What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

How many weeks for Graham

pHyR3

Juniors
Messages
955
[FKN-SIK];10795108;13251 said:
So you're saying what Graham did was a lot worse than what Kaufusi did to Benji a few weeks ago which got 1 week? :lol:

plus the episode with the refs, and you can bet he has priors while i doubt kaufusi had many

3-4 seems reasonable
 

POPEYE

Coach
Messages
11,397
To his credit, the moment after the tackle he was signalling the referees down because he could see Reynolds was hurt. To say he's a goon or puts no thought in is a bit unfair.

Dearie me, all part of the vaudeville . . . I love the bloke
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,523
When going back over the past couple of seasons, it's such a coincedence how may times Graham didn't mean to injure an opposition player

He plays tough , agreed, but I think he follows through a few too many times for them all to be accidental. That coupled with the style that Des has the team playing ( bullyboy tactics), seems to add to his problems of going too far.

When all taken to account, and the volatile nature of the Dogs fan base, it all came together last night, again no coincidence
 

Danish

Referee
Messages
32,016
Jonathan Thurston straight up booted the wolf man in the head a few years back, and while he got charged he didn't miss a week.

Slater has slid in in dozens of players and never missed a game.

Morris stuck a foot out and missed. I can't see why he'd even be charged given the precedent
 

DURRRHURRR

Juniors
Messages
746
[FKN-SIK];10795108;13251 said:
So you're saying what Graham did was a lot worse than what Kaufusi did to Benji a few weeks ago which got 1 week? :lol:

McClean tackle was barely a spear and Snowden shoulder charge was more him bracing for impact than an actual charge. I dont like it but the injury seems impact the suspension
 

HowHigh

Coach
Messages
12,819
He should be dropped as captain and be given a 6 week ban by the NRL.
I like Graham as a player but that just wasn't on the way he behaved after the penalty was called.
 

bileduct

Coach
Messages
17,832
No charge downs aren't outlawed , but the steve price style of charge down where you throw your body at a kickers feet has been outlawed for at least 5 years now.
It's been outlawed for a lot longer than that.

Rambo Ronny Gibbs used to do this shit all the time decades ago.

I think it was because of him that the rule about diving at a kickers legs was brought in.
 

bileduct

Coach
Messages
17,832
As for this incident, as a serious response - do we now have to outlaw a chargedown in case it goes wrong (which is exactly what this is)?
No, just don't make contact with a kickers legs.

Just like don't take a guys head off when you're going in for a tackle.
 

MightyMoo

Juniors
Messages
744
Jonathan Thurston straight up booted the wolf man in the head a few years back, and while he got charged he didn't miss a week.

Slater has slid in in dozens of players and never missed a game.

Morris stuck a foot out and missed. I can't see why he'd even be charged given the precedent

Rule interpretation has changed since 2009. No such thing as 'precedents' any more. Only a 1 punch rule
 

GongPanther

Referee
Messages
28,676
Should get

James Graham 50 weeks.
David Klemmer 20 weeks.
Josh Morris 60 weeks.
Sam Kasiano 30 weeks.

Supporters of all the other teams should have a blanket ban in attending all Dogs home games until fan safety is assured,and life bans are given to those imbeciles in the crowd who were responsible for the bottle throwing.
 

cleary89

Coach
Messages
16,483
Lichaa clearly calls the ref a dog. Been reported in the media. Surely he gets a week or two.
 

cleary89

Coach
Messages
16,483
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...haa-called-referee-a-dog-20150405-1mew10.html

NRL match review committee investigating allegations Canterbury hooker Michael Lichaa called referee a 'dog'

The NRL match review committee will investigate allegations that Canterbury hooker Michael Lichaa called referee Gerard Sutton a "dog" during the controversial Good Friday clash against South Sydney.

The match review committee has placed the entire heated exchanges towards the end of the match under investigation and will listen to multiple referee and broadcast microphones as part of a review of the Canterbury players' emotional tirade at the match officials.

Prop David Klemmer, who was sin-binned for saying "you're f---ed, you're off your face", and skipper James Graham are likely to face contrary conduct charges for the verbal abuse of the officials.

However, Fairfax Media understands several other players could find themselves in hot water, including Lichaa.

Lichaa is heard on the broadcast saying "he tripped over", believed to be referring to South Sydney halfback Adam Reynolds, who was on the ground in agony after Graham made contact with the playmaker while he was attempting a field goal.

The Bulldogs' No.9 then said: "dog", but it is unclear who exactly Lichaa was referring to.

The match review committee is aware of Lichaa's remarks and will examine further audio when it meets on Monday morning.

Meanwhile, the police investigation aimed at identifying the Canterbury fans who threw bottles at match officials last Friday could be hampered by the fact that members were not in their allocated seats.

The authorities, ANZ Stadium and the Canterbury Bulldogs club were hoping to identify the perpetrators by matching up their seat number with their memberships.

However, the wet weather at ANZ Stadium on Friday meant fans were scattered across the grandstand in search of shelter.

Two fans were arrested on the night for throwing projectiles at the referees, with more expected to be identified in the coming days with the potential of being hit with life bans.

The club and police are relying on facial recognition to identify the hooligans who threatened the safety of the NRL match officials.

ANZ Stadium insists it won't increase security measures for Canterbury's game against St George Illawarra next Sunday afternoon, comfortable the necessary procedures are in place.

The Bulldogs face the possibility of losing points over the behaviour of their fans, with the NRL weighing up the possibility of dangling competition points over the supporters to ensure there isn't a repeat.

Eels coach Brad Arthur believes stripping the Bulldogs of competition points wouldn't be the right punishment.

"I seriously don't think they should be," Arthur said. "But that's up to the NRL to make those decisions, it's got nothing to do with me."

The fans erupted after Bulldogs skipper James Graham was penalised for attacking the legs of Adam Reynolds while he was attempting a field goal to take the game into golden point.

Rugby league immortal Andrew Johns insists it was accidental conduct but believes the decision to rule a penalty was the right call.

"I still think it's an accident," Johns said on the Sunday Footy Show. "He's heads down and it's a split second. If he hits the ball and charges it down he's a hero but unfortunately he's missed the ball and hit the leg, but I still think it was an accident."

Former Roosters five-eighth Brad Fittler echoed Johns' sentiment. "It's a penalty every day of the week," Fittler said. "Every single day of the week."
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,523
Like a lot of fans, I and my family are always doubtful about attending Dogs games, the behaviour and attitude of of a small,number of their fans when a decision goes against them is awful. Sitting in the corporate seats, a Dogs fan ran up th stairs at half time, and got in one of the people in my areas face and yelled he would smash him till his head came off, what had he done - nothing was standing up at halftime in the opposition clubs polo shirt

Some of their fans are great, but they do themselves no favours , the biggest common denominator in a lot of poor behaviour is Dogs games and their minority of out of control , passionate section of so called supporters
 

Latest posts

Top