What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

General Discussion Thread

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,026
So I noticed in the Sharks forum, someone asked Chat GPT to name the greatest Sharks lineup.

I did the same for the Panthers:
  1. Rhys Wesser - Fullback
  2. Josh Mansour - Winger
  3. Ryan Girdler - Centre
  4. Brad Izzard - Centre
  5. Michael Gordon - Winger
  6. Brad Fittler - Five-eighth
  7. Craig Gower - Halfback
  8. Tim Grant - Prop forward
  9. Royce Simmons - Hooker
  10. Martin Lang - Prop forward
  11. Mark Geyer - Second-row forward
  12. Craig Gower - Second-row forward
  13. Luke Lewis - Lock forward
  14. Greg Alexander - Utility back
  15. Tony Puletua - Interchange
  16. Trent Waterhouse - Interchange
  17. Nathan Cleary - Interchange
Craig Gower pulling double duty (and as a Second Rower no less) is definitely not something I thought I'd see.

Don't quit your day job Chat GPT.
Wtf is this list, how does sauce and flash make the list, but Rooney and Sattler doesn't FMD terrible, mate i'd have Preston Campbell in over 2 Gowers too
 
Messages
4,307
Wtf is this list, how does sauce and flash make the list, but Rooney and Sattler doesn't FMD terrible, mate i'd have Preston Campbell in over 2 Gowers too
Given some members of this forums’ fascination with playing Tago in the second row, they would probably place Campbell into the side in expense of the second row Gowie…
 

Goonji

Juniors
Messages
457

Panthers boss, Yeo slam bitter Fox hunt​

Danny Weidler

April 9, 2023 — 5.30am

Panthers boss Brian Fletcher and captain Isaah Yeo have spoken out about attacks on the club by Fox Sports pundits, saying Penrith will consider legal action against the broadcaster.
The Panthers hammered the Raiders 53-12 last weekend and have now won five straight and nine of their past 11 games against them. Fletcher said Fox Sports’ coverage of issues in the match was the most recent example in a history of the broadcaster unfairly criticising the club. The Panthers board will meet this week to discuss banning players from appearing on Fox Sports. Legal action is also being considered.

“We’ve got to protect our players,” Fletcher said. “And we’ve got to protect our coaches and their reputations ... We will discuss it as a board and we will look at all options.”
He said Fox Sports pundits, “sit there without knowing what our club is about and tear strips off the reputations of good people.”

Yeo said: “As a club we understand people are going to have opinions, and they aren’t all going to be good, however it’s ... tarnishing a brand that doesn’t deserve to be tarnished, and I think the public are starting to understand this, which is pleasing.
“The fact that we are giving this more oxygen than what it deserves is something I’m not overly happy about and will only allow for another rebuttal ... but you can’t allow them to continue to take potshots at the club without comment.”
Fletcher was angry about the attacks on head coach Ivan Cleary in particular. The implication is that the coach lacks class.
“The focus should be on the opposing coach after we thrash them, not ours, but that’s not how things play out,” Fletcher said. “As a club, we can’t just sit back and let this go on. It all started a few years ago when there was an article about how strong the Raiders’ reserve grade team was and we smashed them. Then they came out and called our players mug lairs. And now the attacks continue. The latest was the stuff with Jaeman [Salmon].


“To say, as some have on Fox, that parents shouldn’t send their kids to Penrith is just outrageous. That’s an insult to good people like Kevin Kingston, Joe Galuvao and Glen Liddiard, who work in that area. They say things that attack everything this club stands for and then expect us to play ball and put people on their shows. It’s not on and we have a duty to explore every area to protect our club against the rubbish that is said.”
Yeo is proud of the culture at the club and says it is respected throughout the game.
“I know the feedback we get, not just from Penrith supporters but the supporters of other teams, about how much we do for the community, and how good we are after games getting around and seeing the fans,” Yeo said.
“When you’re getting feedback like that, your culture has to be strong. You can see it after games – the Panthers players are the last ones out on the field, signing things for the fans, particularly after losses. If you look at that on its own, you can see how strong our culture is.
“Looking at our cultural showcase the other night, and the amount of people we had there – from Harold Matthews to first grade – that shows a strong culture from the bottom to the top.

“We’re good people and do great work in the community. And once you know that, other people’s comments don’t matter. There are going to be certain people in the media who are goingto make comments, but we understand who we are. We’re proud of what we do. We know what we bring to the competition and we understand the work we do in the community.”


Did anything come of this, sorry if i missed it? In particular, this comment by Brian Fletcher "The Panthers board will meet this week to discuss banning players from appearing on Fox Sports. Legal action is also being considered".
 

Whino

Bench
Messages
3,392
Did anything come of this, sorry if i missed it? In particular, this comment by Brian Fletcher "The Panthers board will meet this week to discuss banning players from appearing on Fox Sports. Legal action is also being considered".

I haven't read anymore on it.

I think it was just a baseless threat. To temper the over the top criticism. No way they win that in court.
 

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,835
Did anything come of this, sorry if i missed it? In particular, this comment by Brian Fletcher "The Panthers board will meet this week to discuss banning players from appearing on Fox Sports. Legal action is also being considered".
Probaly nothing. I have noticed Kent has been a bit more measured in his comments involving Penrith since, even used Nathans tackling technique as an example on how players should be tackling to avoid hip drops. The tackles he used as examples were cover tackles, so not really relevant anyway, but I'd say he is trying to suck up a bit as I reckon he copped a rocket from he bosses at Fox. They still want click bait and faux outrage, but there is a line and he crosses it too often.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,858
Zac Lomax got dropped lol.

Getting in early to say he is one player I hope our club doesn't attempt to recruit.
It is suggested he is in their top five highest paid players at $800k a season. Reflective I guess of what the lesser sides have to pay to keep their best players. I think it is a sad indictment on the failings of the salary cap really. True value probably $500k but given the lesser sides can’t recruit marquee players they are kinda forced into paying overs for potential.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,776
It is suggested he is in their top five highest paid players at $800k a season. Reflective I guess of what the lesser sides have to pay to keep their best players. I think it is a sad indictment on the failings of the salary cap really. True value probably $500k but given the lesser sides can’t recruit marquee players they are kinda forced into paying overs for potential.

Enjoy it while it lasts!

We are at the other end. Players will sign for less to advance their careers.
 

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,272
You are right. This season alone Api and Viliame, next season Crichton and Lenui, that doesn’t even take into account the previous seasons. It’s a myth, the brotherhood, taking less to stay with the band so to speak it actually just hasn’t happened.
I've done the Api thing to death so ill leave that but losing Leniu is going to look like such a bad decision in the future
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,858
I've done the Api thing to death so ill leave that but losing Leniu is going to look like such a bad decision in the future
It’s an absolute total f**k up now, never mind what happens down the track.

There was talk about not paying overs and all that BS but seriously if there was one 22 year old forward who was a must retain it was Spencer. We can agree to disagree on many issues but Spencer had to be retained and we didn’t get the business done. Massive fail on our part. There may be a Spencer Lenui on the horizon but not for 2024.
 
Messages
4,307
It’s an absolute total f**k up now, never mind what happens down the track.

There was talk about not paying overs and all that BS but seriously if there was one 22 year old forward who was a must retain it was Spencer. We can agree to disagree on many issues but Spencer had to be retained and we didn’t get the business done. Massive fail on our part. There may be a Spencer Lenui on the horizon but not for 2024.

He is going to be the most impactful prop in the game.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,776
You are right. This season alone Api and Viliame, next season Crichton and Lenui, that doesn’t even take into account the previous seasons. It’s a myth, the brotherhood, taking less to stay with the band so to speak it actually just hasn’t happened.

Those guys have won 1/2 comps and played rep football. They have nothing left to achieve at Penrith. All of them are on better coin elsewhere and should be chasing money.

I don't expect them to play for peanuts but I do expect others will sacrifice some cash in order to chase a premiership at Penrith and increase their chances of playing rep football. I'll be very surprised if we don't land some decent signings for 2024.
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
12,191
Those guys have won 1/2 comps and played rep football. They have nothing left to achieve at Penrith. All of them are on better coin elsewhere and should be chasing money.

I don't expect them to play for peanuts but I do expect others will sacrifice some cash in order to chase a premiership at Penrith and increase their chances of playing rep football. I'll be very surprised if we don't land some decent signings for 2024.

All the good players are signed for 2024.

The next batch come onto the market in November for the 2025 season.
 

Latest posts

Top