OldPanther
Coach
- Messages
- 13,404
Burton played one game!!!!! Nathan Cleary had a disappointing season overall.
While Jimmy came here on a three year deal he was only ever staying for the two and his move to Catalans was something worked out well in advance as I posted in April last year well before his move was announced.
You and other’s seem to want to insulate Matt Moylan and absolve him from criticism. Moylan in 2016 was outstanding, that was his season, he deserved his SOO and Kangaroo selections. Sadly however that was it, one season. Jimmy delivered for each and every NRL team he played for almost 250 appearances and represented the NSW Blue with distinction.
James Maloney will be remembered fondly as a great of the game while Matt Moylan will largely be forgotten if he hasn’t already and that is sad because Moylan should have been capable of more but he lacked the intestinal fortitude and dedication required to be a top player.
Most of that was irrelevant to the topic of discussion.
Yes Burton had 1 game. It was better than anything Jimmy did after origin in 2019 and if we are taking his injury into consideration it makes it even worse since there were options that could fill in.
How he played for other teams means nothing to me as a fan of this team and it doesn't change that he wasn't any better for us than Moylan was. We got him at the end of a hard fought career. No shame in admitting the physical toll.
No idea what the dig about insulating Moylan has to do with this. Both took us to week 2 of finals. They are objectively equal as Panthers players based on performance.