Give an honest rating of your club player(s)

[murraymob]

penrith
we only had petro he was outstanding as always

 

[Caged Panther]

It was Petro, do I really need to say anymore?

 

[Sir Biffo]

Weyman was okay
Poore was bad
Creagh was bad
Boyd was nonexistent but didnt boof up

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

As a Tigers' fan, watching Farah has been painful.

I thought he's only chance of being picked again was if NSW had won.

You're kidding about O'Donnell.

We face another few years of watching origin games without any Tigers players involved

On the other hand, Lawrence and Galloway may be given an opportunity in the near future. I really hope that they put in a better effort that Farah. How can a guy who absolutely dominates everybody at club level look so out of depth at origin?

 

[feeding frenzy]

gal ok bust his guts out 1 stupid offload

baz thought he had a great game behind hayne


but ffs the problem all starts with farah his service was appalling and after 20 minutes wouldnt he of realised he isnt going to get penalties for markers not square??

 

[catch22]

Broncos fan.

Thaiday - not sure why he got MOM? he was solid in the middle and without seeing the stats his defence was much much better than previous weeks
Lockyer - very professional performance, always looked in control - his defence was spot on tonight 1-2 miss tackles which didn't lead to a linebreak anyways?
Hunt - solid, nothing amazing - he did the job covering a center spot as he did in game 1. needs to learn how to tackle properly though
Wallace - his passing game was better than in game 1 he spread the ball alot more from first receive, his kicking game was pretty terrible and he did make abunch of mistakes. will NSW bite the bullet with Kimmorely or Mullen?
Folau - was good tonight, first 20mins saw plenty of early ball and made plenty of meters, got quieter as the game went on.

 

[typicalfan]

If had to do RLW style rating for the players i would go

Gidley- 7
Hayne- 9
Monaghan- 7
Lyon- 6
Williams- 5
Barrett- 8
Wallace- 4
Kite- 4
Farah- 6
Weyman- 6
O'Donnell- 5
Creagh- 5
Gallen- 5

Poore- 5
Stewart- 7
Watmough- 7
Morris- 4

Slater- 7
Boyd- 7
Inglis- 7
Tonga- 7
Folau- 8
Lockyer- 7
Thurston- 9
Price- 9
Smith- 8
Civoniceva- 8
Harrison- 6
Thaiday- 7
Johnson- 5

Hunt- 4
Hannant- 5
Myles- 6
Crocker- 7

 

[effnic]

Lyon- Not bad
Kite- Rubbish
Wolfman- Rubbish
Stewart- OK
Watmough- Awesome

 

[Shorty]

Thurston - Fantastic, tackled his guts out, attacked his guts out and kicked pretty well - Kicking could have been better but pretty spot on.
Tonga - Did the job very well, didn't attack hugely but had awesome defence.
O'Donnell - One of NSW's best, definitely their best forward, as is always with Luke he lost his temper very quickly.

 

[Knights_for_spoon]

Gallen - tried hard but no impact
Barret - He's no andrew johns but atleast he took inglis out.

 

[typicalfan]

Thurston - Fantastic, tackled his guts out, attacked his guts out and kicked pretty well - Kicking could have been better but pretty spot on.
Tonga - Did the job very well, didn't attack hugely but had awesome defence.
O'Donnell - One of NSW's best, definitely their best forward, as is always with Luke he lost his temper very quickly.

Well put, NSW were so poor in the first 25 minutes it negated the fact that QLD had as poor of a kicking game as Wallace did most of the night, Hayne, Williams and Gidley got the ball on the full so many times only for the Blues to cough it up 1-3 tackles later.

 

[skeepe]

Joel Monaghan - solid, but not spectacular. The best thing you could say is that he didn't let any tries in, although he tried hard to. Had some really strong runs but didn't get involved enough.

Tom Learoyd-Lahrs - don't let the fact that he played 0 minutes fool you, this contribution already puts him ahead of roughly 3/4 of the NSW team. Tremendous hit with the tackle bag to floor Watmough in the warm up.

 

[ByRd]

Hannant is an absolute beast, God i love him and so happy his at my club. Morris was quiet and didnt get much ball when on.

 

[ByRd]

Joel Monaghan - solid, but not spectacular. The best thing you could say is that he didn't let any tries in, although he tried hard to. Had some really strong runs but didn't get involved enough.

Tom Learoyd-Lahrs - don't let the fact that he played 0 minutes fool you, this contribution already puts him ahead of roughly 3/4 of the NSW team. Tremendous hit with the tackle bag to floor Watmough in the warm up.

TLL should of been there in the first place

 

[hineyrulz]

Hayne was easily our best player again, 9/10.