How many weeks for Cameron Smith?

[Meth]

I would argue the contact with the head was accidental but the actual act of kicking was not at all. Especially after it was continued on 2-3 times more

At best reckless, at worst intentional

I'm happy enough with that assessment

 

[Blues Riff]

I would be filthy if any of my players copped a suspension over something like that.

One of our players was. Wallace copped a suspension for a similar incident (one kick). Penrith fans were filthy. Smith probably doesn't deserve any time off either, even though his was much worse.

 

[chigurh]

One of our players was. Wallace copped a suspension for a similar incident (one kick). Penrith fans were filthy. Smith probably doesn't deserve any time off either, even though his was much worse.

Wallace was charged with dangerous contact which meant 91 points, so unless he fought it and was found guilty he escaped suspension.

I imagine it will be the same story with Cam Smith.

 

[gUt]

How many weeks did MacDougall get for kicking Toovey in the head in the '97 illegitimate grand final? Something similar seems fair.

It wasn't illegitimate as much as it was reserve grade

 

[macnaz]

Its not what you know, it's what you can prove.

Not hard to prove at all really. He was deliberately kicking his legs knowing full well there was a player there , and his action had every chance of hitting someone ! Anyone kicking out it that crazy fashion would be aware of the possible consequences. Therefore he is guilty of a dangerous act.

 

[macnaz]

Its like throwing a beer glass across a crowded bar and claiming you didnt mean to hit anyone ..it was an accident .

 

[Hutty1986]

The accountant getting suspended at Origin time?

Somehow I think not.

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Its like throwing a beer glass across a crowded bar and claiming you didnt mean to hit anyone ..it was an accident .

Cameron Smith should grow a moustache...

 

[--Storm--]

0 weeks, accident.

 

[macnaz]

Cameron Smith should grow a moustache...

Haha.. total accident , and this guy had know idea he hit someone either until his mate told him later

 

[macnaz]

0 weeks, accident.

No. 0 weeks .. guilty grub protected Storm player .

 

[--Storm--]

No. 0 weeks .. guilty grub protected Storm player .

Protected hahaha now I've heard it all, he missed a GF

 

[IFR33K]

He simply didn't know....

 

[Jason Maher]

Only because his grapple on Thaiday was so blatant the NRL couldn't have possibly ignored it.

 

[OVP]

Not his go ...

p.s. $1000 says he wont get suspended ... Qld would whinge for years.

 

[Canard]

Its like throwing a beer glass across a crowded bar and claiming you didnt mean to hit anyone ..it was an accident .

It would be like standing in the spot that people have thrown bottles at for 100 years, getting hit and then saying "It's your fault"

 

[Canard]

Not his go ...

p.s. $1000 says he wont get suspended ... Qld would whinge for years.

QLD conspiracy!

 

[thorson1987]

Not his go ...

p.s. $1000 says he wont get suspended ... Qld would whinge for years.

And nsw will whinge if he gets off.

Either way people are gonna bitch and moan about it.

 

[Jason Maher]

How about every member of the New South Wales team gets a free kick at Smith's bollocks?

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Not his go ...

p.s. $1000 says he wont get suspended ... Qld would whinge for years.

'Passion'...