How many weeks for Peachy?

[lockyno1]

7 weeks plus loading if he has that

 

[seanoff]

at least 6, more truthfully about 10. that was terrible.

the ref should also get a holiday. if you aren't going to send people for that. give it away.

 

[lockyno1]

If that wasn't a send off I really have NO IDEA WHAT IS!

 

[Charlie124]

I really have NO IDEA

 

[Usain Bolt]

I'd like to know how Hodges is allowed to elbow people in the face and still get the penalty?

 

[lockyno1]

I'd like to know how Hodges is allowed to elbow people in the face and still get the penalty?

No need to pull that up. Bar the ridiculous non send off that game was reffed extremely well.

 

[Card Shark]

Grade 4, whatever that is worth to him.

Doesn't get much worse than that, considering the whistle had well & truly gone (hence not a grade 5).

Accidents happen but to me, after the whistle signals intent.

In his defence, Beau Scott did similar after the whistle & got SFA.

 

[roofromoz]

Should be graded higher than Bird's but as everyone seems to be forgetting, Bird only got his 8 weeks because of his terrible record for repeat offences, so i doubt Peachy will get as harsh a penalty unless he has priors. If he has a clean record, id say hes looking at 4 to 6 weeks tops, and rightly so.

I believe he is a clean skin. I'm expecting at least 6 weeks for that though. Brain explosion and a half.

 

[ek999]

Grade 4, whatever that is worth to him.

Doesn't get much worse than that, considering the whistle had well & truly gone (hence not a grade 5).

Accidents happen but to me, after the whistle signals intent.

In his defence, Beau Scott did similar after the whistle & got SFA.

725 points so 5 weeks with an early plea (assuming no loading or carryover points). Sounds about right to me

 

[Jason Maher]

Beau Scott should be made Prime Minister for his effort on the world's biggest sook.

 

[Kiwi]

To spear tackle a bloke after the whistle was blown and while he wasn't looking is as malicious as king hitting him and had the potential to do far more damage. I don't care if he is a clean skin, I don't care who he did it to, I don't care if it's not his go or not how he plays, it was a cheap shot dog act and comparable to what happened to Hohia, should be gone for a long f**king time. No grading straight to judicary followed by a 12+ week holiday.

 

[gronkathon]

2. No hands between the legs should keep the category lower and his clean record will help as well

 

[chrisD]

3-4, not as bad as Heigho's, whatever he got.

 

[cleary89]

3-5

 

[Kiwi]

2. No hands between the legs should keep the category lower and his clean record will help as well

after the whistle and on a player not looking should make the no hands between the legs and clean record irrelevant. Intent can not be argued, the intent was there, his reaction after was not one of remorse.

 

[Kiwi]

People are making a mistake comparing this to other spear/lifting tackles, those happen during play, not after play, after the whistle and on a player not looking. Not even comparable.

 

[gronkathon]

Some people are being realistic based on the grading system, the process and his record.

Some people are severely butthurt Broncos fans thinking it is the worst thing to happen on a football field.

I am comfortable with my choice. If he gets suspended longer still doesn't have any effect on my crap team

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

Some people are being realistic based on the grading system, the process and his record.

Some people are severely butthurt Broncos fans thinking it is the worst thing to happen on a football field.

I am comfortable with my choice. If he gets suspended longer still doesn't have any effect on my crap team

What the f**k have we got to be butthurt about? we won :lol:

 

[Kiwi]

Some people are being realistic based on the grading system, the process and his record.

Some people are severely butthurt Broncos fans thinking it is the worst thing to happen on a football field.

I am comfortable with my choice. If he gets suspended longer still doesn't have any effect on my crap team

If Blair did it to Peachey the cries of outrage and cries for a much longer suspension than the ones being suggested here would be deafening. You don't get butt hurt sitting in 1st place.

 

[2010Dragons]

He should have been sent off...plus 8 weeks suspension.