I was 11 when we won in '86 and really too young to enjoy it. and after '81,'82 and '83 just thought what a great club I'm supporting and that we win premierships every 2-3 years, how wrong was I. Poor player signings and even worse retention policies made the years from '87 til about '99 very hard to take, from 2000 til now we have had the players to win premierships just injuries or a off day has cost us.
You can bag Fitzy all you like but it all comes down to the coach IMO, players when signing for a club want to play under a good coach with runs under his belt so to speak, cronin and hidlich didn't have that, once they left and Smith was installed the club managed to sign some quality players and keep the promising juniors.
And yes success is winning a premiership provided your roster is strong enough to do so, you would not expect say the Raiders to win the premiership this year with thier roster, but if they made the top 8 that would be a great effort and make it a successful season.
We have a great coach on board and hench we are keeping our rising talent and marquee players at the club where maybe in the last 2-3 years of Smith as coach we struggled to do so.
Fitzy should have seen the writing on the wall well before he did and should never sign a coach for more than 3 years. We needed a change in coach about 2 years before we got one.