What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Email to Greenberg

Dragonslayer

First Grade
Messages
7,817
If anyone bothwrs to take the time, Annesley has a football operations segment on NRL.com every monday afternoon, its very informative. Part of the presentation goes through some, not all, contentious refereeing decisions from the round. A couple this week were on shepherds, and another about Addo-carr putting his foot into touch a call which was incorrect and players standing in an offside position whilst in attack.

Maybe those wanting to vent against referees should take a look before going off.
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,971
If anyone bothwrs to take the time, Annesley has a football operations segment on NRL.com every monday afternoon, its very informative. Part of the presentation goes through some, not all, contentious refereeing decisions from the round. A couple this week were on shepherds, and another about Addo-carr putting his foot into touch a call which was incorrect and players standing in an offside position whilst in attack.

Maybe those wanting to vent against referees should take a look before going off.
Don’t be stupid..

Clearly any deranged fan is much smarter than anyone with football nous and experience..
 

Hawkins

Juniors
Messages
1,993
Some lovely young lass wrote back explaining how the draw was done

How is the draw done? Brisbane play on channel 9 nights and Canberra play every Saturday and the Sunday game that's on Foxtel.

I cannot understand the NRL head honchos with the tv people pulling on their vocal cords from the arse end up.
 

merahputih

Juniors
Messages
922
How is the draw done? Brisbane play on channel 9 nights and Canberra play every Saturday and the Sunday game that's on Foxtel.

I cannot understand the NRL head honchos with the tv people pulling on their vocal cords from the arse end up.
I am never sure how the actual draw is decided. Not so long ago every side played each other team twice during the regular season. Now they sometimes play certain teams only once. TV free to air games are decided by Chanel 9 based on ratings. Teams like Souffs and Broncos are considered to be among the top rating tv performers, while Canberra and the Titans etc are seen as lesser lights as they . We seem to get a fair share of Ch9 games if we are going well. Until this year The Broncos seemed to have almost a permanent Friday night slot, which gave them an unfair advantage in having regular training schedules and longer turnarounds. I guess Channel 9 reckon they are paying the piper so they can call the tune.
 

Brutalitops

Juniors
Messages
2,333
I am never sure how the actual draw is decided. Not so long ago every side played each other team twice during the regular season. Now they sometimes play certain teams only once. TV free to air games are decided by Chanel 9 based on ratings. Teams like Souffs and Broncos are considered to be among the top rating tv performers, while Canberra and the Titans etc are seen as lesser lights as they . We seem to get a fair share of Ch9 games if we are going well. Until this year The Broncos seemed to have almost a permanent Friday night slot, which gave them an unfair advantage in having regular training schedules and longer turnarounds. I guess Channel 9 reckon they are paying the piper so they can call the tune.
I can explain why brisbane have less of a hold of the Friday night slot this year, and that's because the NRL took more control of the draw away from 9.

For what it's worth, the broncos themselves didn't even want the constant Friday night slot. They had been complaining for a while about their lack of Sunday afternoon games
 

TruSaint

Referee
Messages
20,860
Based on that still shot his foot has not touched the ground in front of the 1/2 way line & the ball has been kicked. No penalty.

Very true but moot.
This is a snapshot of many stills promoting Magic Round.

Yet, we find a " flaw it in ". LMAO....
 
Last edited:

avocado

Juniors
Messages
1,265
I am never sure how the actual draw is decided. Not so long ago every side played each other team twice during the regular season.
huh? This hasn’t happened since mid 90s?

You do realise in a 16 team comp that if you played every team twice that’s a 30 week comp plus finals.
 

Gareth67

First Grade
Messages
8,838
How is the draw done? Brisbane play on channel 9 nights and Canberra play every Saturday and the Sunday game that's on Foxtel.

I cannot understand the NRL head honchos with the tv people pulling on their vocal cords from the arse end up.

Very well put Hawkins , I couldn’t had said it any better myself - and that is saying something ! :innocent:
 

Slippery Morris

First Grade
Messages
7,900
I heard Bill Harrigon the other day say something allong the lines that refs could blow a penalty every set of 6 in a game. Kent then said they should which then Bill replied no one would watch the game if they did.

So basically if a ref can blow a penalty each set of 6 shows how much power they have to influence the result. They can find a penalty anywhere and give the opposition a leg up to make the game close. Against Manly Saints were all over them, the the Refs came in and gave Manly as much ball as possible. Luckily they realised how much of a mockery the game became and did not give Manly a penalty in the last seconds. THey made fools of themselves and had to defend the bad call in the end and not the others way before that got them to that stage.

Same with Parra, Saints were clearly on top then that kick off penalty which was absolute crap. But what bothered me is soon after that, the Parra hooker took a quick tap and split the saints which led to a try. No mark was given, no whistle nothing. He actually walked a step or 2 in front of the ref before taking the tap and ran. 100% of the time the refs call it back but that one, no way. So they were strict with the halfway penalty but lenient with the quick tap.

The refs have way to much power compared to other sports. If teams dominate in other sports they usually win but in NRL, the ref can actually starve a team on a role of possession so easily like we witnessed against Manly, Parra and Roosters 1st half where Saints just got no ball due to ref's.
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,971
They got 3 or 4 of them in a row when we were ontop. We had almost 70 percent possession at the time.
They had 2 in a row in the 35th minute.

Possession for the half was 52-48.

Fails:

SET2JT: 2
 

SET2JT

Juniors
Messages
1,266
They had 2 in a row in the 35th minute.

Possession for the half was 52-48.

Fails:

SET2JT: 2
The possession finished 52-48 but during the first half we were up by a lot more before the leg up penalties to get out of their half were given.
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,971
The statistic is penalty conceded btw. So the warriors got 5 penalties
A 1 penalty variance is not a “smashing” regardless if it’s received or conceded..

None of which you could consider controversial either..

Fails:

SET2JT: 3
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,971
The possession finished 52-48 but during the first half we were up by a lot more before the leg up penalties to get out of their half were given.
Possession at the time was 52-48 to us.

It finished 47-53 to the Warriors.


Fails:

SET2JT: 4
 

Latest posts

Top