Sure would be.
IMO the second isn't too bad (well not as bad as some people say it is on the SidHe forums) personally I'd give it an 8/10 (10 being the best, 5 being an average game and 1 being poor).
What the gameplay needs to do is fix some of the gameplay mechanics.
*Fullback needs more ball there should be a passing button to pass it to him and make him come up at the line.
*Player Responsiveness needs to be fixed.
*Sprinting needs to be fixed, it has to be either holding down the button or tapping the X not both IMO.
*Palming should have some more effect.
*Forwards running onto the ball should be given more power to fend off or shoulder bump players. Lockyer seems to be tougher than Webcke which makes it totally unrealistic.
*Dummyhalf scooting has too much effect, make it harder to make metres.
*Bomb mechanics should be tinkered with as well as contesting for the high ball
*Stronger goal line defence, more players together in the middle and let them slide more.
*Fix some of the stupid forward pass glitches.
Other features:
*A much more in depth create a player
*A never ending season mode
*Allow the coaches to select their represenative sides
*Players can get involved in off-field dramas and thus lose pay or get suspended
*Keep head to head stats but add a stats list to see who the top try scorer and so on much easier
*Players personality, as I posted awhile ago have certain players have individual talents. For instance give Benji his step to go both ways, some players line up to get the ball more than others or come into support or don't support at all. Just qualities like those to set players apart.
Well I could have more but that's all.
If they had all that then IMO they've created the best sports game IMO.
What would you guys suggest?