Hayne vs Inu

[Johns Magic]

yes i am serious. If you get shot at, will you be the same person again? It takes time to get over these things, the experience just doesn't disappear with a flick of the wrists.

I think you're being melodramatic.

 

[Adsy]

Roosters69 must be Hayne's psychiatrist.

 

[Hanscholo]

Hayne. Inu is going to be a great centre, Hayne has his head all wrong imo.

 

[Kiki]

nah I agree, i think the shooting really affected Hayne. not everyone has the constitution of a Moran brother. its bound to shake you up.

 

[apeman]

hoffman

 

[watatank]

At this stage, probably Hayne but only because Inu is only just coming back from injury into a side on a really bad run. But I think Hayne should really be playing on the wing IMO, plays his best footy there whether he likes it or not really. Moving him around with no definitive role or anything (although I know he asks for it) hasn't really helped at all.

 

[Pumba]

Hayne.

 

[Tommax25]

hayne is way more overrated, inu was good in his first few games back but I guess the disease doing the rounds at parra has now tainted his form too

 

[Sleep]

I'd take Inu over Hayne in a second. I don't think his form in the games he's been back this year have been as bad as Hayne who's been horrible all year.

Inu seems to have alot more natural talent to me too. Hayne is a good player though. Just having a terrible year. He'll bounce back.

Haha! What's with the tags?!

 

[barney gumble]

The thing is, like most of the Eels backline, they are wingers forced to play out of position.

Inu and Hayne come into grade and played their best footy on the wing.

 

[Brookie]

hayne = turd

 

[Rogue.9]

At least Inu isn't crying to the papers about not being able to play what postion he wants.

 

[[FKN-SIK]]

Hayne.

He's a whinger and spends more time on his back milking penalties than anyone else in the NRL

 

[aqua_duck]

Macdougall outplayed Inu lol

 

[sooperdooper]

both a good players...
its not there fault they are behind a pack of fairies and an incompetant coach

 

[perverse]

Macdougall outplayed Inu lol

doogs has been in superb form lately.

 

[Utey]

Hayne, f*cken useless. Fire up you cat! Maybe I should take pot shots at him. F*cken idiot.

 

[lockyno1]

The whole Parra backline are useless, it is not just these two. Out of the two I'd pick Hayne as frankly he does not do enough!

 

[Tekken Lord]

The whole Parra backline are useless, it is not just these two. Out of the two I'd pick Hayne as frankly he does not do enough!

Don't you mean the whole Parra team? As shocking as Hayne and INU have been all year they've been better than our useless forward pack and halfback.

 

[strewth_mate]

If he really is still shaken by the shooting, should he not take some kind of respite instead of dicking around listlessly on the field? Looked like he had no interest whatsoever last night.

Think of the children.