see how we could have stopped what killed Dutchy? Sure, I'm annoyed too but last time I checked we can't protect during the day.

Also, your desire to not lynch JM is interesting. Noone knew he was unkillable (his post could be read as a bluff) and then you come on, after not voting (your only saving grace right now) and huff / puff that we outed the don? We now have a chance to RB him, and given what soc says below, it was likely the only info we'd get.

The bolded is just odd.



Agree.

I didn't vote because I was asleep. You're twisting my words. My problem is not with outing JM, it's that everything is always done so quickly and reactively. We may well have not found out anything else, but no one had a chance. A bunch of people weren't online along with me. What if I'd had the info for example? I'm also cranky because I know exactly how valuable Dutchy was.

Baz is probs mafia

f**k up Monk.

 

[afinalsin666]

Have a look at butch if there are no other likelies. Seemed too confused at us killing a blue. Can claim a derp, but it is better to be sure. Indies almost always out themselves in these games like that, hilariously.

 

[Drew-Sta]

I didn't vote because I was asleep. You're twisting my words. My problem is not with outing JM, it's that everything is always done so quickly and reactively. We may well have not found out anything else, but no one had a chance. A bunch of people weren't online along with me. What if I'd had the info for example?

I'm not twisting. I'm simply looking at what you've posted. Exactly what have I twisted?

Also, it was no turbo. You were also online well after the update (40min to be exact) yet disappeared the second people began to vote for JM.

Its just curious, is all. You seem very upset by the dud lynch, which was a tactic Apey mentioned in his classic mafia a while back. 'Bad lynch was bad' type of thing. Mafia tactic.

I'm also cranky because I know exactly how valuable Dutchy was.

Sure, and so am I, but exactly how were we to save him?

The distress is interesting also. Reminds me of this.

Learn to convincingly appeal to emotion. Getting upset works better than getting sad.

You could quite likely be town. I just find what you're posting interesting is all. Not common behaviour from you.

 

[cjrankin]

Have a look at butch if there are no other likelies. Seemed too confused at us killing a blue. Can claim a derp, but it is better to be sure. Indies almost always out themselves in these games like that, hilariously.

Afs has a pretty good point. If butch got his role as town and it read team dungeon and a team treasure hunter got lynched i dont see why he would have got mad at the lynch. Either he has royally derped two games in a row or something is fishy here. I would guess he is indie.

 

[Bazal]

I said I'm cranky. I'm frustrated at the way people play. All speed and no thought. The even more hilarious thing is how you now overthink every letter I post but don't apply anything like that to a lynch. It's all "this bloke is the don" and everyone forgets about any other info. You yourself said a game or two ago everyone expects info, lynch, Town win. I don't care how I look, I'd like for once to play town and not have everyone derping.every phase.

 

[cjrankin]

I said I'm cranky. I'm frustrated at the way people play. All speed and no thought. The even more hilarious thing is how you now overthink every letter I post but don't apply anything like that to a lynch. It's all "this bloke is the don" and everyone forgets about any other info. You yourself said a game or two ago everyone expects info, lynch, Town win. I don't care how I look, I'd like for once to play town and not have everyone derping.every phase.

Who should have been lynched instead? Im sorry u drank too many fosters last night btw.

 

[Parra Pride]

If anyone knew anything else we'd likely know it by now, so stop your bitching Baz.

 

[Bazal]

f**k up seppo

 

[Drew-Sta]

I said I'm cranky. I'm frustrated at the way people play. All speed and no thought. The even more hilarious thing is how you now overthink every letter I post but don't apply anything like that to a lynch. It's all "this bloke is the don" and everyone forgets about any other info. You yourself said a game or two ago everyone expects info, lynch, Town win. I don't care how I look, I'd like for once to play town and not have everyone derping.every phase.

Look, I get what you say, but look at the facts.

Investigator finds mafia. Investigator gives information. Player lynch started and finished. Mafia is outed.

Exactly what is wrong with that?

I will admit though that there's a few inconsistencies in the lynch train as to who jumped on. I'm looking into that. But you got my attention because of how you were conversing with JM (it seemed like collusion) and then your insistence on giving time to the matter seemed a bit disproportionate to the issue itself.

We're currently ahead here; one dud lynch is not going to cost us this early, especially since we now have one dead mafia, one outed don, and a lot of townies alive.