Front Runner For This Years Over Rated Award

[gorilla with a shotgun]

Can we take Mateo off your hands?

pffft mateo doesnt deserve half the wraps he gets

 

[SoftSydney]

gasnier is overated...he certainly is'nt the best center in the world..not by long shot

I didnt have Gaz in mind but after reading your post I will have to agree with you, based on the hype he gets in the media and hs pay cheq

I think we have a winner

 

[adamkungl]

If Jamie Lyon is 5/8th, hands down

 

[t-ba]

Steven Bell.

 

[smeghead]

LOL Smeghead, its funny you make a poll like this ... YOU ARE THE ONE who hijacked the club you love, simply by creating an ogre to the media. You'll always be a androtop in my books. Karma says you'll get what you deserve, very soon.

:lol: :lol:

It's ok princess. Life will get better for you soon

 

[badav]

Eric Grothe.

If this guys name wasnt Eric Grothe i have no doubt he would not be playing first grade footy.

I'm not a NSW supporter but i feel bad for those who are if Grothe is considered for selection. How he could be considered with his poor form and attitude towards rep footy is quite strange.

 

[Billythekid]

To be fair, the bloke's hardly had a run this season. But yeah, he's looking fairly ineffective hitting the line at this stage and not much seems to have changed since departing Penrith. Hopefully he'll pick up as the season progresses as he's shown us before that he's a very capable prop.

Yeah, he really isn't looking anywhere near his best. Hopefully he picks it up as the season goes on cause i enjoy watching him in full flight.

 

[Chook Norris]

Gasnier, Cooper

havent seen much doing from them for a while

 

[roughyedspud]

I didnt have Gaz in mind but after reading your post I will have to agree with you, based on the hype he gets in the media and hs pay cheq

I think we have a winner

i got shot down once for comparing gasnier to keith senior...both look like they are good and both run over people once in a while...but generally both never really do anything :lol:

 

[madunit]

John Morris

Someone once gave him a rating.

They shouldn't have done that

 

[Tiger Hawk]

Dean Young. Because he's rated that highly yet is just an average first grader. Nothing unique or special about him at all.

Ben Hornby as well.

Generally anybody from the Dragons, if only because so many commentators are Dragons fans and salivate over everyone of them.

 

[TheBourbonBeast]

darius boyd

 

[badav]

I cant understand why Dene Halatau keeps getting NZ test caps.

 

[kia ora storm]

Orford
Bell
Ryles
Hannant
Rooney

 

[Geohood]

Put Gasnier in a good team and he'd kill it every week.

 

[Knights_Premiers]

Karmichael Hunt

 

[Johnmack]

No way in the world will he get a blue jersey unless Qld selectors pick the NSW team.
btw Manu Vatuvei is twice as good as grothe.

I have to agree with the choice of Daniel Wagon as the most overrated player for 2008.This imposter has been up for selection in this category for at least three years.This bloke is gettig on in years and is almost old enough to vote now.He has been beyond the pace for at least three years,and I thought he might have been axed after Brian Smith was shown the door.But,apparently,the selection committee must still owe him money.Alas !1
Johnmack

 

[themanonthehill]

Nathan Hindmarsh
13 sideways hit ups for 62m
35 tackles (25 as 4th man in, 5 as 3rd man in and 4 as 2nd man in)
17 flops
Spends half te game in no man's land between 2nd marker and the line
What a hack

If the NSW selectors have balls they'll start picking the likes of Laffranchi, Heighington, O'Donnell etc instead of past it tools like Ryan and Hindmarsh

 

[Eels Dude]

Early prediction for next yr. Neil Henry.

 

[Eels Dude]

I have to agree with the choice of Daniel Wagon as the most overrated player for 2008.This imposter has been up for selection in this category for at least three years.This bloke is gettig on in years and is almost old enough to vote now.He has been beyond the pace for at least three years,and I thought he might have been axed after Brian Smith was shown the door.But,apparently,the selection committee must still owe him money.Alas !1
Johnmack

How can Daniel Wagon be overrated? No one has rated him for years. That's like putting in a vote for Steve Price as more under-rated.