Serious question. Where does BA rate amongst the other coaches? Is he behind bellyache or further down?
Imo, he wouldn't be too far behind.
He has managed to lure Mitchell Moses, Kane Evans, Clinton Gutherson, Nathan Brown, and Michael Jennings to the club, to name but a few players. These are all rep-level players.
He has dealt with our off-field garbage with dignity, and in 2016, managed to keep the team competitive.
He has developed promising youngsters like Kaysa Pritchard and Tepai Moeroa into solid First Graders (and they have high ceilings).
He has managed to build a team with great depth - last night, we played the entire second half with arguably our fourth choice fullback (I would wager Will Smith would be ahead of Norman), and our third choice hooker, and didn't miss a beat.
Let's not forget that since 2015, he's had salary cap dramas to deal with, meaning we had a squad with little depth, and were over-reliant on Jarryd Hayne; I'd argue that Arthur steered us through the post-Hayne era with aplomb.
He has also shown a great knack for identifying areas of opportunity in our squad, and moving to fix those areas (eg: he saw we needed a halfback, and orchestrated Moses' release to join us).
As a relative rookie, he is still learning about tactics and working the interchange system - but he's shown good signs.
Imo, I'd rate him just below Bellamy.