What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Evolution on Carney - CT Article

Tokyo_Raider

Juniors
Messages
1,229
Interesting take here on why Carney was in reggies earlier in the year. Remember when everyone was screaming for the coach's head and questioning his selection decisions? Makes people look very uninformed now.

That aside, it's a really good read.

The evolution of Todd Carney
Chris Wilson
Saturday, 9 September 2006

Just minutes before he warms up for tonight's NRL final against the Bulldogs at Telstra Stadium, Canberra Raiders half Todd Carney will write his own commandments on the strapping-tape around his wrist.


'Shoulder in,' he'll start. Confidence begins with strong defence.
'Talk.' Communication will help steer the Raiders around the park.
'Support.' Put yourself in the right place, at the right time.

'Run.' Be aggressive, take the line on at every opportunity.

Carney saves the most important messages for the top and bottom of his list - 'must win' at the top, 'believe' at the bottom.

This is where you begin to see the contrast in Carney.
The 20-year-old can think so deeply about his game that he literally dreams of football the night before a big contest.


beacon.asp


But he's also typical Generation Y, not a creature of habit but of habitual change. He changes hairstyles like mechanics change oil.

He's a kid with confidence and natural ability, a long pass as fluid as his kicks are deep. But he grew up playing to please his father and now, more than anything, he strives for the respect of his teammates. He has an almost naive honesty. But with a rogue streak like his, he might be better served to lie once in a while, or at least keep the truth to himself.

Carney got his driver's licence back less than two months ago. It was suspended, he offers, in the preseason for a low-level drink-driving offence.

The Raiders also dropped him to Premier League early this season for a separate off-field incident in his home town, Goulburn, where tall poppies can be treated much like the noxious purple weed, Paterson's Curse.

The club secretly put him on probation, good behaviour. His next offence, they warned, would carry a very heavy fine.

Although he hasn't always been responsible, Carney takes responsibility for that.

He admits he's had to grow up. Fast.

Until now he's spent his money on the latest clothes and fast cars. But it's with obvious pride he says he's paid the deposit on a new three-bedroom townhouse, adjacent to Raiders headquarters in Bruce, which will be built by January.

"I've still got to grow up more too I guess, next year being a senior person," he says.

On the eve of his first NRL finals series, Carney says he wants to be Canberra's dominant playmaker next year. He's been groomed for the job since he was 17.

He played four NRL games in his first season, 2004, 11 in his second season and 21 so far this year. There has been a succession plan.

Veteran Jason Smith, 34, known to teammates as the 'King', will leave the Raiders at season's end. Carney is crown prince.

"Smithy's been great, not just the things he's told me but the things I've taken off him," Carney says. "Just little things, how to read the game and slow the game up.

"Even though I think I've been playing reasonably good, I think people are still doubting me that I'm the person to take over from Smithy. That's what I'm excited about, taking on that challenge ... Hopefully I'm the player down the track that people are saying who's going to take over me."

Carney can relate to another young playmaker, Parramatta's Tim Smith, barely old enough to drive but put in charge of steering an NRL team around the park.

Smith was NRL Rookie of the Year last season, but has been the focus of off-field incidents in '06.

"I haven't had big things really," Carney says of his trouble. "You've got to feel for him [Smith] because he was going to quit the game, retire, for something so little.

"Everyone has form slumps and doubts themselves, if you don't you're not human."

Carney's audacious hairdos are a small sign he's more comfortable around his Raiders teammates. He can be himself. His elder sister Melinda is a hairdresser and he's a willing testdummy. It's been that way since she was an apprentice and Carney wanted to copy the Beckham Mohawk.

At 17 he quit school, after Year 11, to join the Raiders full-time squad in 2004.

He didn't want the first impression to be a cocky kid who'd been given a chairlift ride to the top, so he toned down his hair.

But, in accordance with rugby league initiation, senior players still teased him - for using gel. Carney admits he was daunted.

"Probably because it was my first year and they didn't really have the respect for me," Carney says. "Sometimes I felt, is it always going to be like this?"

Things have changed. In round 12 this year, Carney kicked the winning field goal in extra time against the Cowboys at North Queensland. He did it again in round 23, against the Tigers at Campbelltown.

Carney says he felt the change coming before that, after he'd returned to the top grade following his disciplinary demotion.

"I just thought then, I'm going to have to bite the bullet," Carney says.
He has worked hard on his kicking game with Raiders assistant coach Andrew McFadden. He's done extra defensive drills with former Raiders premiership player Dave Furner.

In the past, he's concentrated on being a ball-player or a running man. Now he's trying to combine his strengths in both areas, as he's done so successfully in junior grades.

"If I stuffed up I used to get down on myself a little bit," Carney explains. "But now with the confidence I've built with the players, if I stuff up I know I've got to do something to make up for it."

Carney says he's wanted to play for the Raiders since he was three. "And I don't want to leave the Raiders," he adds, bringing up the inspiring and emotional send off for long-serving stalwart Jason Croker, a man he's admired from day one.

They have similar backgrounds; Croker from Crookwell and Carney from Goulburn. Carney was four when he began playing league, his mother, Leanne, used to give him $5 to coax him out of the car.

His father, Daryl, was a bigger influence as he got older. At the time Carney felt pressured, now he feels thankful.

"There's been a few of my cousins from Goulburn who [played lower grades at the Raiders but] didn't make it due to their personal reasons," Carney says.
"After going through 15s and 16s at the Raiders winning the SG Ball grand final and that, I felt [my dad] stuck on my back. He was always making me do weights, watching videos and he was always hard on my game if I played bad. I think that was because he didn't want to see someone else fail. I owe a lot of that to him ... he helped me to hang in there and gave me the best shot."

Carney denies he's just playing for his family, which includes another older sister Krysten.

"It's sort of all for me," he says. "I'm the one doing the hard work and there's a lot of hard work to go."

Tonight's final is a sign of how far Carney has already come. He made his NRL debut against the Bulldogs, on June 19, 2004, just 17 days after his 18th birthday.

He recalls the match in detail. He was exhausted 10 minutes after coming off the bench. He kicked crossfield for winger Matt Gafa in the dying seconds to try and steal a late victory for the Raiders, but it was intercepted by opposition half Brent Sherwin and the Bulldogs held on to win by four.
"It didn't find the money so I had to live with it."

Carney hates losing, the kind of kid, he admits, who refused to take it out in backyard cricket.

"If you don't like winning you've got to have a good look at yourself I think."
Hence the written message 'must win' on his wrist tonight. The Raiders must win to remain in the finals.

Carney believes they can. 'Believe' will be the last thing he writes, his final thought before he runs on to Telstra Stadium. "If you've got belief in yourself, noone can stop you."
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
I love that kid, i want to carry his kids :D
whatta legend! He's going be awesome for us for the next 10 odd years
 

legend

Coach
Messages
15,150
Carney will be a superstar because when the game is on the line, he wants the ball in his hands and he has lifted us to victory twice with field goals and his running late in the game last week was that of a player with a will to win.

If he runs as well tonight, he will cut the Bulldogs to ribbons around the ruck.
 

Tokyo_Raider

Juniors
Messages
1,229
The nice thing about this thread is all the guys who kept slamming the coach for not picking Carney putting their hands up saying "Oh, right...it was disciplinary. I guess we really didn't understand what the hell we were talking about.....sorry, Matt....boy, I feel like a goose".
 

Raider Jack

Juniors
Messages
90
to quote R-69:

"yes, they have done extremely well to build a core group of really talented young players, no one has ever bagged them for not doing that, but theres no point having those players there if they waste away in PL all year long because

1. the coach refuses to pick them
2. there are elderly players who offer less to our future crowding the ranks.

Id be over the moon with this years recruitment if only one Mogg/Schif had of stayed and Dunemann and Logan were not signed. Mogg AND Schif were allowed to leave (silly contract additives for schif, and early release for mogg, why?), and Dunemann and Logan were signed and will probably feature in our FG team next year (please, Henry, prove me wrong!)

they deserve a rap, but they must also cop the treatment that comes from some poor decisions"
 

Edwahu

Bench
Messages
3,697
Tokyo_Raider said:
The nice thing about this thread is all the guys who kept slamming the coach for not picking Carney putting their hands up saying "Oh, right...it was disciplinary. I guess we really didn't understand what the hell we were talking about.....sorry, Matt....boy, I feel like a goose".

True, it proves Elliot had no control over his selection. He was copping flack for his use of Carney long before he was dropped though.
 

Raider Jack

Juniors
Messages
90
Ok we might have got it wrong on the Carney demotion thing, but i'd rather a coach take the position like Mick Malthouse and say stuff you lot, i'm not reprimanding him/them cause he/ they are some of my best players. Who gives a damn what he did, he plays for us and on his good days he plays like a man possesed.
 

Edwahu

Bench
Messages
3,697
In reality there is zero negative effect from getting some analysis of the footy wrong. That is one of the reasons why its enjoyable to do and doesnt deserve the kind of criticism it sometimes cops.
 

Tokyo_Raider

Juniors
Messages
1,229
Raider Jack said:
T-R just loves to critiscise everyone don't you dude

It warms my lizard heart.

Nah, in this case I just thought it was interesting. I think a lot of comment goes on here that is utterly unfounded, and I thought the Carney dropping was a good example of that. Elliot took a lot of flack for not starting Carney, but it turns out there was a reason for it. In that environment, it would have been easy for him to explain why publically, but out of respect for the player (I assume) he took the hit on the chin and got on with things. For me, that is a sign of an outstanding leader, and it needs to be commented on.

I guess I feel a bit sorry for the coach and players that are the whipping boys here, that's all, and I want to offer a bit of perspective. I think an otherwise excellent page is brought down somewhat by the constant harping on the same theme.

And yes, I know I'm doing the same thing.
And yes, I know that makes me a hypocrite.
 

edabomb

First Grade
Messages
7,190
I'd say myself and TR and a few others copped a heap of criticism for saying there is no point rushing Carney into firsts. I don't see why we shouldn't reciprocate.
 

SOULS 04

Juniors
Messages
2,097
hahaha i knew about the gouburn thing months ago.

great story... i love the cvomments about wanting to play for the raiders since he was yung and never wanting to leave... its the stuff legends are made of.
 

azza

Juniors
Messages
1,799
Why don't we just all worry about this after tonight's game, I just hope Carney plays a blinder and we win.

Go the green machine.
 

edabomb

First Grade
Messages
7,190
azza said:
Why don't we just all worry about this after tonight's game, I just hope Carney plays a blinder and we win.

Go the green machine.

Hear hear.
 

Mal Meninga

Bench
Messages
3,412
SOULS 04 said:
hahaha i knew about the gouburn thing months ago.
What did he do?

About Carney and his motivation... i've read about the $5 to get out of the car... how his dad is basically living through him :lol: ... does he want it enough? I think he can be a match winner, and a Raider great but he needs to command the ball and be prepared to be the hero or villain, he just 'passes the buck' a little too often for my liking, and his urgency is very delayed.

Carney is now an above average/good first grader. The club, the fans, the players around him, now need him to become a great first grader. Little things like getting his kicks away on 5th tackle inside our own half which drive the opposition into the corners, coming away with repeat sets when nothing is on, and working on his handling are a must.
 

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
I just can't see Carney developing into our halfback. Probably time he models his game as a 5/8 which he seems well suited to with his runs and long kicks. Just doesn't have 5th play option in the opposition half sorted.
 

Latest posts

Top