Honest opinion

[851]

I am a Wests tigers supporter,but I think the sinbinning of Moltzen was way over the top.
What does a bystander think,we let in a try (6points)whilst he was gone.
I thought a penalty at best,maybe i am one eyed,what is the concensus.

 

[Vicious]

Definately not a sin bin offence, but luckily it didn`t matter in the end.

 

[bartman]

Yeah, a bit over the top for so early in the game imo. If it was preventing a near definite try then maybe, and then maybe t here wouldn't be a problem conceding 6 points while he's cooling down in the sheds.

Didn't make a difference to the result though.

 

[Miller was a legend]

That sin bin was stupid. It was in no way worthy of the bin.

 

[Holla if ya hear me]

why not a sin bin..we criticise when they dont use it and whinge when they do use it.it was fair enuff but there have been worse instances than that for the bin

 

[Stranger]

If the ref deemed it was a professional foul then bin was good option.

TBH, i thought it was professional foul if he stripped the ball. IF he stripped the ball. Didn't see the replay.

 

[ozbash]

over the top

 

[Raging Rabbit]

Ridiculous ruling!!

Robinson is a useless merkin.

 

[Holla if ya hear me]

says the rabbits supporter

 

[benoir91]

over the top

 

[Parra]

Not over the top. Should be more of it. I am sick of the niggling crap in this game - if you like that sort of sh*t then watch AFL.

I would prefer it if there was no sin bin, but a punch in the mouth - but that is not going to happen. 10 minutes on the side line will hopefully keep wankers like that out of first grade.

 

[Paul Hewson]

I have to say that I am a Bunnies supporter and I was baffled as to why he was sin-binned. It wasn't a professional foul in any way.

 

[ledzep]

I thought it was a good decision (assuming he stripped the ball)
I think there should be a lot more use of the sin bin and send offs generally though

 

[Knightmare]

Maybe it was a bit harsh, but it was good to see a ref back their own judgement rather than be soft and just put it on report.

 

[Patorick]

Yeah, a bit over the top for so early in the game imo. If it was preventing a near definite try then maybe, and then maybe t here wouldn't be a problem conceding 6 points while he's cooling down in the sheds.

Didn't make a difference to the result though.

Whether or not it was preventing a definite try should not effect whether or not something is a professional foul.

Bit harsh I guess, but I always get frustrated when a bloke makes a break gets tackled and is impeded from getting the quick play the ball he is entitled to.

Hopefully this incident today will deter it somewhat over the next few weeks.

 

[Shorty]

Yeah I personally thought it was absolutely ridiculous.

 

[Penance]

robinson is the worst Ref

 

[Pedro Collins]

That was the worst decision I have seen in rugby league for a long ime. The Tigers didn't lose so it won't get any coverage but that was a joke. I want to know how many games it has been since a sin-bin and I estimate at least 50 if not 100.

8 games a week and I haven't seen a sin-bin for a lot of weeks yet that was. I could find many things such as blatant head highs and strips (which Moltzen didn't even do) yet the ball popped out and this was a sin-bin. The pity is that the tigers didn't lose and this won't recieve coverage.

Jason Robinson HAS to be dropped for that mistake, I know I wont have supporters because the Tigers overcame it but that was ridiculous.