Grub Carney out of Grand Final after malicious high shot

[Spot On]

An award winning dive by Scott. He is getting very good at it. Hate to see him actually cop one around the head.

 

[Deacon]

I think you people are blind. It was a massive swinging stiff arm to the head. 1 week suspension at minimum. There is no way he will get off that.

rlforever did you change ur username to this?

 

[_Johnsy]

He'll miss the 1st 5 minutes of the GF breakfast.

That's all it deserved

 

[Danny-Boy]

I want him to play next week to make it a better contest against whoever they play but....

He will be out for at least a week, even with an early guiilty plea.

Swinging stiff arm connected with the head without coming off the ball or shoulders. He got him flush.

He is gooooooooooonnnnnneeeee!!!!!!!!

Couldn't have happened to a nicer team or bloke. :lol:

 

[Eels Dude]

Fair penalty. No way will he even be charged for that. And for the record for those imbeciles that think he actually will be suspended, unless he gets charged with a Grade 3 or above he'll be free to play next week. And that's a Grade 1 at the very worst.

 

[LazyDreamer]

Grade 1, early plea, free to play.

Just as well, because straight after the grand final Carney & Anasta are flying out to the Commonwealth Games. Apparently they represent our best medal chances in the diving.

 

[Deleted member 10972]

Carney didn't dive. He got belted in a legal tackle, I didn't think it was a penalty, but he was legitimately hurt. Braith did however, stay down, if only for the sheer purpose of the referee having a second look at the hit on Carney.

Scott Prince is no better, anyone who wants to have a whinge at the Roosters for doing it are either bias or simply didn't see what happened.

Deserving and convincing winners two weeks in a row after what can be arguably seen as a lucky win vs Tigers. Not sure if they have the guns to beat the Dragons.

 

[innsaneink]

I think you people are blind. It was a massive swinging stiff arm to the head. 1 week suspension at minimum. There is no way he will get off that.

He needs a grade II to miss a match....I highly doubt they'll give him that.

 

[Brutus]

Funny thread.

Even funnier than the name Sheila Diksh*t.

If they let Dally M Hayne play last year's GF after his knees on Goodwin, then Dally M Carney is a certainty to not even be cited. It was a nothing hit anyway.

 

[Brutus]

Carney didn't dive. He got belted in a legal tackle, I didn't think it was a penalty, but he was legitimately hurt. Braith did however, stay down, if only for the sheer purpose of the referee having a second look at the hit on Carney.

Scott Prince is no better, anyone who wants to have a whinge at the Roosters for doing it are either bias or simply didn't see what happened.

Deserving and convincing winners two weeks in a row after what can be arguably seen as a lucky win vs Tigers. Not sure if they have the guns to beat the Dragons.

Braith's dive was a shocker.

But he's got an excuse. His eyes are too close together.

 

[sarahk]

Just as well, because straight after the grand final Carney & Anasta are flying out to the Commonwealth Games. Apparently they represent our best medal chances in the diving.

Haha everyones on fire tonight. I've thoroughly enjoyed reading all your rants but the awards have to go to Macdougall and pantherz9103 lol .

 

[typicalfan]

What is worse is that the refs reward the diver. If Carney jumps back to his feet then no penalty arrives. Cat like behaviour.

 

[melon....]

Nothing shot, he and Anasta should be given a week for disgraceful diving

If they get a week, then Prince and Nate Friend should get a month...Disgraceful milking and diving.

 

[typicalfan]

Carney won't miss the GF either. LOL @ full blooded swinging arm/stiff arm etc.

 

[Loudstrat]

Carney's dive was a get square for Princes dive. Both were sh*t - like Hargreaves against the Tigers!

 

[Kurt Sherlock's Mo]

If he gets a graded charge then they should drag Dwyer back in for a chat with the panel as well.

Penalty sufficient, Prince a protected species, play on.

 

[Chook Norris]

I want him to play next week to make it a better contest against whoever they play but....

He will be out for at least a week, even with an early guiilty plea.

Swinging stiff arm connected with the head without coming off the ball or shoulders. He got him flush.

He is gooooooooooonnnnnneeeee!!!!!!!!

Couldn't have happened to a nicer team or bloke. :lol:

ok you f**n idiot

 

[MacDougall]

Haha everyones on fire tonight. I've thoroughly enjoyed reading all your rants but the awards have to go to Macdougall and pantherz9103 lol .

Surely you must agree that Anasta is a diving, sooking jerkoff. Yeah?

 

[Stewie]

Grade 1, early plea, free to play.

Just as well, because straight after the grand final Carney & Anasta are flying out to the Commonwealth Games. Apparently they represent our best medal chances in the diving.

Was thinking maybe an Academy Award for best Actor to Carney and Best actress in a supporting role to Anasta. Really pathetic the way Anasta wouldn't play the ball and kept pointing over towards Carney and when he realised the ref didn't want to know about it, he faked an injury to stop the clock. I use to like Anasta as a player before this performance.

 

[Tom Ace]

Prince, Carney, Anasta all stayed down longer than they needed to to gain their team an advantage.

Every team does it.

So to those pathetic fools standing on your high horses, wake the f**k up.