R&WTILLIDIE
First Grade
- Messages
- 5,667
How complicated do you imagine the role of a prop is?
You'd think it would be easy right?
How did our props go last year?
How complicated do you imagine the role of a prop is?
Fullback not settled, centres not settled, something clearly going on with Morris whether we work out something for next season (and beyond) or not which is not helping. We may have players available for those positions but quality of players and the combinations themselves remains to be seen. It looks better on paper than it does in reality at this stage, could change though.
Will Matthews if fine leave him be please.
Everyone also thought Aliomai (or whatever the f** his name is), that PNG park player, Pumipi, Harrison, Matthews, Ah Mau, Vea, O'Brien and Groat were poor gambles over the past couple of off seasons and they were right. This bloke is a less-than-reserve-grade standard clown. This is the rubbish we are left to recruit.
Abysmal.
a 6ft 5in prop who played Yawnion...not league
wow just wow lol
League fans give Union a bad wrap. But I like both codes. The differences in roles of props for Union and League aren't that different from one another.
League Props are traditionally leaner cause that don't require the same mass to anchor the scrums and they are stronger defensively in a lateral sense cause in Union they just set up the pillar and post if they aren't in the ruck and defend against pick and drive.
But... If he is playing Union in New Zealand as a Prop/Hooker, I have no doubt that he'll be tough as nails. Which gives me solace. There was a West Tigers Junior who unfortunately decided to play Union. 6'6" 140+ kgs named Will Skelton, playing 'yawnion'... You think he wouldn't cut it in the NRL?
No,p*ss him off as well,bring in new players,the current have done f#*kall for 3 years now ,enough of give him another off season,please.
You'd think it would be easy right?
How did our props go last year?
Most ppl would agree Creagh went well at Prop and Cooper was solid for most of the year. Friz & Stockwell were out injured a fair bit. According to the forum we need some more size and 1 or 2 more props with mongrel. I dont recall anyone writing off the whole pack
Our forwards were out muscled by pretty much every team last year. So what is our clubs' solution? Sign up a guy who has never played in the league.
Regardless of his size, the fact that he has never played league is a real concern to me...Yet you tend to think that if he is a big enough unit then all should be ok.
If our forwards went ok last year then I would welcome this guy. But under the circumstances, this is a bit of a worry.
I'm just not prepared to write him off before seeing him play. Saffy only played 8 NRL games before joining the Dragons, while he wasn't my fav player he didn't seem to suffer much from the transition. This guy is much bigger and if he has mongrel that's a good start. I respect your point in regard to if our pack was already performing well you could accept it but I'd rather a budget signing like this than spending 400k on a flop or 800k on Fafita.....how did he go this year for the Sharks?