I'm also in the Vossy-best-current-RL-commentator camp, as I tweeted to him once, he gives me aural pleasure. Great balance between calling plays, hyping up big moments & injecting some humour into the broadcast.
I was once annoyed by Halligan, but have learned to love him and his invention of words. To be fair I don't think he's said "Johnny-on-the-spot" for quite a while, which was one of his pet phrases a few years back.
The Brisbane trifecta of Hadley-Wally-Locky is quite possible the worst commentator combo possible, feel sorry for all you Brisbane-ites. They actually drain enjoyment from the game. It would be nice if there was a commentator-mute button where you still get all the atmosphere without the inane dribble from the guys on the mics.