What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

He we go...again

Sharkman

Juniors
Messages
1,018
How Shane Flanagan brought Sharks to its knees with cap rorts
MARCH 23, 2019

Shane Flanagan made one fatal mistake that plunged the Cronulla Sharks into a million-dollar salary cap scandal and cost him his job.

The now deregistered coach sent a confidential spreadsheet of undisclosed player payments from his own private Bigpond account to his Sharks email address on June 3, 2017.

It was a moment of self-destruction, and the smoking gun at the centre of the NRL’s investigation.

The spreadsheet was originally in an email from another person connected to the club.

It reveals hundreds of thousands of dollars of unapproved third-party agreements, including cash payments, to seven of his star players who had won the premiership the previous season.

The Sunday Telegraph has obtained the secret document that left the 2016 premiers facing a crippling salary cap crisis and $1 million in fines.

It is the first evidence that Flanagan had knowledge of the additional payments to players.

Porn shop king Con Ange was found among the data base of around 20 third party providers.

The Sunday Telegraph can also today reveal the names of the players affected by the scandal — Luke Lewis, James Maloney, Wade Graham, Valentine Holmes, Josh Dugan, Jack Bird and Chris Heighington. Holmes, Maloney, Bird, Lewis and Heighington have since left the club.

The Sharks committed $200,000 to Lewis between 2013 and 2016 in payments not disclosed on his playing contract. Another $80,000 went to Bird.

Some of the money was paid to their managers in cash, in amounts of up to $25,000.

There is no suggestion that any of the players or their managers were aware that the payments contravened salary cap rules.

NRL chief executive Todd Greenberg reveals in a letter to the Sharks that the hidden payments were uncovered by integrity unit investigators from the Sharks’ internet server, which contained the email Flanagan sent to himself while he was the team’s coach.

Flanagan sent himself the email 12 months before the Sharks salary cap rorts were exposed. Otherwise it may not have been detected. Other copies were kept on private email accounts.

Until then the NRL knew only of $75,000 in undisclosed payments that had been self-reported by chief executive Barry Russell.

Cronulla Sharks salaries in 2017.
3196e828676ec9eb327549dfa9f74fe6

Cronulla Sharks salaries in 2018.
a0a3501e0e9ec4697b4a7b1873535f40

Cronulla Sharks salaries in 2019.
b347b279aeec311aee15adb2cddf6ad4

Cronulla Sharks projected salaries in 2020 and 2021.
All up, the NRL investigation identified $993,000 of financial commitments by the club to the players that were not included in contracts registered with the NRL.

The spreadsheet on Flanagan’s email was compiled by a company called Connection 2 Sport.

The managing director, Luke Edmonds, started the company when he resigned from his role at the Sharks as its sponsorship manager. Edmonds has denied any wrongdoing.

The document detailing the salary cap breaches.
The NRL says Connection 2 Sport was established with the knowledge of the Sharks board and executive, yet no action has been taken against their CEO Lyall Gorman, who now works at Manly. Gorman has denied any wrong doing

“Edmonds and Connection 2 Sport were from its inception the primary drivers for the sourcing of third party agreements for the Sharks playing roster,” Greenberg writes in his letter.

“Edmonds would provide hospitality and an ‘inner sanctum’ experience for actual and potential third party agreement providers.”

Under NRL salary cap rules, it is illegal for club officials to facilitate or have any involvement in third-party deals.

The Sharks declined to comment.
———
Outlined, not linking to their trash.

Edit: here’s the link, sorry mods

https://outline.com/https://www.cou...s/news-story/c8eee15ceec8e12f9204eba0bb622a2b
 
Last edited:

Sharkman

Juniors
Messages
1,018
I’m having hard time separating our version of the Broncos Thoroughbred club being such a clusterfg.

Has no journo thought ask anyone at NRL how our failed and illegal attempt to mirror the successful and legal Broncos attempt is different?

I’d genuinely love to know the difference. Is it because Flange was directly involved?
Edmonds has left the club, if it was his business sourcing TPAs, hows that a breach?
So Lyle knew but what’s the issue, CEO of Broncs knows about Thoroughbreds... Bennet started it up back in the day I’m pretty sure and I’d be amazed if he didn’t know what those TPA amounts were per player.
Is it because we never declared the amounts as TPA?

Anyway, as always, rubbish journalism. Click bait headlines with and poorly researched work.

FG all you mofos, News and Fairfax.
 

Weaponhead

Coach
Messages
10,219
I’m having hard time separating our version of the Broncos Thoroughbred club being such a clusterfg.

Has no journo thought ask anyone at NRL how our failed and illegal attempt to mirror the successful and legal Broncos attempt is different?

I’d genuinely love to know the difference. Is it because Flange was directly involved?
Edmonds has left the club, if it was his business sourcing TPAs, hows that a breach?
So Lyle knew but what’s the issue, CEO of Broncs knows about Thoroughbreds... Bennet started it up back in the day I’m pretty sure and I’d be amazed if he didn’t know what those TPA amounts were per player.
Is it because we never declared the amounts as TPA?

Anyway, as always, rubbish journalism. Click bait headlines with and poorly researched work.

FG all you mofos, News and Fairfax.
It's the direct link through the club that was the issue.

In practice is it any different? Ask Andrew Gee if he would hand over the Broncos servers.
 

Generalzod

Immortal
Messages
32,092
Hell I read some where that where so cash strapped every time we play at Shark park we lose money, There are even suggestions that we might be moving some games to Fiji or Tonga... Oh well regardless how much money the Sharks have it seems to me that we are targeted for relocation or termination....
 

shaggs

Coach
Messages
10,831
Hell I read some where that where so cash strapped every time we play at Shark park we lose money, There are even suggestions that we might be moving some games to Fiji or Tonga... Oh well regardless how much money the Sharks have it seems to me that we are targeted for relocation or termination....
Smh

As for the payments
Maloney not here in 2018
Holmes gone 2019/2020

That equals $250,000 that never made it.

Shit plan. Shit management.
 

Card Shark

Immortal
Messages
32,237
The agenda is there for all to see. Keep driving the shark hate. Makes it easier for the NRL when they cut our balls off.

Griffo, it’s not the NRL writing the stories.

Greenberg categorically denied we cheated to win the premiership & we wouldn’t be losing it.

The press need to drag it out now that deBelin has been banned.
 

Card Shark

Immortal
Messages
32,237
It's the direct link through the club that was the issue.

In practice is it any different?

No.

I really can’t see what the problem is if the club arranges it.

3rd party payments are so murky, the rules cause the disadvantaged clubs to cheat.
 

Sharkman

Juniors
Messages
1,018
@Weaponhead that’s the bit I think is unexplained. Is the direct link Flanno and the content of the emails or was it just the numbers?
It’s not unreasonable to think a coach or club rep has a spreadsheet set up detailing TPAs for each year. In order to get that information, you have to speak to who organised the TPA (because the club can’t have arranged it).

The whole issue and how it played out was very sketchy.
 

Frenzy.

Immortal
Messages
48,501
@Weaponhead that’s the bit I think is unexplained. Is the direct link Flanno and the content of the emails or was it just the numbers?
It’s not unreasonable to think a coach or club rep has a spreadsheet set up detailing TPAs for each year. In order to get that information, you have to speak to who organised the TPA (because the club can’t have arranged it).

The whole issue and how it played out was very sketchy.

The article here says Luke Edmonds formed the company AFTER he left as sponsorship manager. I find that dubious to be honest. I won’t be surprised if it was revealed as the direct club link.
 
Top