What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Early tip: Sandow won't see out his contract

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,362
I stimulate discussion. What the f**k have you ever contributed besides negativity you miserable merkin?

How did you know I was talking about you ? :lol::lol::lol:

PS - If you must know I'm the Oracle and predict the future. Now would you like to take the blue or red pill ?
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,161
So what about the clubs that haven't retained his services? He hasn't been at the same club for longer than a year.

Itchy feet you reckon?

Kearney has been at three clubs since he started coaching in 2006. Would you say that's a bit more stable than Johns' celebrity cameos at various organisations?

You had previously argued that Kearney isn't shit because he has been able to pick up work somewhere else (Brisbane). I was merely applying the same logic to Johns. He has no problems picking up work which means that people rate him.

Who knows why he has been at a few clubs? There could be a multitude of reasons that dont point to him having a poor understanding of the modern game. Here's a few for you:

- He might have conflicting surfing commitments
- He might not have enjoyed it
- He might not have gotten along with everyone
- It could have been an agreed short term gig and he had done everything the club required

Some might argue that he is a knob but I don't buy for a second that he has no idea about the modern game.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,412
2005 was a weak comp.
2009 we played maybe the best side in NRL history-Who where over the cap(and we almost won)
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,300
There's really no need to argue in favour of the fact that part of a halves job is to organise the team, it's the evidence against that fact which needs to presented if Pou wants to make his point.

My point always was that there is no reason to get rid of Sandow, other than his defence.

This point stands on a number of arguments, all of which need to be refuted for it to be proven invalid. Indeed, it is my opponents who are ignoring the entire argument in order to focus on a perceived small victory.

The popular argument is that Sandow should be moved on because he's not an organiser. This is an untrue statement if any one of the following arguments are true:

1. Sandow is an organiser
2. Organisational ability is unimportant
3. Someone other than the halfback can do the organising

Unless all of these statements are false, then Sandow is capable of being a key member of a high scoring attacking unit, like he was from '09-'11.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,362
My point always was that there is no reason to get rid of Sandow, other than his defence.

This point stands on a number of arguments, all of which need to be refuted for it to be proven invalid. Indeed, it is my opponents who are ignoring the entire argument in order to focus on a perceived small victory.

The popular argument is that Sandow should be moved on because he's not an organiser. This is an untrue statement if any one of the following arguments are true:

1. Sandow is an organiser
2. Organisational ability is unimportant
3. Someone other than the halfback can do the organising

Unless all of these statements are false, then Sandow is capable of being a key member of a high scoring attacking unit, like he was from '09-'11.


You cannot use any of that logic because last week organising could not be quantified. Therefore all 3 points do not apply. Therefore we get rid of Sandow and replace him with a younger player because they according to you always improve. :D

Simples.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,362
Only in response to hostility from others. If Avenger is going to dish it he should expect to cop it back.

You get all exposed like a Portuguese chicken. I'd love to interrogate you. You would be a mess in a few minutes.
 
Last edited:

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,300
How did you know I was talking about you ? :lol::lol::lol:

Several reasons:

1. You posted right after me
2. You like to post about people rather than to them
3. You have been very mean to me these past few days and it hurts

PS - If you must know I'm the Oracle and predict the future. Now would you like to take the blue or red pill ?

Are you trying to get Casper started?
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,362
Several reasons:

1. You posted right after me
2. You like to post about people rather than to them
3. You have been very mean to me these past few days and it hurts



Are you trying to get Casper started?

I don't think you are a dumb merkin. I actually think you make some great points but please you should not always argue about everything and change your mind to suit a specific argument. You will get exposed every-time. My memory is too good.
 

Latest posts

Top